3 ms·
I work in an open-plan office and none of the stuff in this article rings true. The office is open-plan for everyone, from the lowliest intern to the CEO. Desks
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
I work in an open-plan office and none of the stuff in this article rings true. The office is open-plan for everyone, from the lowliest intern to the CEO. Desks are not categorized by rank - the new CTO occupies the desk formerly held by a 3 day/week freelancer. A few people are stuck in marginally smaller desks due to a space crunch, but apart from that all the desks have the same model #.
As for the risk of my boss sneaking up on me while I'm looking at baby elephants on /r/aww, I'm sure it's happened since I make no attempt to hide it. It's a complete non-event.
The lack of outward signs of power is actually confusing. A person who sits in the vicinity of accounting recently came over and started asking for progress reports from a developer. It took about a week before that developer's manager informed him that the "accountant" was actually the CEO.
Don't get me wrong - I can make criticisms of open office plans, mainly about the distractions and the ease with which one can be interrupted. But the pseudo-marxist critique of power dynamics embedded in this article doesn't ring true for me.
- michaelochurch 13y agoThere are still power dynamics in an open-plan-for-everyone arrangement. The CEO may sit in open view, but: 1. He can leave any time he wants for a cafe, a conference room, or even take a drive and go home for the day. Open plan isn't horrible for people who can escape it any time they wish. It's the peons who are expected to be there 8 hours per day-- the ones that people will say shit about if they spend an hour or two (no matter how productive) away from the desk-- who are going to get sick. 2. He can do whatever the fuck he wants. If he wants to spend the whole day playing video games, he can. He has nothing to fear from other people seeing his daily activities. If he has stinky farts, the rest of the office will start eating beans and cheese to match the stink of his flatus.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoHe can leave any time he wants for a cafe, a conference room, or even take a drive and go home for the day...If he wants to spend the whole day playing video games, he can. Why do you think a developer can't do these things? I don't disagree that there are power dynamics and office politics. They are just orthogonal to the seating arrangement. I've occasionally wondered if it might be better if there were outward signs of power. At the very least, it would give us apolitical developers a visual clue that ignoring or talking down to person X might be something to avoid.