10 ms·
The problem is that a single upvote-downvote axis has to capture two different, sometimes orthogonal, judgments I would like to see a HN-like site with a 2 par
by stcredzero 18y ago
The problem is that a single upvote-downvote axis has to capture two different, sometimes orthogonal, judgments
I would like to see a HN-like site with a 2 part Karma system.
It would appear as three numbers A and S:N where A = Agree, S = Signal and N = Noise. S:N would not really be a ratio, and the Karma calculated from the three numbers could be any function, and wouldn't necessarily just consider S:N as a ratio.
But voting would effectively be a 4-choice radio box, so you could only pick one of the 4.
- Agree (+A +S)
- Disagree (-A +S)
- Signal (+S)
- Noise (+N)
Agree/Disagree will move the Agree number up or down and also add a point on the Signal number. Signal will up S. Noise will up N.
I suspect that those who try to game this system and censor comments by voting Noise as opposed to Signal will get overwhelmed by the Agree/Disagree voting on Signal.
I also suspect that Signal could just add to Karma, and Noise could just subtract from it. This might be able to exhibit the same dynamics as up/down voting on HN.
Another idea is to put the Noise vote button away from the up/down voting arrows and put it next to "Flag". The Signal control should still be next to Agree/Disagree, however. (Maybe a little star or sunburst? Wait, I know, a Sine Curve! Noise could have a square wave icon next to it.)
I proposed this before on HN, but I can't find it with SearchYC.
- gojomo 18y agoSignal/noise is another good way to express the 'valuable' axis -- terms with a long history in net discussions. I would still like to be able to agree/disagree without giving a 'signal'/karma boost. A comment might be true, but trivial/superfluous/repetitive -- that's an agree-but-no-signal. (In the case of snark or offtopic trolling, I might even say I agree-but-that's-noise.) Similarly, something that's both a rule-transgression (noise) and egregiously wrong (such as dangerous misinformation) should get disagee-and-noise.
- stcredzero 18y agoNoise voting should take precedence over agree voting. Perhaps an even better idea would be to not have the Agree/Disagree voting add directly to signal, but for the score to have some affect on Karma and comment visibility through some function. Also, this scheme might be to your liking: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=613520 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=613520