4 ms·
OK, so you run a company with practically infinite resources, an OS that is portable across architectures, and a managed language runtime that's portable across
by Zigurd 13y ago
OK, so you run a company with practically infinite resources, an OS that is portable across architectures, and a managed language runtime that's portable across architectures that powers hundreds of thousands (millions?) of useful applications with a suite of languages including what is arguably a nicer language than Java.
You see Android running the same apps on multiple mobile device architectures using Java and the Dalvik VM. That's a technology you had since 13 years ago with NETCF.
Hmmm. What to do? What to do? I KNOW: Let's segment the market by blowing off compatibility with a gazillion apps my enterprise customers have written and use and let's use Surface RT to go for a Quixotic attempt to beat Apple and Google with Modern apps which are over-sandboxed and can't talk to .NET apps.
That comes off as derisive, but how do you say it nicer? They lost a billion dollars in a write-down - not a write-off - doing that, and not one word about "Gee, can we fix the product formulation?"
Well, at least they didn't buy Motorola. That's going to be a write-down that leaves a mark.
- cryowaffle 13y agoGoogle bought Motorola as a defensive patent move, it's almost completely intangible.
- cremnob 13y agoThat's not working out too well. http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/26/4271432/does-anyone-know-why-google-bought-motorola http://www.theverge.com/2013/4/26/4271432/does-anyone-know-w...
- mullingitover 13y agoFrom that article: "Which again leads to the question: why did Google buy Motorola? The real answer is worth $12.5 billion." I love how people keep trotting this number out. Nevermind the fact that Moto had $3 billion in cash[1], which immediately became Google's cash when the purchase went through, so the real price was closer to 9.5 billion. Motorola also had 24,500 patents in its portfolio[2]. Apple, MS, and RIM paid 4.5 billion for 6,000 Nortel patents not long before the Moto sale. [1] http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/08/16/whats-behind-the-hefty-motorola-break-up-fee/?_r=0 http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2011/08/16/whats-behind-the-heft... [2] http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/08/valuing-patents http://www.economist.com/blogs/babbage/2011/08/valuing-paten...
- jussij 13y agoBut that 9.5 billion investment is yet to return a profit: Motorola, acquired by Google in 2012, racked up a loss of $218 million before items, more than four times the $49 million it lost a year earlier. http://www.dailyfinance.com/2013/07/19/google-earnings-ad-rates-motorola-losses/ http://www.dailyfinance.com/2013/07/19/google-earnings-ad-ra...
- srathi 13y agoThey also recovered $3 billion by selling the set top box business.
- nilsbunger 13y agoDo you have any data on the quality of the patents? I thought the Motorola ones were mostly standards-essential and were a "second tranche" after the cream of the crop was previously sold off. But I can't find a good reference that I believe...
- mullingitover 13y agoIt's anyone's guess. How do we know how many patent suits were avoided because Google had a new arsenal to fight back with? How many new patents have Moto engineers filed since the purchase? How do we put a dollar value on the hardware expertise that Google picked up in the purchase?
- strandev 13y ago12.5+ billion dollars isn't intangible, even for Google.
- treeface 13y agoHe's trying to say that Google paid something tangible for something intangible. It's difficult to estimate the present value of a patent portfolio, ergo it's "intangible".
- hkmurakami 13y agobefore the Motorola acquisition, Google's patent arsenal was in the hundreds, which was abysmally small for a company that size. This probably stemmed from their ideals and their culture, but the ugly reality is that companies need patent arsenals to protect themselves. There is a reason why no one messes with IBM with a patent war. The counter punch would murder anyone who'd try. Maybe Google now has enough patents to deter most of the absurd threats, and given their cash flow, even the huge cost of the Motorola acquisition may be "worth it" as a contingency plan and a risk hedge.
- jussij 13y ago> This probably stemmed from their ideals and their culture, but the ugly reality is that companies need patent arsenals to protect themselves. I'm sure that's what Google was hoping for. But it appears the 12 billion paid for those patents don't seem to be offering too much in the way of protection, as they keep losing in the courts. http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/04/april-was-disastrous-for-google-on.html http://www.fosspatents.com/2013/04/april-was-disastrous-for-... Add to that, the additional Motorola restructuring costs and Motorola’s inability to make a profit, it's starting to look like the purchase won’t be far off from a total right down.
- hkmurakami 13y agoI wonder if the Nortel patents would have served them better.
- jussij 13y agoThe may have been forced to purchase Motorola in order to protect Android? During its Q2 earnings conference call Motorola hinted that it is ready to join Android patent racket, and start demanding licensing fees for its IP from other Android manufacturers. This week Motorola’s CEO Sanjay Jha reiterated this message, and made it even more clear – they do indeed have plans to start collecting IP royalties from other Android makers. http://www.unwiredview.com/2011/08/11/motorolas-sanjay-jha-openly-admits-they-plan-to-collect-ip-royalties-from-other-android-makers/ http://www.unwiredview.com/2011/08/11/motorolas-sanjay-jha-o... To find out, I guess we'll have to wait a few decades for the book?
- Sven7 13y agoMoving from desktop to mobile keeping compatibility (with a huge base - a challenge no one else had - possibly only nokia transitioning from dumb to smart) isn't a trivial problem by any stretch of the imagination. They took a swing in a very unpredictable and hyper competitive market. It had to be a big swing and it didn't work. Its a shame cause I think their dev tools/platform/languages are solid. I enjoyed working with C#/WPF/xaml in comparison with Android/java/flash and the current hodge podge of web tech.
- joseph_cooney 13y agoThis x 100. The CLR was designed for this from the ground up (or they copied the design from Java, take your pick). As you pointed out, they've had a working implementation forever in the form of the .NET Compact Framework. And yet they went with the 'strategy' they went with.... You couldn't make this shit up if you tried...
- edandersen 13y agoWindows RT has a full version of .NET 4.5, the only thing stopping it running your own pure "AnyCPU" binaries is the signature check.