9 ms·
A factual one, which has been widely reported over the years. Universities pay for their own police. The goal of the university is to avoid incidents which wo
by rdl 13y ago
A factual one, which has been widely reported over the years.
Universities pay for their own police. The goal of the university is to avoid incidents which would deter parents from sending their children to the school. Rape, particularly date rape/incidents involving alcohol are quite common on campus, if only due to demographics (young, socially connected, etc.)
There are three ways to solve it -- either actually addressing the underlying issues, or full prosecution of every incident, or sweeping it under the rug to the extent possible.
#1 is obviously ideal, but difficult. #2 would end up with both scary stats and large numbers of other students with felony convictions. #3 is the standard university police outcome.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bennett-l-gershman/campus-culture-complacency_b_1095510.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bennett-l-gershman/campus-cult... is one article.
Anyone who is a victim of a serious crime in a place with "internal" police should almost certainly report directly to the territorial police instead, or at least in addition to, since they have much fewer conflicts of interest, and probably more expertise in dealing with serious crimes.
("Real" police departments are also (theoretically) much more accountable to voters and the public, too. This is particularly an issue with weird transit or internal-to-agency police like the BART Police (who are tied with East Palo Alto PD as the worst department in the region).)
- larrys 13y agoInteresting. So you are saying it has to do with essentially restricting or retarding the flow of information that could be harmful to the University. Then I would expect over time with the Internet that that would not be as effective as it was in years past before the Internet. Do we have any data on how this has changed now that anyone can broadcast anything and get attention? I would expect that if the primary reason for existence of the police force was to control the information flow as I think you suggest (which it could do quite easily pre internet) that we should see much more of this negative information has come out because it has a path. Has that been the case? (Serious question).
- rdl 13y agoGood question. I think it's more about having alternatives to official reporting channels so the stuff never actually gets reported, vs. hiding reports. But, we've seen citizen cameras as a huge force to accountability in cases of police abuse, too (Rodney King for a city PD; BART and Toronto for transit police, various people who came forward at Penn State after the Sandusky stuff blew the issue up there). So it seems plausible. I'm not saying the only thing the police do is hide rapes, it's that their essential differentiation vs. other LEOs would be to protect their employers from embarrassment which would be detrimental to the organization's mission, which rape would be. So the reason it exists as a distinct force is that, whereas they still spend a large percentage of their effort in duties totally in common with a city police force.
- saraid216 13y agoReally, leveling such an accusation at the university police is trying to deal with a symptom. Abolishing university police forces won't cause rape instances to decline appreciably, but it will accelerate the implosion of higher education as a whole. Precisely for the reasons you stated. Perhaps it would be better to look for a solution where universities are less motivated to compete for student head count, so that their police forces are less motivated to cover up incidents that would reduce it.
- cmsmith 13y agoCities pay for their own police. The goal of cities is to avoid the appearance that the city is dangerous, to encourage investment and more taxable income. https://www.google.com/search?q=downgrade+crime https://www.google.com/search?q=downgrade+crime I'm not saying that we don't need checks on the system, but to say that university police don't provide any valuable service is ridiculous.