3 ms·
Well, there was a big controversy over basing your protocols on datagrams with stateless nodes in the middle. The CCITT's X.25 didn't. When I was working for
by hga 13y ago
Well, there was a big controversy over basing your protocols on datagrams with stateless nodes in the middle. The CCITT's X.25 didn't.
When I was working for Lisp Machines Inc. (LMI) in 1982-3, when TCP/IP was being mandated for the Arpanet (and therefore Lisp Machines, sometime I worked on at LMI), I can remember the father of the Lisp Machine, Richard Greenblatt, arguing that it wouldn't work because too many packets would get lost in the middle. With stateless nodes---a necessary virtue for the small memory minicomputers the Arpanet was built on---re-transmission has to come from the endpoints, and if the error rate was too high it would have failed to be practical. Look at TCP over ATM for a modern example of this sort of lossage.
I assume Vint Cerf et. al. did the math based on observed error rates, then tested it to make sure (TCP/IP and NCP ran side by side for some time on the Arpanet) and Greenblatt, who was rather distracted designing his 3rd generation Lisp Machine, was going by general principles.