3 ms·
> In any given instant, the arrow has to appear motionless. If it wasn't motionless, there would be two instants, one in which the arrow was at one position and
by ars 13y ago
> In any given instant, the arrow has to appear motionless. If it wasn't motionless, there would be two instants, one in which the arrow was at one position and one in which the arrow was in another position.
I don't follow. Why can't the arrow be in both places at the same time? With the probability of one vs the other dependent on the velocity and the size of the time slice.
- rosser 13y agoRemember, the arrow is one of Zeno's paradoxes. He's not describing reality; he's trying to impose a conceptual-only understanding of reality on the thing, itself, and ending up in a logically impossible situation. His description of the arrow's motion, or the runner's traveling half the distance to the finish line, and then half the remaining distance, and then half the distance left after that, and so on, and thus never actually finishing, are exactly that: descriptive, not prescriptive.