3 ms·
The widespread availability of mass produced books should have taken teachers out of the lecturing business. I'm not sure if it's true that lecturing started be
by ZeroGravitas 13y ago
The widespread availability of mass produced books should have taken teachers out of the lecturing business. I'm not sure if it's true that lecturing started because books were so expensive that one person read out the one chained to the lectern and everyone made their own copies, but it feels about right. It certainly makes much more sense than the modern spectacle of someone reading bad powerpoint slides badly. But books didn't supplant lecturers, nor did radio, television, VHS video tapes, computer aided-learning, nor the internet.
Yet they should have. Ask anyone who actually wants to learn stuff and you'll find they, naturally, use all these tools and reserve the precious time they spend with an actual expert to mentoring, hands-on skills, subjective evaluation, asking clarifying questions etc. Imagine how stupid you'd feel to hire a world class expert in something and get them to read you a summary of a chapter of their book.
But in Higher Education, having someone, who doesn't really want to teach, has no real aptitude for it and who probably isn't hired, paid or promoted on the basis of how good they are at it, stand in front of a large room of students is basically their equivalent of Homeopathy. A logically preposterous notion, contradicted by all available evidence of efficacy, that mind-bogglingly survives into the 21st century.
No matter how bad this stuff is, and any bit of software being sold to higher education is basically terrible for much the same reasons that nearly all enterprise software sucks, it can't really be any worse than the status quo.