6 ms·
You can be completely correct and still be a crackpot. What we need is strict limitations on what can and should be collected, and how it's used, plus better m
by astrodust 13y ago
You can be completely correct and still be a crackpot.
What we need is strict limitations on what can and should be collected, and how it's used, plus better methods of securing what's being exchanged. For example, sending email as plain-text, leaving it on the server as plain-text, maybe that's a bad idea.
The NSA isn't necessarily the only reason you'd do this. Foreign governments are going to take an interest in this, too, and it's only a matter of time before someone gets access the data the NSA is hoarding. No program of this scale is ever 100% secure.
- blueprint 13y ago> You can be completely correct and still be a crackpot. This is very important. What do you mean by "crackpot"?
- Karunamon 13y agoIt's not feasible for the average person to restrict their lives to the point that RMS does and advocates for. * Reading the web via email only * Using completely free software and hardware (which as far as I can tell, limits you to a very small subset of Linux on a single Chinese-made netbook) * Not carrying a cellphone * Not using any social networks. Stallman's principled stand is admirable, but untenable for most. I need to violate every single one of these tenets in an average day at work. And that's before we even enter the realm of entertainment, which is even worse as far as the FSF's definition of freedom goes.
- jacquesm 13y agoPrincipled != crackpot. Crackpot is an insult intended for the feeble minded and is used to reduce any opinions a person might hold on a subject as reject-able out of hand. Over unity energy generation from the vacuum is rightly labeled as 'crackpot' imo, Stallman's position, while extreme should (again, imo) not be labeled as such.
- Karunamon 13y agoWhere Stallman breaks from admirable principle and dives into untenable crackpottery, IMO, is where he calls proprietary software evil.
- jacquesm 13y agoCrackpot => unsupported by evidence. Calling proprietary software evil is an opinion, and there are plenty of examples of evidence that proprietary software was created in ways that one could label as evil. Give it a while and there might be some revelation which will cause lots of people to go 'oh, that Stallman was such a visionary, calling proprietary software evil'. Now on this particular aspect of Stallman's reasoning I find him hard to follow because that would mean a whole class of something is bad whereas I believe it should only apply to instances on a case-by-case basis. But I'm going to hedge my bets here and sit it out for the next decade or two (assuming I have that much time remaining) to see if he might not be on to something again that is still hard to see from where we are standing right now. One way in which this could play out is that in order to avoid certain societal fates is to have nothing but open source for certain classes of application (for instance, voting computers, software in use by the government in general or software that is used to power network infrastructure). Don't be too quick to judge, Stallman has been right more often than I'm comfortable with on some of his most 'extreme' views.
- astrodust 13y agoI've never heard Stallman be right about anything that wasn't blindingly obvious to anyone who was an open-minded observer of the same things at the same time. He's not the only one that's been crowing about electronic surveillance. Ever since things like Carnivore (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnivore_(software) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnivore_(software)) were uncovered in the 1990s, it's been obvious that there's a lot going on we will never be fully informed about, that the internet is no longer a safe playground devoid of malevolent actors. Mailing lists and USENET groups at the same period of time were constantly aflame with these sorts of issues. If you can cite an occasion where Stallman has had a unique insight into the situation, I'd be surprised. Stallman, for all his posturing and relentless drum beating, which is at least admirable from the point of dedication, is still no Alan Kay, Marvin Minsky, Marshall McLuhan or Raymond Kurzweil.
- pknight 13y ago> Over unity energy generation from the vacuum is rightly labeled as 'crackpot' imo Then it seems that crackpottery is a term that may be removed in retrospect. I'm sure at some point in the future someone will crack the energy from the vacuum riddle, who knows.
- tedks 13y ago* RMS reads the web via email because he's traveling virtually all the time and rarely has Internet access. A batch-based system makes more sense for him. This isn't an ethical stance, and the fact you include it hits your credibility severely. * The FSF uses computers other than Yeeloongs. The FSF also doesn't really care about free hardware. The Yeeloong has chips with non-free firmware burnt in, and the FSF doesn't care because that isn't software. It's the Free SOFTWARE Foundation, after all. * Stallman is on a few social networks, notably identica @rms@identi.ca (possibly now defunct). He probably has a GNU Social endpoint. I think you're conflating Stallman's willingness to be uncompromising in his own lifestyle with his calls for reform. Stallman is fairly intelligent and understands that not everyone can live like he does, but I suppose he feels the need to answer the question of "what should you do in the present beyond push for reform." I also don't know what "entertainment" you're talking about. The FSF is against proprietary video game engines, but their mission pertains to software, not music/movies/etc.. They campaign against DRM because DRM requires non-free software to enforce.
- anigbrowl 13y agoRMS reads the web via email because he's traveling virtually all the time and rarely has Internet access Surely you can't expect people to take this argument seriously. It's easy to get internet access on the go in much of the world already.
- tedks 13y agoRMS emails in restaurants, cars, trains, etc., in Europe and the United States but also frequently in SE Asia and South America. There are pictures of him responding to email in the mountains in Nepal. It's easy to get Internet access on the go in most of the places I've been to, but I've been to a tiny fraction of the places RMS has been to.
- anigbrowl 13y agoI didn't say one should never use offline mail. I'm just disputing that it's a sensible default, rather than a backup.
- astrodust 13y agoAn example of a crackpot is Glenn Beck, that is, someone who is drawing incorrect, incoherent conclusions from the facts they observe. Suggesting that people abandon social networks, never own cellular phones, avoid using the web almost entirely, these are extreme positions. What makes them crazy is when he's an advocate that everyone should follow these edicts. Surely it's some kind of "geek social fallacy" that's being applied here. Stallman has come up with what he perceives as the optimal strategy and anyone who diverges from this is doing it incorrectly, just as how free, open-source software is the only kind of software that's acceptable, and everything else is "evil".
- kudu 13y agoI think the free access to the data once it's mined is worse than the collection. Such access should require a warrant, if not a wiretap order, not a justification one-liner.
- danenania 13y ago"You can be completely correct and still be a crackpot." Not really. At that point, you are just using the term as an ad hominem in a childish attempt to ward off cognitive dissonance. You don't win an argument by calling the other guy a weirdo.
- astrodust 13y agoHis observations are correct, but his conclusions are incorrect, just as people like Glenn Beck start out with facts and end up with paranoid delusions and fantasies. I think Stallman's observations are valid, but his method of dealing with the implications of those observations are impractical, if not completely wrong.
- lazyjones 13y agoWhen you are done attacking Stallman with a false analogy, would you care to name a few of his invalid conclusions? More specifically, what is so impractical or "completely wrong" about not using smartphones?
- astrodust 13y agoHe's not opposed to smartphones, he's opposed to cellular phones as these can serve as a tracking beacon, following your movements. Given that the cellular providers are capturing and archiving location data, this is fact, his conclusion is we should avoid using these sorts of phones completely. Why? The reasoning here is a awfully thin, but has something to do with "being tracked = bad" and then goes into crazy territory from there. It's the same thing with credit and debit cards. They can be tracked, therefore bad, therefore nobody should use them. If he's concerned about remaining invisible, then this must be applied rigorously across all aspects of his life. Does he wear dazzle face-paint or glasses with bright IR LEDs on them so that CCTV cameras can't pick him up? Does he only use methods of travel that require no identification? If the FBI wanted to retrace Stallman's activity on any given day, it'd take hours at most to piece it together. The sign that someone's a crackpot is in how inconsistent they are in applying what they've concluded. It means they're missing something important. For example, there are people that have a genuine need for absolute secrecy, that need to remain invisible, yet they still use cellular phones, email, and social networks. They're aware of the same risks as Stallman, but they take precautions instead of avoiding them completely. It's notable that Osama Bin Ladin was taken down because he'd gone to such great lengths to avoid being tracked that he stood out as an anomaly, an approach that proved to be self-defeating. He had this large house, but a paranoia about electronic snooping so severe that he had no internet connection, and that alone made that house highly suspicious. If you're that affluent, you have an internet connection, even if you barely use it. Everything Stallman advocates to avoid detection just makes him an even bigger target.
- laxatives 13y agoYou make crackpot sound more like a personality trait than a status.