8 ms·
If there ever was an article written and filled with mis-information and a completely superficial look at the pros and cons of the Danish society and it's merit
by ThomPete 13y ago
If there ever was an article written and filled with mis-information and a completely superficial look at the pros and cons of the Danish society and it's merits, it is this article.
The claim that Danes are ambitious is flat out wrong. The younger generation more so, but there is a reason why danes are the "happiest people" in the world and it's not because of their ambitions.
The Danish model is under huge pressure and haven't escaped the reality of globalisation and automatisation.
But because wealth gets distributed the way it does, it doesn't feel the heat too much just yet.
In other words the Danish system is a thing of beauty as long as it works. Unfortunately it doesn't work anymore and somethings gotta give.
Edit: Was asked to be more specific.
Out of 6m people:
Almost 0.8m people on some sort of social welfare
Almost 0.8m people are working in full time positions for the public sector.
In comparison 1,9 in the private sector and it is shrinking rapidly.
It is notoriously easy to start a company in Denmark but notoriously hard to grow it among other things because most Danes don't have those ambitions and are very very risk-averse.
We are long past the point where more people are depending on the state than on the private job market and as those jobs disappear because of the named automation and globalisation and because Denmark is just too expensive, it will be hard for any government to promise the elaborate system we have now.
This is already starting to show as the latest government scramble to lower taxes for corporations and reduce the number of entitled benefits Danes can expect.
Furthermore Denmark took the wrong educational strategy and unfortunately like most of the european countries believed that knowledge worker meant book reader.
The result of this is that we have a large over educated part of the population who will have a very hard time finding a job.
- Svip 13y agoThis is nothing new. All BBC articles on Denmark are almost entirely inaccurate. It's like the BBC has no researchers in Denmark or on Denmark, and basically swallow some brochure. Every other week, a Danish newspaper has an article about another BBC article painting another rose picture of Denmark. Is the BBC working for the Danish tourism board?! Just two weeks ago, a BBC article claimed Danes can usually command 3 languages besides English and Danish, which hardly accurate (unless they count Swedish and Norwegian, but that's cheating!).
- treenyc 13y agoJust curious, which parts are not accurate? I would be very nice to know for someone who is not Danish.
- Svip 13y agoAs my parent points out, the statement by Christian Bjørnskov, that Danes are ambitious. Danes are far more interested in working for an employer than being one (on average). Danes like a large welfare state and we like comfort. While Bjørnskov goes on to hide his suggestion with the fact that Danes don't like to show off (we have a culture against showing off, see Law of Jante[1], which is diminishing but very slowly), his concept of 'ambitious' does not translate into something that makes Danes particularly happier. Our 'happiness' rating stems from our comfort, because despite the welfare state's quirks, it does work some of the time. But it is a huge drag on the treasury, and a lot of the money are not exactly spent efficiently. Denmark is not a perfect place, and I am not sure people coming here will automatically be happier (particularly considering how we treat immigrants). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_Jante
- marknutter 13y agoI thought Danish people were the happiest people in the world because they had the lowest expectations. 60 Minutes did a piece on it a while back: http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=3841772n http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=3841772n
- Svip 13y agoWe do, because our comfort level is so high. Because one might ask, 'why do Danes have such low expectations?' following that conclusion.
- kalms 13y ago> Danes are far more interested in working for an employer than being one (on average). Danes like a large welfare state and we like comfort. I don't think you're necessarily right about that statement. Most people I know dreams of being self-employed, especially where I grew up in Jutland. That doesn't make me right either. Both of us are using ourselves as a measurement here, and that's probably a bad idea.
- joakleaf 13y agoGood thing your post wasn't a bug-report, although you do mention that something doesn't work. You didn't describe any symptoms or argue why the Danish system no longer works or what precisely doesn't work, so it would be great if you could give some examples, facts and figures. Are you talking about unemployment? Average wealth? Class mobility? Freedom? Pollution? Any country that has a model that works better? US, UK, China, France, Singapore? In what way?
- vidarh 13y agoScandinavians love to whine about how our countries are falling apart. Until someone writes an article about how we're best at something, then we'll temporarily use the opportunity to gloat before going back to complaining. It appears to be some weird inferiority complex.
- Svip 13y agoHow is this different from any other country?
- morsch 13y agoThe damned Scandinavians get to be best at stuff that matters. :)
- vidarh 13y agoIn my opinion, it is massively different in tone. I'm Norwegian, and I live in the UK and have spent quite a lot of time in the US. While people in the UK and US will also complain loudly, the character is entirely different in that outside of Scandinavia the self-criticism is more "if we don't fix this things will go to hell", whereas in Scandinavia a lot of the self-criticism implies we're competing with war-torn third world countries about who gets to be the butthole of the world and are likely to win. The focus of self-criticism in Scandinavia seems to me to be hugely disproportionately focused on describing us as doing horribly compared to everyone else in a way that seems to indicate a huge inferiority complex, where self-criticism other places seems to in general be more internally focused. Of course there are exceptions.
- klausjensen 13y agoI am Danish, and I approved this message.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoEvery time there is a US/UK article about how much better things are in Scandinavia/Netherlands/Germany, someone from the latter pops up and starts listing a number of negatives, usually with a strong right-wing/libertarian bias. None of these are false in themselves, but these same issues are largely common to all Western societies (the US being a bit of an outlier in some aspects), and not a sign of total failure of a specific model. Name one Western country that isn't struggling with public spending, globalisation, automation and education issues.
- fetbaffe 13y agoWhat usually all these comparisons (from all sides) fail to understand is that all countries have different history and culture, therefore the solutions will always differ and cannot be implemented across different countries. And people will prefer one over the other because of their own bias as a member of any given country. However what you can measure is the progress within you own country, is it improving or not. One thing worth mentioning is that usually the top countries is all these articles is usually small North European countries. That suggest that human societies does not scale as databases.
- mseebach 13y agoWhenever one of these US/UK articles pops up, it's usually from a left-leaning angle, emphasising the left policies of these countries as the cause of all the goodness there - so it's only natural that the counterpoint would be right-leaning. > not a sign of total failure of a specific model. It's not that it's a total failure, it's more that the scandinavian model isn't the utopia it's made out to be by its (mostly left leaning) proponents.
- subsystem 13y agoThe problem is that the counterpoint doesn't have very much to do with issue at hand. It's like a number of people read "Denmark" and thought "Let me tell you what is wrong with Denmark!". This is exactly the type of political discussions that should be avoided on HN, because when arguments are vague and with little relation to the article the quality of the discussion will suffer.
- joakleaf 13y agoI agree that too many people are employed by the public sector. This number grew rapidly in the 1970s, but has continue to grow (although much less) steadily since. http://punditokraterne.dk/2012/06/22/offentligt-ansatte-1970-2012/ http://punditokraterne.dk/2012/06/22/offentligt-ansatte-1970... Do you mean that the danish "model" is broken, because the public finances run with a deficit and/or because of unemployment? It is still not obvious for me what you mean by broken. Since the number of people employed in the public sector hasn't increased by more than around 10% since the 1980s, and the unemployment rate is now actually relatively low (5.8%), one could argue that the model really does work. It hasn't crashed over a period of 30 years. Public spending was excessive during the 2000s, so the "model" does need some refinement, and will like continue to undergoing constant refinement as the economy fluctuates. The unemployment rate is currently dropping, and it is lower than e.g. UK (5.8% vs. 7.7%) and certainly Southern Europe. Unemployment is a reoccurring problem in a historical sense, and a much bigger problem in most of the world than Denmark. People everywhere struggle to find jobs as a consequence of increased automation. Especially, uneducated people. Denmark is running with a deficit at the moment, but there have been years with surplus too. Of course, that could be explained by the income generated from natural resources (oil+gas), just as the deficit could be explained by fluctuations in the world economy. The deficit in 2013 is expected to be 1.2% of GDP which isn't bad compared to everywhere else. National debt compared to GDP is higher in many countries: http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/774/economics/list-of-national-debt-by-country/ http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/774/economics/list-of-nati... Another point you mention is that it is hard to grow a company because of lack of ambition in Denmark. It is hard to grow a company in Denmark, but I personally consider high salaries as a bigger problem than lack of ambition. On a positive side, because there is very good support for unemployed people, Danish employment laws are less restrictive than many countries, making it much easier for companies to hire and fire their employees. Flexibility is very good thing for a company that wishes to grow. If you say automation is making it hard for people to find a job, what do you propose as an alternative to educating people (you mention a large part is overeducated)? Lowering taxes for corporations was a ridiculous idea. It is higher almost everywhere else, and nobody could give a compelling argument for lowering it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_rates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_tax_rates Corporate tax is paid of the profit, before the profit is distributed to its shareholders. 3 percentage points lower tax of dividends, before income tax, will not change much for the shareholders of Danish corporations. You also haven't pointed to a country with a model you feel is working better.
- wslh 13y agoHow do you "benchmark" Denmark with Norway about the present/future?
- mjn 13y agoAn opinion: Denmark has a more modern and dynamic economy, but it's hard to compare anything to Norway, because they have such huge natural resources that they can pay for all kinds of arrangements if they choose to. For example, Norway has an inefficient agricultural sector deliberately kept isolated from the EU market with high tariffs, but it's seen as culturally important, and the country can afford to maintain it as long as it's popular to do so. Even looking into the future, their resource economy seems likely to persist. Oil production is declining, but fairly slowly, and natural-gas production has actually been rising. The value of hydroelectric exports has been going up as European demand for "green" electricity allows them to be sold at a premium price. There are large thorium reserves, which might some day be valuable. There are also large, barely-exploited wind resources, which could be exported like the hydroelectric ones are, though they pose more grid issues. Between all these different sources they sort of hit the energy jackpot.
- oellegaard 13y agoSure, the Scandinavian system who made several relatively rich countries is deeply flawed. I think the cold war created a unhealty general view on socialism. Distributing wealth equally seems to work very well for many countries, including Denmark, Norway and Sweden. I lived in Switzerland for two years where they are very liberal, but still it felt like that the middle class was large and rather healthy. Having a large, rich middle class is far better for the economy than having a small portion of super rich people and many people who can barely afford living, like in the US. This have the two following bad economic effects: Large savings for the few rich people and no purchasing power for the masses, effectively killing many businesses. Also, its far better to have people on welfare spending money locally than having people so poor that they can't afford food and living. I think Denmarks largest economic problem is that lack of Venture Capital. With companies such as Podio and Zendesk showing up, I think this is just a matter of time. Recently the Government made initiatives to invest in new companies with growth potential, which hopefully creates a better environment for start ups interested in growing.
- osth 13y ago"The result of this is that we have a large over educated part of the population who will have a very hard time finding a job." Consider the alternatives: a large under educated part of the population who will/will not have a very hard time finding a job. An educated population makes for a better society, irrespective of what "the economy" may or may not have to offer[1]. Economies can change on relatively short timeframes, while the character of societies[2] change much more slowly, if at all[3]. 1. Author's opinion. 2. Substitute "character of society" with "culture" if you wish. 3. Another author opinion. "Over educated" is interesting terminology. What exactly does that mean? Do we define education only in economic terms? Why did wealthy classes historically seek to become educated, even when "economically speaking" they already had society's best resource allocation?
- ThomPete 13y agoThat isn't the point about over educated and you are right it's not very precise of me. Let me elaborate in an hour
- INTPenis 13y agoTo try and define an entire nation of people in one article/comment with a few fancy words is down right silly. I've lived the last 10 years around Øresund, in various places, and the best explanation of the danish lifestyle I've heard was that they don't expect success so they get more happier when they have it. But I only enjoy that explanation because it fits into my little belief of how I want people to be. It says nothing about how people actually are. It's ridiculous to believe that there aren't people who strive for success and material wealth in a place so well developed as Denmark.
- ThomPete 13y agoI am not sure about your definition of a generalization, but to me that does not include the exceptions.