3 ms·
It's kinda interesting that the modern corporation was explicitly designed to shield the decision-makers from risk. Without it, many of the large industrial &
by nostrademons 13y ago
It's kinda interesting that the modern corporation was explicitly designed to shield the decision-makers from risk. Without it, many of the large industrial & trade breakthroughs of the enlightenment wouldn't have been possible, as nobody would've been willing to take the personal risk of venturing to the Indies or setting up a cotton mill when the downside of failure was perpetual indentured servitude.
I don't think it's bad to require some skin in the game, but require too much and many risks that are quite beneficial to society as a whole just won't happen.
- ronilan 13y ago> "nobody would've been willing to take the personal risk of venturing to the Indies" Made me think of this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pM-igYjn6E4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pM-igYjn6E4 The corporation sheilds from financial risk, thus enabeling an actual risk. When latter is missing the problem of lack of skin may appear.
- lmkg 13y agoPartially disagree. The original necessity of corporations was to distribute risk, not to remove it. There was the same total risk, but born across a wider number of people. The financial risk was unchanged, but the consequences were made less catastrophic. Equivalently, a corporation aggregates enough resources for the risk to become rational. By contrast, one of the functions of modern corporations is that culpability does not pass-through to the decision-makers. This is an actual removal of risk, not re-distribution, as there are consequences that a corporation is not capable of facing.
- pash 13y agoI was thinking about this the other day. Just as with joint-stock ownership, legally limiting financial liability redistributes risk (by transferring it to creditors), but doesn't reduce it in net. Creditors tend to be established firms and bankrupt companies tend to be new, small enterprises, so it seems that limited liability promotes socially beneficial risk-taking by offloading bad outcomes on those who are best able to absorb them. ... "From each according to his ability, ..."
- bcbrown 13y agoWell, it caps risk, but doesn't remove it. Whomever owns the corporation presumably put some equity into it, right? That's the amount they have at risk.
- alan-crowe 13y agoThe cap is about as low as it could be. The investors put up capital which is committed to the ordinary operation of the business. Buy some materials, hire some workmen, make some stuff. Perhaps none of it sells even at 90% off. The capital is gone. BUT the investors were never on the hook for any extra. One could imagine company law creating a same-again limitation on liability. If you invest a million dollars, you have two reasons to watch the management you appoint, first they could lose your investment. Second if they screw up and do a lot of damage the investors are on the hook for the same again; potentially another million dollars. It is quite a tricky proposal to analyze. Consider the common practice of supplying goods on 30 days credit. It is slightly risky. The purchaser might go bust without paying. Under current once-only limitation of liability it is common for suppliers to lose out, which can cause a ripple effect as one company goes bust, causes its suppliers to fail causing their suppliers to fail... Under same-again limited liability the ripples go in a different direction as investors liquidate assets to meet "second" liabilities.