4 ms·
Can you enlighten me on the truth of what was happening there? (Serious request) Your write-up of Alexander is spot on. He has been referred to both the most p
by samstave 13y ago
Can you enlighten me on the truth of what was happening there? (Serious request)
Your write-up of Alexander is spot on. He has been referred to both the most powerful and the most feared man in the world.
- tptacek 13y agoI have no idea why anyone outside of the DoD would fear him. Again, the truth is simple: it was a press op. The event was corporate enough that nobody was going to throw pies at him, but just countercultural enough that he could be assured that someone would make him look better by heckling.
- samstave 13y ago>"I have no idea why anyone outside of the DoD would fear him." It was said, which is basically confirmed with this latest revelation, that he has all the information on everyone and can blackmail anyone.... I am trying to recall where I heard that though, originally.
- tptacek 13y agoI don't think anyone as savvy and successful as Keith Alexander wants to bake J. Edgar Hoover's image into their legacy.
- jlgreco 13y agoMany people consider legacies to be overrated. Reputation while still alive and kicking is something that concerns just about everybody though.
- temphn 13y agohttp://jontaplin.com/2008/03/11/eliot-spitzer-the-nsa/ http://jontaplin.com/2008/03/11/eliot-spitzer-the-nsa/ "I’ve been tough on Spitzer, but we can’t forget that the reason he got in trouble was because of the new NSA domestic surveillance apparatus that was so brilliantly depicted in the Wall Street Journal yesterday. Here’s the Lede. Five years ago, Congress killed an experimental Pentagon anti-terrorism program meant to vacuum up electronic data about people in the U.S. to search for suspicious patterns. Opponents called it too broad an intrusion on Americans’ privacy, even after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks. But the data-sifting effort didn’t disappear. The National Security Agency, once confined to foreign surveillance, has been building essentially the same system. Spitzer was what the data-mining experts at the NSA call a PEP–a politically exposed person. Banks now monitor PEP’s money wiring activities figuring they are classic targets of blackmail or bribery. Spitzer got caught in the data mining screen. I know people will probably say that even Mukasey had to sign off on an investigation as explosive as this. Spitzer was a self-detructive idiot, but at the end of the day, we have to realize that nobody has any privacy anymore."
- sneak 13y agoI wrote something about how ubiquitous surveillance can be used to blackmail anyone about a month ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5974734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5974734
- umsm 13y agoFearing someone for organizational reasons is different than the fear I believe he is referring to. People may fear him due to the power he holds on changing people's lives with the information he controls and has access to.
- griffordson 13y agoAnd his detractors look like a bunch of OWS hooligans even if only subconsciously. I haven't actually seen the Black Hat talk yet, but I can imagine the audience does not compare favorably to another recent PR event: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fawN4OZEt-Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fawN4OZEt-Y This kind of thing helps build up the conscious and unconscious associations in the minds of many that favor the NSA a great deal.
- tptacek 13y agoThe audience for this event is infosec professionals wearing t-shirts, for whatever that's worth to you. Demographically pretty compatible with Reddit, or at least the subset of Redditors with top-quartile (for IT) incomes. To the extent that this audience has any engagement with public policy, that engagement is likely to take a Ron Paul-ish flavor.
- griffordson 13y agoSorry, my comment wasn't very clear. I was comparing the behavior of the two audiences more than appearance or socioeconomic status or anything else. When the video comes out, people are likely to be reminded of the people doing Mic Checks at board meetings etc. And for many, that sort of thing is just rude and out of bounds. Notice how he wore his uniform this year instead of something more casual like he did at last year's Def Con. I agree, this was very carefully orchestrated to help discredit his detractors.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoThat's not the BlackHat audience that I've seen for many years now. It's basically RSA these days. I think that demographic exists at BH as a vocal minority. When you're actually on the floor, it's difficult to actually find anybody you're thinking of. Don't forget that attendance is over 8,000 lately, IIRC.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm not going to say the conference isn't vendor-y and commercial; it is definitely that, and more so than it started. But it's nothing resembling RSA. Also: Defcon is nothing like what it was in the 90's; it's had a trajectory reminiscent of Burning Man's.