4 ms·
"receivers cost £2,000 per vessel" Hmm, yes kind of like how a new GPS costs $5K, because the first .mil model did cost that much. Or all computers currently
by VLM 13y ago
"receivers cost £2,000 per vessel"
Hmm, yes kind of like how a new GPS costs $5K, because the first .mil model did cost that much. Or all computers currently cost millions of dollars because the first ones did.
- snom380 13y agoA new GPS made for commercial, certified use (eg. for use in aviation) will cost way more that $5K. Just a software update to it might cost as much. Technology is getting cheaper, certifying it isn't. In don't know about ships, but I assume there is some form of certification for nav equipment there as well.
- D9u 13y agoI don't know about presently, but in the past the GPS transmitters had an introduced error known as "Selective Availability," the purpose of which was to deny pin-point accuracy to unauthorized devices. For a price, one could acquire the necessary hardware/software to mitigate Selective Availability in order to increase the accuracy of GPS readings, although I forget what those prices were/are.
- joosters 13y agoGPS used to be that way to give the military access to accurate positioning and provide lower accuracy to others. They can still do this selectively to whole areas of the world should they want to.
- bigiain 13y agoThis probably still mostly true. The US claim that since 2008 they've been launching GPS satellites without selective availability capabilities. That means 27 of the current working GPS satellites are older ones which do have SA which could be switched back on at any time, and 12 are newer allegedly non-SA equipped satellites.
- mikestew 13y agoSelective Availability hasn't been used for over a decade: http://www.gps.gov/systems/gps/modernization/sa/ http://www.gps.gov/systems/gps/modernization/sa/
- bigiain 13y agoI remember reading a fascinating article (which seems to elude me on Google right now) about the competitors in the 1990 BOC single handed Around the World yacht race noticing the CEP (circular error probable) on their GPS devices drop from ~100m down to ~10m or better in late July – a week or so before the Gulf War officially started. They didn't permanently switch off Selective Availability til mid 2000, but they could and did temporarily switch it off when it suited them (and, no doubt, could easily switch it back on today if they thought it worthwhile… They claim any satellites launched since 2008 haven't had SA capability, but I suspect that's only a small-ish percentage of the GPS constellation today…)
- jevinskie 13y agoSA has been turned off, at least for now and at least in the US.
- hga 13y agoErrr, as I read it, the cost is for new eLoran receivers, intended to be an alternative backup to the Mark I eyeball if GPS flakes out for whatever reason. Not going to be widely deployed like GPS receivers, and big ships need reliability ... in fact, the only customers are those who really need this sort of thing, unless it becomes mandated.
- ThatGeoGuy 13y agoAs somebody who's primary field of study is GPS / Navigation / Positioning, I'd like to remark that survey grade receivers such as in the eLoran stations can cost much, much more than £2,000. Their price isn't so much the hardware itself, in fact, most of the receivers seen in cell phones today cost less than $1USD. However, when dealing with more accurate receivers, the receivers typically need extensive calibration and testing. I mean, it's possible to get measurements from GPS accurate to 1mm, but you need to have both a careful setup and very good knowledge about the errors associated with your receiver. So yeah, these receivers are actually quite expensive, and most of it is because the calibration on repeatability and stability of these sensors is of the utmost importance. On a secondary note, survey-grade receivers are typically not as prone to jamming as consumer-grade receivers, mostly because they can use multiple GPS frequencies / can collect over a wider bandwidth. There's a lot more to it than that, but effectively the point I'm making is that the receivers spoken of in the article are not the same as everyday GPS receivers. If you want to see how crazy the prices on these receivers can get, look no further than http://www.surveyorsmart.com/product.sc?productId=548 http://www.surveyorsmart.com/product.sc?productId=548. I doubt many surveyors would go for that particular model by Leica, as it is definitely expensive, even for survey equipment standards, but it's not unreal in terms of pricing.
- joosters 13y ago1mm?
- hga 13y agoYep, I gather that nowadays they use this type of instrument to measure e.g. how fast California is sliding into the Pacific ^_^.
- andrewcooke 13y agothis is actually easier in some ways because it's so slow you can integrate forever and so reduce noise (both "normal" noise and the added stuff, if they are still doing that).
- 13y ago
- bkanber 13y agoThere are different grades of GPS receivers, all licensed differently. Consumer-grade receivers have a maximum accuracy of something like 3 meters and a slow response time. There are also aviation grade and military grade receivers, which cost more (build & calibration) but also require a special license.
- ballard 13y agoI interned at Trimble in the radio group. Industrial GPS receivers could be purchased by more / less anyone, however they were built and priced for heavy-duty industrial consumption (mines, farms, ships, aircraft, etc.). The unassisted accuracy without kinematic corrections was around +- 1 m horizonal and ~10 m vertical, constantly changing as the constellation moves. This would be for a top-of-the-line 24 channel parallel receiver. WITH kinematic GPS, +- 10 mm (not a typo) horizonal and ~3 m vertical. It was so good that receivers could be installed on the left and right sides of a grader's blade that the angle and position could be known with great accuracy and precision. Kinematic means a nearby stationary reference ground base station sending updates over radio frequencies to another GPS receiver that could be in motion. This was also used to subtract SA pre-Clinton because the injected error would be the same in nearby locations.
- randomdata 13y ago$5K doesn't seem out of the question. Even commonly found used receivers can go into the thousands of dollars. Ex: http://www.agdealer.com/list/view_image.cfm?ID=401541 http://www.agdealer.com/list/view_image.cfm?ID=401541