4 ms·
Do any related laws require disclosure of paid for or fake reviews? Blogs must state financial interest in reviews they do now: http://internet-law.lawyers.co
by curiouscats 13y ago
Do any related laws require disclosure of paid for or fake reviews? Blogs must state financial interest in reviews they do now:
http://internet-law.lawyers.com/Truth-in-Blogging-New-FTC-Blog-Disclosure-Rules.html http://internet-law.lawyers.com/Truth-in-Blogging-New-FTC-Bl...
It would seem this type of action would be done (in this case) by lobbyists (paid for by lobbyists), I wonder if there are rules on lobbyists paying for fake reviews (since lobbyists do have some constraints on actions that others don't).
- diminoten 13y agoWhy does there have to be a law against this? If Amazon wants to allow astroturfing, what say does the government have in it?
- curiouscats 13y agoI am not saying there should be. I am not sure I really think the law for blogs is a good idea. I agree it isn't a great thing to do, but there are lots of things that are not great things to do - most of which are probably legal. I was just asking if there was a law that prohibited it.
- pessimizer 13y agoAs long as the reviews aren't presented as being honest or real. If they are presented as honest or real, it sounds like fraud to me. If I sell you a cinderblock in a box and tell you it's a computer, I think the government should have a say. Same situation if I sell you a book and tell you that Bob the fisherman from New Orleans thought it contained real original scholarship about Soviet central planning, and it turns out that his name isn't even Bob.
- diminoten 13y agoSure, but that's not what is happening here. Someone not involved in the purchase or sale of the item is making statements about said item. That's entirely different.
- pessimizer 13y agoNo, Amazon is the publisher. I think they're responsible.
- diminoten 13y agoWhat do you mean no? Amazon isn't writing the reviews, someone else is.