2 ms·
His point is that there's rarely a reputational hit for being wrong in those professions. There should be, but there isn't. Examples: Thomas Friedman supporte
by graeme 13y ago
His point is that there's rarely a reputational hit for being wrong in those professions. There should be, but there isn't.
Examples:
Thomas Friedman supported the Iraq war.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwFaSpca_3Q http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwFaSpca_3Q
Joseph Stiglitze and Peter Orzag predicted Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac faced near zero risk.
Stiglitz later claimed credit for predicting the financial crisis(!) and Orzag had a prominent position in Obama's administration
http://www.pierrelemieux.org/stiglitzrisk.pdf http://www.pierrelemieux.org/stiglitzrisk.pdf
What commentator can you think of that's lost his job for a bad prediction?
Pundit's have perverse incentives. They can point to correct predictions to boost their career, and they are penalized very little for wrong ones.
They have an incentive to make many predictions, and retrospectively choose to highlight only those that panned out.
- TheCowboy 13y agoTo be fair, Fannie Mae changed its practices, engaging in the risky "financial innovations" that caused problems for a lot financial institutions, after Stiglitz' original study of their exposure to risk. It is not as if Stiglitz was in control of the institution or encouraged that they engage in these more risky behaviors. It is more like a doctor performing a check-up on a patient, which represents a mere snapshot in time, saying they're in good health. And then the patient decides it's okay to start smoking, eating fastfood for every meal, and giving up exercise. Are you going to blame the doctor for not warning this could happen? I would say the stronger lesson is that continued checks and oversight are critical to the health of any institution or business. Though I do also agree and think people who make sloppy predictions should also be held accountable for their behavior.