6 ms·
Aaron would be alive today if he'd only stopped before he decided to hang himself in his apartment. No one else bears any responsibility for his death.
by philwelch 13y ago
Aaron would be alive today if he'd only stopped before he decided to hang himself in his apartment. No one else bears any responsibility for his death.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ralish 13y agoI'm sorry, but that's absolute rubbish. I rarely post on HN, but I feel compelled to do so here. People rarely live in a vacuum, they engage with society, and those interactions have tangible results. I feel this is obvious, but it seems lost on people. When a person is systematically bullied, that negative interaction with society will inevitably have an impact, and if severe enough, suicide is a potential result. Aaron had the weight of a state on his shoulders, and while I'm glad to say I've never experienced that the prospects of it terrify me. As someone with a history of depression, I can quite confidently state, I'm unsure I'd survive through the experience, and can foresee it simply becoming too much. To state that no one has responsibility for his death is to excuse the gross abuses of those who's interactions with Aaron led to it. You are giving a pass to disgraceful prosecution tactics including intimidation and overreach. You are giving a pass to institutions that abandoned morality by siding with an abusive prosecution instead of standing up for a member of their community. Most egregiously, you are encouraging a broad view that only the victim is at fault for their choice. There's so much wrong with this view it's hard to know where to start, but for one, it suggests they're in the position to even logically and rationally evaluate the choice. If you're depressed to the point of suicide, it's fairly safe to assume, you aren't thinking logically or rationally. How can you then be held at fault for the resultant choice? Suicide is horrible, and I've known some who've taken that path. But blaming those who commit such an act is the easy way out. To reduce the instances of people taking their own lives, you need to understand why. This means fully comprehending the circumstances that led to their choice, and this means holding those to account that contributed to it.
- antoko 13y agoI'm sorry, but that's absolute rubbish. I rarely post on HN, but I feel compelled to do so here. Thanks for this, you should post more, a community is only as good as its active members.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Zikes 13y agoIf depression and suicidal thoughts are not logical or rational, how can anyone outside of the condition hope to interact with someone suffering from it?
- unreal37 13y ago"But blaming those who commit such an act is the easy way out." You have to admit that people that commit suicide are primarily responsible for their own deaths. That's like saying, people who drink alcohol are primarily responsible for getting drunk - it's just true prima face. He killed himself, therefore he was responsible for his own death.
- roc 13y ago> "You have to admit that people that commit suicide are primarily responsible for their own deaths. " Perhaps in the same way that we might say someone who dies of cancer is responsible for their own deaths. That is: if we were in the habit of assigning blame to the suffering, for the medical problems they suffer. Or if we are to outright deny what science has to say about it and instead further the US habit of denying mental health conditions as actual, legitimate medical issues.
- jlgreco 13y agoDoes an abusive father have no moral responsibility for his children falling into alcoholism?
- philwelch 13y agoBy your logic, a culture that teaches people they aren't responsible for their own actions would bear responsibility as well.
- michaelwww 13y agoThat's technically true, but prosecuting him with a 30 to 35 year sentence gave him all the incentive he needed. I think any reasonable person facing 35 years in prison would at least consider suicide as an alternative.
- raldi 13y ago> I think any reasonable person facing 35 years in prison would at least consider suicide Would you say the same about any person facing a six-month plea deal?
- mistercow 13y agoBeing convicted of a felony in the US is never over. A plea deal like that is a life sentence of a different sort.
- mpyne 13y agoThis kind of felony would hardly have been the end of the world. Why, I bet it's possible that one could even go on to great success in the tech field, even with (or especially with) a CFAA felony. That's kind of besides the point, because a felony conviction would have been overkill here. But it still would have been much better than the alternative we ended up getting. Let's face it, many hackers have faced felony charges before without killing themselves, and few of them had as much potentially going for them after the trial as Aaron would have.
- twoodfin 13y agoWell it's a "life sentence" that somehow one of YC's founders managed to survive. Not just survive, but become very successful and an MIT professor. I'm not trying to downplay the significance of a felony conviction, but it shouldn't be overplayed either.
- sophacles 13y agoYou note the exceptional case. Of course odds of that happening are very low. Hence it is exceptional. Sure - 2% of people survived a fall from the Golden Gate bridge, so that means it's silly to focus on the death aspects of such a fall when reasoning about "if someone does fall". Similarly people occasionally choke to death on food. So we should stop talking about eating without serious choking warnings all over the place, right?
- riggins 13y agoNo one else bears any responsibility for his death. that's a black and white view of the world. One that I also don't think would hold up to the slightest logical scrutiny. Can we delve into your comment a bit. Is your claim that when someone commits suicide that no else ever bears any responsibility for their death?
- philwelch 13y agoI'm sure you could construct a counter example to any general statement about the question
- riggins 13y agoHow about Alan Turing?
- philwelch 13y agoWhat about Alan Turing? Isn't it enough that the British state is responsible for oppressing and chemically castrating one of their national heroes? Would their treatment of him had somehow been less evil had he chosen not to kill himself?
- riggins 13y agoIsn't it enough that the British state is responsible Safe to say that for me, I find your comments unclear. let's recap. Here's how the thread started. This may in fact be true, but this claim is leveled with the implication that MIT is responsible for his death. -pkfrank You're the second comment on the thread No one else bears any responsibility for his death. from that I infer (and I think most people would as well) that you don't think MIT has any responsibility in the matter. Furthermore, because of the terseness of your comment (there's no qualification or explanation) your comment reads like an almost absolute claim that when someone commits suicide no one else ever bears any responsibility. That's why I asked for clarification. Here you acknowledge that the British state bears responsibility for oppressing and chemically castrating Turing. But would you say the British state has no responsibility for his suicide?
- mistercow 13y agoEw. Put that victim blaming away, sir.
- philwelch 13y agoIt follows from the definition of suicide that the victim is also the perpetrator. Are you suggesting it wasn't suicide?
- mistercow 13y agoIt does not follow from the definition of suicide that responsibility lies solely with the victim.
- philwelch 13y agoThe responsibility for any act lies with the person who committed it. I think you can work out the rest of the syllogism from there.
- mistercow 13y agoDeath is not an act, it's a consequence. So even if we accept that a person cannot bear any responsibility for someone else's actions, they can still bear responsibility for the consequences. The premise that a person bears sole responsibility for the consequences of their actions is untenable as no consequence has a single cause.