13 ms·
The Quantum Zeno Effect actually does stop the world
- damian2000 13y agoMore info here for those interested http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/47252/simple-explanation-of-quantum-zeno-effect http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/47252/simple-expl...
- molmalo 13y agoThe picture in the article fits perfectly, not only because of Neo stopping time, but because, more importantly, at least to me, this looks like if the Universe has its own Garbage Collector. Which could mean that we are living a simulated reality [1], something like the Matrix! [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulated_reality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simulated_reality
- k__ 13y agoI think so, too. We have gaps in reality, the planck length, planck time etc. Also, we have Gödel's incompleteness theorems, which tells us about the gaps in theories we can't fill.
- monjaro 13y agoYou are assuming more about the Planck units than is currently known. Directly from wikipedia: "There is currently no directly proven physical significance of the Planck length; it is, however, a topic of research."
- krichman 13y agoPlanck length and time are curious; but incompleteness is a mathematical construct, so it's true for all universes, simulated or not.
- atondwal 13y ago> Gödel's incompleteness theorems, which tells us about the gaps in theories we can't fill That's mathematical, not physical, so that would mean that in the parent universe somehow _something else constitutes a formal language_, which requires changing what it means to be a subset, which requires changing set theory. So if GITs are invalid in the parent universe, it means, roughly either that you can compare something to itself, and find that it contains different things that itself (absurd), or that list comprehensions are logically impossible (not as obviously absurd, but still "whaaa?").
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ars 13y ago> In any given instant, the arrow has to appear motionless. If it wasn't motionless, there would be two instants, one in which the arrow was at one position and one in which the arrow was in another position. I don't follow. Why can't the arrow be in both places at the same time? With the probability of one vs the other dependent on the velocity and the size of the time slice.
- rosser 13y agoRemember, the arrow is one of Zeno's paradoxes. He's not describing reality; he's trying to impose a conceptual-only understanding of reality on the thing, itself, and ending up in a logically impossible situation. His description of the arrow's motion, or the runner's traveling half the distance to the finish line, and then half the remaining distance, and then half the distance left after that, and so on, and thus never actually finishing, are exactly that: descriptive, not prescriptive.
- ars 13y ago> Every time you check on it, it will revert to its "original" measured state, and the clock will start over. This makes me uneasy - I feel like there is a violation of thermodynamic laws in there somewhere. Decay is not the only thing that is probabilistic, tunneling is too, and if you can manipulate things so it's more like to go in one direction vs the other, you can reverse entropy.
- fauigerzigerk 13y agoThat sounds nice. Unfortunately, knowing nearly nothing about any of this, I'm having a hard time imagining what it means to "check on" an atom and how that could influence its state. Sometimes it seems to me that every day words become mere metaphors when applied to physics.
- Cogito 13y agoThey use the term 'observe', which typically means to shoot photons or electrons at it. A laser is a common option. This is a pretty reasonable use of the term, as when most people observe anything it's typically by capturing photons that previously bounced off it.
- KenoFischer 13y agoThe problem with Quantum Physics (well, physics in general, but in classical physics it's mostly ignored) is that in order to make a measurement, you need to interact with the system thus changing it's state. You might for example measure perturbations in an electric field, but by applying the electric field you influenced the state of the system. This is also an important part of say the uncertainty principle. One way to think about why you can't measure position and momentum simultaneously to infinite accuracy is that perfect measurement of one would require shooting it with photons of zero momentum, while perfect measurement of the other would require shooting it with photons of infinite momentum. The real fun comes in when you leave a system alone for a while because then everything becomes probabilistic.
- jasimq 13y agoSaying that this effect "stops the world" doesn't seem right to me. It just "appears" to have stopped only for the observer, who observes the world at very very small intervals.
- zaptheimpaler 13y agoI have never understood why Zeno's paradoxes are considered so profound. Consider what an instant of time is. Is it a non-zero chunk of time smaller than any other finite chunk of time? In this case, we are defining an instant as an infinitesimal chunk of time. If we posit that such a thing exists, then why can't an infinitesimal distance (which the arrow travels in that time) exist? The other option is to define an instant of time as no time at all. Not the smallest, simply zero. Saying that since you cannot move a non-zero distance in zero time is valid. However, a chunk of time is not composed of an infinite series of zero time chunks, just like 0.00000...1 is not equal to 0 + 0 + 0... There is a gap between zero and infinitesimal that cannot be bridged by zeros alone.
- jamesrcole 13y ago> Consider what an instant of time is. Is it a non-zero chunk of time smaller than any other finite chunk of time? Here's how I think of Zeno's paradox: it is saying that if time/space are continuous then there are no such things as finite chunks of them, therefore they must be discrete.
- zaptheimpaler 13y agoThats a nice way to look at it - Zeno's paradoxes are proofs by contradiction that time/space are discontinuous!
- monjaro 13y agoThat's not true though. Zeno's paradoxes are all pretty easy to resolve using first-year calculus. They certainly don't prove that time or space is discontinuous.
- jamesrcole 13y agoCalculus doesn't resolve the paradox. It's just a tool, and it doesn't involve any literal division of anything into infinities. You're making a map vs. territory mistake. [edit] i can't reply to monjaro's comment, so I'll put my reply here: does calculus prove that there are actually an infinite number of positions between any two positions?
- asperous 13y agoA mathematician and an engineer agreed to take part in an experiment. They were both placed in a room and at the other end was a beautiful naked woman on a bed. The experimenter said every 30 seconds they would be allowed to travel half the distance between themselves and the woman. The mathematician said "this is pointless" and stormed off". The engineer agreed to go ahead with the experiment anyway. The mathematician exclaimed on his way out "don't you see, you'll never actually reach her?". To which the engineer replied, "so what? Pretty soon I'll be close enough for all practical purposes!".
- biggfoot 13y agoGood Sir! That's the fuckin' funniest thing I've read in a while.
- Jach 13y agoThat's pretty funny, but the mathematician must be one who lived before the invention of calculus, which resolves such paradoxes. (With either infinitesimals or limits.)
- ajuc 13y agoI think mathemathician considered getting there after inf * 30 seconds to be "never". The important difference between this and Zeno paradox is - in Zeno paradox time is also divided.
- phaemon 13y agoNot in this case. In Zeno's paradox, as the distance halves, so too does the time. In this case, the time for each halving is constant at 30 seconds. This means the mathematician is right and theoretically they'll never reach the woman (except practically, as pointed out).
- Jach 13y agoGood point, I guess I can see in this case the mathematician might realize that while he can cross the full distance easily enough with infinite time, he might not want to wait around for infinite time...
- monjaro 13y agoThis article is very low quality. The account of Zeno's paradox is wrong on pretty much every count, which makes it hard to trust anything else the article claims.
- czr80 13y agoSeems okay to me - what precisely do you think they got wrong?
- monjaro 13y ago"He did this by setting up a series of paradoxes that showed, among other things, that half a given span of time is equal to twice that given span of time, that time and space are neither continuous nor discrete, and that nothing ever moves. Ever." None of those things are true. One minute isn't equal to four minutes, Zeno didn't prove anything about time and space being neither continuous nor discrete, and things clearly do move.
- czr80 13y agoThe only correction I'd make to their sentence is change "showed" to "appeared to show". And his paradoxes did appear to show all those things. Of course empirically you (and the ancient Greeks) could see that they must be wrong - the challenge was to find the logical flaw in his arguments. Finding that took a very long time.
- monjaro 13y agoPerhaps I'm being overly pedantic, but in my mind "showed" and "appeared to show" mean very different things.
- hemmer 13y agoThe Ask A Mathematician page linked is quite a bit better. http://www.askamathematician.com/2012/03/q-is-the-quantum-zeno-effect-a-real-thing/ http://www.askamathematician.com/2012/03/q-is-the-quantum-ze...
- ajuc 13y agoI don't know if I understand it correctly. If space and time is discrete, and movement is deterministic - Zeno paradox is a paradox - object moving at speed 1 minimal division of space (MDS) per 2 minimal divisions of time (MDT) isn't at any valid point of space after 1 minimal division of time which is paradoxical. Calculus solved this, but it has assumption that space and time is continuous. Now we have experiments that shows us it's not true, so probably the assumption about determinism isn't true. So for example object moving 1 MDS per 2 MDT "really" moves 1 MDT per 1 MDT with probability 0.5. Am I getting this right?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gus_massa 13y agoThe problem with this explanation is that checking more often the state of the quantum state makes it decay more "slowly" it doesn't stop it totally. > ... Check on it after three seconds, and it probably will have decayed. But, Misra and Sudarshan argue, check on it three times in one second intervals, and it will most likely not have decayed. ... Let's invent numbers for an example, with 3->5. It you check a system after 5 seconds the probability that it has not yet decayed "is" 1-0.05 . It you check a system five times in the 5 seconds interval the probability that it has not yet decayed "is" (1-0.002)^5=~1-0.01 . The measurements makes the decay probability smaller, but it's not reduced to 0 as the article try to induce, to make it similar to the Zeno paradox. The important point is that at the quantum level every measurement changes the system [1]. So the result of the experiment is affected by the measurements. (At the classical level, some measurements are negligible, and it's safe to ignore them.) [1] of an operator that doesn't commute with the Hamiltonian of the system
- chrischen 13y agoWhat I don't get is wouldn't you see the same effects in a classical mechanical wave: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Polarizacio.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Polarizacio.jpg ?