3 ms·
Bloomberg is comparing apples and oranges, to the point of caricaturization. They are also link baiting with false statements. First, the link bait: "The same
by zaroth 13y ago
Bloomberg is comparing apples and oranges, to the point of caricaturization. They are also link baiting with false statements.
First, the link bait: "The same procedure costs $106,385 at Ohio’s Cleveland Clinic, according to data from the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services." Funny thing is they actually cite their data source, so I downloaded the Excel sheet and looked for myself. The $106,385 is the "Average Covered Charges" for "238 - MAJOR CARDIOVASC PROCEDURES W/O MCC" at Cleveland Clinic. If you read the definition of "Average Covered Charges", it is not the cost of the procedure. The cost, aka "Average Total Payments" was actually $26,898. That's what medicare pays, including co-pays, deductibles.
I spent a few minutes browsing http://my.clevelandclinic.org/ http://my.clevelandclinic.org/ - the Ohio Cleveland Clinic has over 3,000 physicians and scientists, 1,700 residents and fellows in training, with 47 buildings on 167 acres. They helped develop coronary bypass surgery in 1967.
Shetty (the "Henry Ford of heart surgery") is standing on the shoulders of giants, and as well he should. The Cleveland Clinic and Narayana Hrudayalaya coexist symbiotically, and I'm happy we have both in the world. Coronary bypass surgery has to be invented first at Cleveland Clinic before Shetty can put it on the assembly line.
If you have the time, read the Cleveland Clinic's 2012 Annual Report (http://viewer.zmags.com/publication/71bd62a6#/71bd62a6/1 http://viewer.zmags.com/publication/71bd62a6#/71bd62a6/1) and you can see what they think they are doing differently to provide the best service, continue driving innovative research, support their local community, and reduce costs. Take a minute to appreciate the breadth of research that goes on in their facilities, in areas including high-performance computing, robotics, 3D printing...
Cleveland Clinic had $228m in Operating Income on $6.2b in Revenue in 2012. Their $6b in expenses are dominated by $3.5 billion in "salaries, wages, and benefits" which unfortunately is not broken down much further that I could find in the report. "Functionally" their expenses are $4.7b healthcare services, $450m on education and research, and $663m on G&A. I was disappointed to see their education and research expenses are less than their G&A, but it's hard to draw conclusions from such high-level data. It was interesting to note they have $1.6b of accumulated pension benefits, which are 68% funded.
Unfortunately there doesn't appear to be anything resembling a financial statement on http://www.narayanahospitals.com/ http://www.narayanahospitals.com/.