5 ms·
>I honestly do not expect a privileged homogenous team to actually be able to come up with a solution, because privileged groups tend come up with solutions tha
by Karunamon 13y ago
>I honestly do not expect a privileged homogenous team to actually be able to come up with a solution, because privileged groups tend come up with solutions that are best for privileged groups.
Leaving aside the issue of whether anyone buys into third wave feminism's definition of "privilege", this comes out as an indictment of every abuse reporting system ever made. It adds nothing and suggests nothing, only says "this sucks".
Actually, I take that back. It's impossible to leave that issue aside since you implicitly accept that definition to even make sense of this article.
Thing is, "abuse" is determined by the service provider, not the users. (And rightly so - or else you run into the problem mentioned where people flag something off and ruin someone else's day because their delicate sensibilities were offended..) Twitter and every other social communication site has a list of "thou shalt not's" which you are reporting when you click on the "flag" button.
- makomk 13y agoButbut, apparently it's important that non-privileged people, as defined by feminists, be allowed to tell privileged people to kill themselves or go choke on their own vomit: http://stavvers.wordpress.com/2013/07/27/against-a-twitter-report-abuse-button/ http://stavvers.wordpress.com/2013/07/27/against-a-twitter-r... To be honest, at this point I wish there was some way every major side of the argument would lose, because they're all pretty unpalatable.
- Karunamon 13y agoNot really. I see three sides in this argument. * The "deal with it" crowd that doesn't care who they offend or see why tone is important. (i.e. 4chan users) * The radfem "offenders are literally hitler" types who go out of their way to give people a hard time over their choice of words, putting zero thought into intent (i.e. r/SRS users) * The people who want to have informative and interesting debate without being hassled by group 2 or trolled by group 1 (i.e. HN users). The first two groups can fuck right off, they are both a plague on constructive discourse and on the sites where they congregate. They also both tend to polarize the userbase and cause more problems by fighting with each other and dragging other boards into it (one can see this in action by the pro and anti SRS factions on Reddit).
- makomk 13y agoI've been seeing a different three sides: * the 4chan /b/ "deal with it" crowd * a group of radfems like Cathy Brennan who think they should be able to insult and dox trans women with impuny (names, addresses, photos, jobs, the works) because they're fighting to protect feminism but consider polite complaints about this to be harassment. They support the Twitter abuse button; if they ever get suspended, they just organise large groups of fellow activists to pressure the service provider into reinstating their accounts. * people like the blogger I've linked who object to this because it isn't strict enough on their enemies and won't allow them to insult and belittle people they believe to be privileged, meaning the above-mentioned radfems, men who've been raped, and various other threats to their form of feminism. Most of the influential Twitter users I follow are in group three. They're opposed to the new abuse button. All three of these groups use near identical "if you're not happy with our unproductive, abusive language, just unfollow/block and stop whinging" arguments. Your group 3 is, so far as I can tell, nowhere to be seen.
- Karunamon 13y ago>Your group 3 is, so far as I can tell, nowhere to be seen. So where would you say HN sits?
- makomk 13y agoI'd say HN sits several hundred miles away, watching the battle on the TV. I hadn't seen HN express any opinion on the topic at all up until now, and it doesn't look like we're likely to become a major player in this.
- kevingadd 13y agoPart of the problem is a lot of abuse reporting systems are automated, so like in the case of YouTube videos, if you want something taken down you just get people to spam on the button. That's actually worse than no system at all, because the abuse reporting system is a vehicle for more powerful abuse. I think this is part of why you see posts like the OP about abuse report systems. The abusers in this scenario are larger in number and have more access to resources, so it's only natural that any automated abuse report system will get turned against their victims instead of against them.
- steveklabnik 13y ago> Actually, I take that back. It's impossible to leave that issue aside since you implicitly accept that definition to even make sense of this article. I don't think this is true. The main thrust of the article is this: You have two options for reporting abuse: automatic and not automatic. The automatic option is flawed because it makes the assumption that the feature itself won't be abused. The non-automatic option won't work because it doesn't scale and humans interpret rules in different ways. No specific thoughts on privilege needed to make sense of that.
- detcader 13y agoIn my experience it's less of a question as to whether one buys into or doesn't buy into the idea of privilege and more one of whether one understands it or (perhaps willfully) misunderstands or only bothers to gain a partial grasp of the concept. It's hardly a tool native to third wave feminism; the most famous essay on the idea is chiefly about white privilege. [1] Anyways, why must one "implicitly accept" the idea to "make sense" of the article? Do we need to accept Communist-Leninism to make sense of Das Capital? I find it hard to believe that you've never understood any piece of writing that you don't already agree with. [1] http://www.library.wisc.edu/EDVRC/docs/public/pdfs/LIReadings/InvisibleKnapsack.pdf http://www.library.wisc.edu/EDVRC/docs/public/pdfs/LIReading...