3 ms·
> The mechanism by which patents work, though, is by (temporarily) banning competition. Yes, for valid cases, since patent is a limited monopoly. Thing is, sof
by shmerl 13y ago
> The mechanism by which patents work, though, is by (temporarily) banning competition.
Yes, for valid cases, since patent is a limited monopoly. Thing is, software is an invalid case to begin with for a number of reasons, including patent thickets issue.
- axman6 13y agoYou mean the same issue that's faced many other fields of endeavour in the past, all of which still exist today? It will always be an issue in new technologies, there's no easy to avoid it. I'm still yet to find a good reason why there should be a blanket ban on software patents. There are many inventions which are simply not possible without software, but if you're right, that invention is worthless. I'm sure you'd be quite happy for the first invention that uses two fingers to say open a mechanism, but now software happens to be involved, it's completely obvious? What a joke. My other problem with this whole "Ban software patents because they're bad because I say they are" circlejerk that goes on HN is that you don't see any of the good patents, you just look at the tentative/borderline/outright invalid cases. There are many inventions which are truly novel and inventive in the software world, but you choose to ignore them because of the few bad ones. It's akin to saying all blacks are criminals because there's a higher percentage in prison, or all Toyotas are shit because some of them had break problems. It's just another form if gross selection bias, and you should be aware that there's much more good in the system than the media would have you realise.