4 ms·
I still don't get why people are attached to the concept of company loyalty in the first place. Maybe it made sense back in the era where you'd work for a compa
by kevingadd 13y ago
I still don't get why people are attached to the concept of company loyalty in the first place. Maybe it made sense back in the era where you'd work for a company for 2+ decades and retire on a pension, but we don't live in that world anymore.
Loyalty is earned, not implicitly deserved. There are thousands of companies out there where a software engineer can show up, do quality work, and draw a salary and benefits. The fact that a company like Google happens to have an on-site masseuse or slightly better 401k plan doesn't really mean anything at all; there are way bigger factors to consider: work/life balance, healthy management and corporate structure, good project planning, opportunities for personal growth, etc.
A company that big tends to have a lot of project churn and waste, too, so it's not unnatural for some of that churn and waste to result in more people leaving than might be the average at a smaller company.
- saraid216 13y ago> I still don't get why people are attached to the concept of company loyalty in the first place. Maybe it made sense back in the era where you'd work for a company for 2+ decades and retire on a pension, but we don't live in that world anymore. Why not? What changed? It's not enough reason to dismiss a concept by saying, "Times changed." You have to examine why they changed and whether or not the things lost are worth preserving or reinventing for the new era.
- makmanalp 13y agoGood question. I keep answering this one and I hope it becomes a more common question. Let's start with at-will employment. Basically, when I'm hired, I sign a document that says that the company may fire me whenever it feels like it, no questions asked, with 2 weeks notice. During my parents' generation, you'd get hired provisionally for a short term contract, and then if they like you you'd be hired in the longer term (year to 5-year). If this is the kind of loyalty we get from companies these days, then what kind of loyalty do they deserve? At will employment goes both ways, of course. I can quit whenever I want. It's also up to an employer to keep their offer competitive. If I have a potentially better deal somewhere else, why shouldn't I go there? The default reaction of employers to increasing market salaries is to ignore that fact unless you specifically go ask for a raise or comply with some set of arbitrary rules. How is that a demonstration of goodwill? If you want me to stay, you have to pay me what I'm worth. If you don't think I'm worth that, but I think I am, why is it surprising that I'd change jobs? If I succeeded in changing, clearly someone agreed with me. If you want me to stay despite non-stellar salary / benefits, you'd better have some other benefit such as: a) your product is my baby and I get personal recognition b) good career development & learning opportunities c) a potential to be great. Basically, if you want me to take a chance on you, you have to take a chance on me.
- Jormundir 13y agoExactly.
- rtkwe 13y agoWell the most obvious way that things have changed is that pensions are largely a relic now with most companies now using 401Ks where they're not liable for the retirements of their workers.
- specialist 13y agoWhat changed? The '80s happened. Greed is good. The decades of corporatist funded libertarian populist propaganda finally started to work. Supply side economics. Mergers and acquisitions. Corporate raiders. Looting pensions. Gaming investment vehicles, or outright fraud. Long-term sustained assault on labor. Offshoring, outsourcing, guest workers. Regressive taxation. Defaults. Bailouts. Deficit spending. Etc.
- LockeWatts 13y agoThe inclusion of the word 'populist' in this post confuses me. Does populist not mean 'for the people', and thus not aligned with the rest of your list?
- rdouble 13y agoIn the negative sense of the word, 'populist' is often used to suggest that 'the people' have been manipulated into promoting something that is actually not in their best interest.
- LockeWatts 13y agoAaah, today I learned. I understand.
- saraid216 13y agoWhile the rest of your comment is arguably useful, > The '80s happened. is the exact kind of response I was complaining about. This one sentence says nothing.
- serf 13y agoHe's not referring to a specific generation of people, but rather a decade that held capitalistic intentions high throughout the world, for good or worse. It says something to me.
- specialist 13y ago
- Domenic_S 13y agoThe fact is that you're going to get discouraged/bored/antsy at any job, no matter how awesome it is, and loyalty keeps you floating through the lows. It's impossible to accomplish anything without both ups and downs. If workers quit every time there's a low ("SUBJECT: Mandatory reorg meeting 11am"), a company wouldn't get anything done. Likewise, the worker wouldn't get the benefit of seeing a long-term vision through to the end. In the old days, the pot-sweetener for sticking it out through the lows was a pension; these days it's RSUs (for BigCo) & options/ownership (for startups & execs). It's easy to show up and do quality work when things are rosy at the company. It's not so easy to plow through when things are bad. But if you give up when things are bad you miss out on the good things to come. That's the function of loyalty.
- kevingadd 13y agoComparing RSUs and options with a pension is insane. The former has a net negative value for you in the average case even if the exceptional case has it making you money.