11 ms·
That's not unethical, it's fraud. And if you go to a bank and say "I don't want to pay this they forgot my drink!" They will probably not even wait to hang up b
by pc86 13y ago
That's not unethical, it's fraud. And if you go to a bank and say "I don't want to pay this they forgot my drink!" They will probably not even wait to hang up before laughing at you. If you get back service, don't go again and write a bad review or two.
- mikeash 13y agoHow about "I don't want to pay this, because they said it would be free"?
- Already__Taken 13y agoThat's why you get a bill to look at before you pay.
- btilly 13y agoThey got the bill, challenged it, and were informed that they had no choice.
- pc86 13y agoThey were informed they had no choice with regard to the service charge. Which, if California's laws in this respect are as odd as they sound, may be a legal barrier and not one at the restaurant. There is no indication in the article about them challenging the dessert.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> They got the bill, challenged it, and were informed that they had no choice. The manager asserting that they had no choice doesn't mean they did; if they disagree, they could have refused to pay unless the offending items are removed from the bill. Obviously, that would have been an escalation, and they chose to acquiesce instead, but that was a choice.
- gohrt 13y agoconsent under duress is not legally recognized consent.
- dragonwriter 13y agoSure, but there is no duress in the story. Someone who has the title "manager" stating the restaurant's view of what is required isn't "duress".
- pc86 13y agoThe bank route is all or nothing. You don't get to say "I feel the service was bad, the manager said this $10 dessert would be free and it wasn't, therefore I want to start a chargeback on the entire $100 bill." No. If the dessert is the issue, don't pay the bill until you ask the manager why it's on the bill when it was supposed to be free. Let them call the police if it gets to that point (it almost never does). But once you pay the bill you're accepting the charges. There is no such thing as "paying under protest" for stuff like this.
- mikeash 13y agoThat's not true. You can dispute any portion of a charge you feel like. A few years ago, I signed up for wireless internet service that ended up turning into crap after a month. I was willing to pay for the month where I got service, but I felt that they used false advertising to get my business, and as such they did not merit the activation fee. Luckily, I paid with a credit card. My charge was $75, which combined the $35 activation fee and the $40 charge for the month of service. I disputed only the $35 and got my money back.
- btilly 13y agoYes, but they also committed fraud when they charged for what they said they would not charge for.