4 ms·
And this is why we have a royal family. I actually felt quite stirred reading that speech. I can't imagine David Cameron or Ed Milliband managing that. I think
by gadders 13y ago
And this is why we have a royal family. I actually felt quite stirred reading that speech. I can't imagine David Cameron or Ed Milliband managing that. I think Churchill was an outlier.
- air 13y agoIt was not written by the queen. "The speech, devised by Whitehall officials at one of the most fraught Cold War periods..."
- gadders 13y agoYeah, but it matters who says it, right? Otherwise you could get a newsreader to deliver it.
- rooshdi 13y agoReading doesn't require royalty. Peasants can too.
- air 13y agoIt does feel a bit funny, that a piece of text she did not write, present, or probably even read, is given as a reason to have her as a monarch. Seems like you would probably get on just fine with a fabricated character played by an actress, who is charismatic enough. Say, "Big Sister"
- prawn 13y agoFirst sentence there is superb. Wish I could up vote more than once. Really quite insightful.
- gadders 13y agoOr we could do what Americans do and venerate a piece of cloth? I'm not having a pop at Americans, but it may make sense to view the queen as a symbol in the same way that the flag is for Americans. It's just that our symbol happens to be a person. Also, the Queen ties us back to stuff like Henry V and Agincourt etc.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI see no reason to venerate either flags or royalty. Frankly I find nationalism toe-curlingly embarrassing at best. If I am feeling particularly generous I tend to agree with Samuel Johnson that "Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel." The rest of the time I am more aligned with Ambrose Bierce's version from The Devil's Dictionary. “Patriotism, n. Combustible rubbish ready to the torch of any one ambitious to illuminate his name. In Dr. Johnson's famous dictionary patriotism is defined as the last resort of a scoundrel. With all due respect to an enlightened but inferior lexicographer I beg to submit it is the first.”
- gadders 13y agoWell when some patriotic/nationalistic people decide to invade the particular piece of ground you are inhabiting at the time, be sure to tell them you have opted out.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoNot how it works. Defending against expansionist nationalists is not the same thing as accepting the philosophy of nationalism.
- tonyblundell 13y agoThe Queen is more than just an actor. Think of how you'd hire a lawyer to speak for you if you had to appear in court. It is necessary to hire a trained expert in collating and co-ordinating information from the relevant sources and communicating in that particular forum. It doesn't detract from the meaning or sentiment.
- drakeandrews 13y agoOf course not. But our politicians tend to have all the charisma of a pile of gravel, as opposed to our royals who are usually pretty decent orators.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI dunno, the Queen just sounds bored shitless whenever she is required to speak in public. As for her husband, his public outbursts of genteel bigotry are more lavatory than oratory.
- patio11 13y agoIf you enjoy zombie science fiction, there is a scene in World War Z (the book, not the atrocious movie of the same name) which you would appreciate. Blink and you'll miss it, but the author distills some of the best parts of the British national character into two sentences which nearly made me (an American) weep for the beauty of it. [Edit: Strong general recommendation for that book, by the way. If it were not in a low-status genre, parts of it would be taught in high schools.]
- gadders 13y agoOh man. I need to go back and find my copy now... :-)
- jychang 13y agoWhat was it? I don't exactly have a copy of the book on hand...
- patio11 13y agoThe government of the UK retreats above Hadrian's Wall after civil order in the country collapses in the wake of the zombie pandemic. The Queen refuses to abandon her people and declines evacuation, makes all royal property throughout the commonwealth a refuge by royal decree for any who can successfully reach and hold it, and with her loyal retainers turns Buckingham Palace into a sanctuary (and beacon of hope) in zombie-overrun London. This later proves to be crucial to the UK as Buckingham Palace happens to be on top of substantial petroleum reserves, which wartime exigencies require tapping. That's what happens, anyhow. Read the book, Max Brooks does it a lot better than I just did from a three year old memory. There is also a very brief meditation by the character being interviewed by the frame narrator to the effect that the monarch is the custodian of the soul of Britain in a way that the Yanks just can't understand. Literary criticism: I would have struck that sentence because the book shows that powerfully and it is weaker for then saying the moral explicitly.
- gadders 13y ago"...the monarch is the custodian of the soul of the Britain." Excellent way of putting it. That is pretty much what she (or he) is.
- seclorum 13y agoI think that the dependency of the English people on their Matriarch for comfort and compassion is a sign of ill-health, personally, as a society. I find it repugnant that in a time of dire circumstances, the dependency on cult figures is still a resolute component of the human social experience. Until we do away with such crutches, we'll always have the very threat of war upon us ..
- xradionut 13y agoWe are much better off in the State with our well working democratic republic based on a advanced enlighten populous!
- tonyblundell 13y agoI'd be interested to hear more on this. At the minute I'm not sure what dire circumstances you mean, or how having a leader implies a threat of war. It seems like a lot of what you wrote could be applied to any leader of any nation. I went through a vehement anti-monarchy phase when I was younger, since then I'm starting to appreciate the idea of a head of state who isn't a career politician that campaigned or even bought their way into office.
- seclorum 13y agoThe human proclivity towards cult behaviour is what I'm talking about. The UK Royals have no real function other than to promote the English personality, as a cultural artifact, to their subjects. In that regard, it functions as a cult, one of the most effective in the world, for promulgating collective reality. This, after all, is how wars get started. Edit: the dire circumstances being, of course, WW3 - the subject of the Queens' speech.
- arethuza 13y agoI'd prefer that we had a ceremonial President like Germany, Ireland or Israel. Having said that, I prefer having the Royals to an elected non-ceremonial Head of State. Having the Head of State separate from the head of the executive branch of government seems like a good idea to me.
- 13y ago