4 ms·
OTOH, you feel safer if the 911 dispatcher is sitting in a far-away call-center and not freaking out because she's at the scene with you, and you feel safer if
by nostrademons 13y ago
OTOH, you feel safer if the 911 dispatcher is sitting in a far-away call-center and not freaking out because she's at the scene with you, and you feel safer if the surgeon is a dispassionate expert at their field and not the patient's mother. You'd feel better being represented by a lawyer who is not on trial with you than one who is.
I think a lot of this depends upon whether the task calls for a rational or emotional response. For tasks that require a rational response, having "skin in the game" can cloud your judgment and make you perform worse than if you were a dispassionate observer. For tasks that require an emotional investment, you want the person's risks and incentives to be aligned with yours. (For example, you want a product designer to actually use the products they design, and you want a teacher to care about your kids as much as you care about them.)
- graeme 13y agoYou didn't really respond to OP's point. They said some skin in the game is sufficient. A surgeon faces large legal risks for a botched surgery. A lawyer is likewise legally responsible for his actions. Doctors and lawyers are two of the professions with the most skin in the game! I don't know enough about 9/11 dispatchers to say if they face liability.