5 ms·
>> I have a right to track how people use my site. But you don't have a right to say what runs on my computer, or make it tell you what I'm doing. This is wher
by Nursie 13y ago
>> I have a right to track how people use my site.
But you don't have a right to say what runs on my computer, or make it tell you what I'm doing. This is where our perceived rights collide.
>> once you've made that choice you are within my domain, under my roof, living by my rules.
No, my computer, my browser, my roof, my rules.
>> People get way too offended by analytics tracking when it's there for their benefit.
No, people get offended when you try to turn their computer into a device that spies on them. And we get more offended that this sort of stuff happens without most people even being aware its going on. They may or may not object to it, but right now they don't even know.
And it's so lovely of you to have made the decision for me that it's to my benefit, so I don't have to worry about pesky things like privacy concerns, or having control over my own computing.
>> Do Not Track is snake oil for the conscientious objector.
This is about the only thing we agree on. It's pointless and it was never going to achieve anything.
- toble 13y ago> No, my computer, my browser, my roof, my rules. I think of websites like private properties. You are given conditional access on the assumption that you can behave (T&C / AUP), otherwise it's like trespassing. So, I don't think that people should expect excessive rights of freedom that they might have on their own property or even in public. It's a balancing act.
- Nursie 13y agoThat's really not how I think, nor does it really reflect reality, IMHO. They are on my property, it's all rendered and running in my browser on my device. All that's happened is I've requested some data from the server and they've given it to me, from then on how I display it and what gets run is entirely up to me. If we want to attach terms and conditions to it (i.e. to use this site you must accept analytics/tracking/advertising) then lets make a framework to automate this stuff. I'm perfectly happy for my browser to say, up-front, that it won't be displaying graphical ads and it won't be running any known trackers or analytic suites, it won't be providing you any location data, nor will it be loading any social media buttons or widgets. You can then decide if you want to give me your data. That would be fine. But I'm not buying into some idea of an implied social contract to let website owners do what the hell they want with my device.
- stingraycharles 13y ago> If we want to attach terms and conditions to it (i.e. to use this site you must accept analytics/tracking/advertising) then lets make a framework to automate this stuff. This has already been done years ago, and failed: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P3P
- Nursie 13y agoShame, that sounds quite good.
- jasonlotito 13y ago> All that's happened is I've requested some data from the server and they've given it to me, from then on how I display it and what gets run is entirely up to me. You currently already have this option. You can control all this. That you've setup your browser to, by default, automatically grant JavaScript the right to run or accept cookies from third parties or numerous other things is on you. That's it has become fairly standard practice is a result of the masses wanting it that way.
- Nursie 13y ago1. No, I haven't set my browser to do this, it comes that way. 2. I am aware of my options, thanks. But you'll find the other parties arguing that I don't or shouldn't have the right to exercise them.
- Metatron 13y agoLook, let's try an analogy. I run a shop, you want to come into my shop, you want to physically bring yourself into my shop, with your personal items, including your wallet and let's say a bag to help you purchasing items, or perhaps just to browse. I'm going to keep an eye on you as I see fit whilst you are in my shop. Surely you can see that as fair? You are an agent entering my property. This is what your computer does when you access my site. I can extend this further. You have your wallet, you make a purchase, I have a till I record the purchase and even give you a receipt of the purchase, so that you can come back and we can both agree that you've been here before. So you come on to my site and you click on a download, I record the event through Google Tag Manager, which shoots it across to Google Analytics, and I even give you a cookie, useful for both of us. Next time you come to the site perhaps that cookie will mean I hide the download button from you, or it shows another related download to you. Feel free to rip up the receipt, or delete the cookie, you're messing with the accepted way of doing things and harming yourself as well as me, but please go ahead you're free to. But please try to understand that not everyone is out to get you, I'm not trying to 'spy' on you, I couldn't care less about you as an individual. I'm trying to optimise for the whole, for my business, for my clients. I have no evil agenda, and if I did you wouldn't be able to stop me because evil finds a way. The social contract exists, it is established, and it is incredibly close to how physical suppliers of products and services work. You live your life allowing businesses to track your movements within their physical domains, so why have a double standard for virtual domains? Don't pretend for a moment that because my 'shop' is rendering at your physical location that you aren't in fact virtually visiting me. You want something from my 'shop'? I want to know how you interact with my 'shop' It's really as simple as that. Your logic damages good, honest people, instead of cutting to the actual problems. Things like Do Not Track and whining about tracking being invasive is simply attacking the symptom and not the root cause. It's like demanding a ban on horses because the cowboys harassing your town all ride them. It does bugger all but damage everyone else whilst the cowboys/evil people just ignore your ban or find another way. Please see logic.
- 3825 13y agoThis is probably a discussion I would prefer us to have offline but the gist of it is that as a nascent industry, we have to make strides towards self-regulation very quickly. The NAI knows about the dangers lurking ahead. Overregulation is not a bogeyman. It is a real threat. DNT is good for us. We don't want to track someone who explicitly does not want to be tracked (boo, Microsoft IE team!)
- belorn 13y agoCan't an IE user turn tracking on if they want to?
- 3825 13y agoAs far as I know, DNT was designed to be a tri-state with { NoPreference, On, Off. NoPreference is the default. If it is turned on by default, what would NoPreference mean?
- belorn 13y agoOne could argue that DNT preference where chosen when the users opted to use IE with DNT as default. As such, NoPreference has no meaning when the user chose is always made one way or the other. In the end, Microsoft made the decision to force it into a yes/no, rather than leaving it at "NoPreference". I can fully see the argument that Microsoft is not following the spirit of the standard in doing so.
- bad_user 13y ago> No, my computer, my browser, my roof, my rules His website. Seriously, people should be warned that they are tracked, the purpose for which they are tracked and what exactly is tracked. Google Search for example is giving warnings lately, that you have to manually dismiss (probably because of EU laws) and I view that as being progress. On the other hand demanding of publishers to not track you while you're on their property is unreasonable. Of course, you can complain about it, you can stop using such services or websites and so on. Voting with your wallet (or eyeballs) still works, even on the web. I also view the "Do Not Track" header as a good thing, because it's an automated way for publishers to respect your wishes, should they choose to do that. But customers must also understand that this header represents a kind request, nothing else and we shouldn't make it something else, as that's a slippery slope.
- Nursie 13y ago>> His website. Running in my browser. >> On the other hand demanding of publishers to not track you while you're on their property is unreasonable. I'm not on their property. I'm fairly happy for them to record what they can see at their end in terms of what pages I go to, but I find it very unreasonable to demand that I run whatever code the website operator asks me to run, to turn my computer into a machine that reports anything/everything about my site interaction to anyone the site owner feels like, and all on the basis of an implied social contract of some form.
- bad_user 13y agoIf you don't like it, don't use it - simple as that. The only thing I find reasonable is for users to be warned that they are tracked, precisely for enabling them to move to alternatives that better respect their wishes. His website is running in your browser by your choice, not his ;-)
- Nursie 13y ago>> If you don't like it, don't use it - simple as that. >> His website is running in your browser by your choice, not his ;-) Excellent, now how do I know ahead of time, or without digging through the source, which sites are going to try and run this stuff? --edit-- Also, and here's the rub - again I just requested some data from his server, and it provided it to me. I made no promise to render or run it in the way he wants. If he has requirements about that sort of thing then maybe he needs to specify them.
- jasonlotito 13y ago> But you don't have a right to say what runs on my computer, or make it tell you what I'm doing. This is where our perceived rights collide. You already have control over this. That doesn't contradict someones right to track how people use the site. > No, my computer, my browser, my roof, my rules. And again, you already have control over this. However, if you give data to a remote server, they have the right to use that data. You are, in fact, giving them that data. > No, people get offended when you try to turn their computer into a device that spies on them. And we get more offended that this sort of stuff happens without most people even being aware its going on. That's a result of people wanting defaults, and most people change those defaults to be the least annoying as possible, regardless of security/privacy implications, even if it's explained to them. > And it's so lovely of you to have made the decision for me that it's to my benefit, so I don't have to worry about pesky things like privacy concerns, or having control over my own computing. But you do. You can prevent cookies from being put on your computer. You can prevent 3rd party cookies. You do have this control. What do you not have control over that you feel you should have control over? You keep talking about control as if you don't have it?
- Nursie 13y ago>> You already have control over this. That doesn't contradict someones right to track how people use the site. >> And again, you already have control over this. However, if you give data to a remote server, they have the right to use that data. You are, in fact, giving them that data. I think we may be talking at cross-purposes. The post I replied to says that they have a right to run tracking scripts and I don't have the right to reject them. This is what I disagree with. Track that my IP address has requested page A, then B, then D, F, Q and P in rapid succession? Knock yourself out. I have no problem with this. If I want to obfuscate it I'll use Tor or a proxy. But he doesn't get to force me to run his scripts. >> most people change those defaults to be the least annoying as possible, regardless of security/privacy implications, even if it's explained to them. Indeed, but at least then they are informed and its their choice to make. At the moment this isn't really the case. >> What do you not have control over that you feel you should have control over? You keep talking about control as if you don't have it? I know I have these powers and I exercise them. I'm only arguing against people who seek to take them away.
- jimktrains2 13y ago>> I have a right to track how people use my site. > But you don't have a right to say what runs on my computer, or make it tell you what I'm doing. This is where our perceived rights collide. Exactly! But you also don't have the right to tell him not to send tracking info either. You do, however, have the right not to execute it. For instance NoScript, Ghostery,and AdBlock+ will prevent the requests for this content from being made and executed. > No, my computer, my browser, my roof, my rules. I think OP meant that once you make a request to his server, his server is free to do what it wants with that request. I agree with this line of thought because most if not all others are silly. > No, people get offended when you try to turn their computer into a device that spies on them. And we get more offended that this sort of stuff happens without most people even being aware its going on. They may or may not object to it, but right now they don't even know. Again, you have the ability to not let your computer send these types of requests for special analytics packages &c. You can't possibly believe that his storing access logs is wrong. > This is about the only thing we agree on. It's pointless and it was never going to achieve anything. Hear! Hear!
- Nursie 13y ago>> I think OP meant that once you make a request to his server, his server is free to do what it wants with that request. I don't think they did mean that - "But you've politely requested that I don't track you. For starters this should only ever be a polite request, not a forced rejection of any tracking scripts. I have a right to track how people use my site." "People get way too offended by analytics tracking when it's there for their benefit." It looks to me like they're saying that if you go to their site you have to run their scripts regardless of your own wishes, and that you're 'under his roof' and will therefore do what he says. >> You can't possibly believe that his storing access logs is wrong. No, I don't, that would indeed be silly! I believe that it's rude to try to demand people run your code, and if you do demand it then we need to find a way for me to tell him up front that I'm not going to, so he can decide if he still wants to send me the page data.
- __david__ 13y agoI generally agree with you but I didn't read what he said that way. Just in the same sense that the browser has the right to avoid running javascript (or loading ads) that a server sends it, the server has a right to log requests the the client gives it (and certainly every server by default logs the IP, timestamp and request URL). I see it as 2 sides of the same coin. And though there are many analytics products that rely on running javascript on the client, almost all have fallbacks to 0px images--all that is needed is to comb through the logs occasionally.
- mcgwiz 13y agoClient and server, guys. A web browsing experience is a cooperative endeavor that occurs on property controlled by both the host (web server) and the visitor (user agent). At a fine-grained level, different aspects of that experience can be said to occur specifically on client or server. Each of those aspects can be constrained or manipulated by the respective property owner. When it comes to preferences of the visitor for certain server actions (or inactions), one can only make a request. This isn't a grand moral point, or a technical one, but one of basic property rights and personal freedom. And such a request is what the DNT header signifies. Likewise, when the server has preferences for certain user agent actions (such as running JavaScript or storing cookies) again it can only request that this occur since the user agent can typically disable JavaScript or cookies. This is what certain HTML metadata elements and the Set-Cookie header signify. If visitors are unhappy with the behavior of a server, they can avoid it. In aggregate, such avoidance can become a significant market force. At the same time, a website that does no analytics for DNT visitors and has a high ratio of DNT visitors may also become less competitive and valuable over time. Both can feedback into respective preference consideration. This is ultimately the meager value of DNT. It (combined with adequate education) provides extra context data that can motivate through market forces an adjustment to web browsing norms. Along the lines of "adequate education", the option in Firefox should read "Tell websites to restrict their tracking of me. __(Learn more.)__" Practically, how would you know in advance if a server will respect your DNT preference without first visiting the site? Well, in real life, how do you know whether someone who invites you over for dinner won't serve you poison? One way is through trusted third-parties, but the market hasn't yet demanded such a service (and may never).
- Nursie 13y ago>> When it comes to preferences of the visitor for certain server actions (or inactions), one can only make a request. Absolutely. But the OP seemed to be saying that it was his right as the server owner to make me run his tracking scripts on my end. If I have the wrong end of the stick then great, I'll shut up, but he seemed to be saying that clients don't get to go to his site and then reject his use of analytics by (for instance) refusing to load the scripts. I find that attitude quite objectionable. I think it's his right not to provide site content for people who refuse to run his scripts, that seems perfectly reasonable, it's his site and his copyright material. I'd be perfectly happy for my initial request to have a header that says "By the way, I don't run analytics, social network widgets or graphical advertising". Then everyone is informed and everyone has a choice.