3 ms·
The comments here seem to miss Taleb's central idea that harm is non-binary. You need to consider not just whether something occurs, but how much impact it has.
by graeme 13y ago
The comments here seem to miss Taleb's central idea that harm is non-binary. You need to consider not just whether something occurs, but how much impact it has.
I don't care whether a bank earns a financial gain or a loss. I care how big the gain or loss is. One hundred years of small profits can be wiped out in one bad quarter.
I do not believe Taleb is proposing punishing all risk taking. He's advocated aggressively taking risks where the downside is known.
The problem we face is that many are now in a position to get a limited, positive upside if things go well, but they face no downside. And the potential harm in such situations has no upper bound.
Skin in the game ought to be proportional to harm. Many comments mention medicine as a profession that should not have skin in the game.
Rubbish. Doctors are very liable if things go wrong. But it depends how wrong. We don't hold doctors accountable for small errors, or random errors.
We hold them accountable for big errors. The bigger the error, the worse the punishment.
- khawkins 13y agoThere's an issue in convincing people that harm is completely continuous. If there is a perception that there is some culpability in performing some action, regardless of how small, then it is easy to exaggerate it to a significant quantity in their mind. This would make society increasingly hostile and litigious for even small gestures like offering to watch their stuff while they visit the restroom.