4 ms·
I'm more impressed with the book than the review. It's a good review, no doubt, but I think Aaronson, while catching Wolfram using a bit of hyperbole on occasi
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
I'm more impressed with the book than the review.
It's a good review, no doubt, but I think Aaronson, while catching Wolfram using a bit of hyperbole on occasions, misses the essence of what NKS is.
It's not simply a review of existing CS theory.
The Feynman quote was quite illuminating. Wolfram does take the discrete conversation to the next step. He doesn't answer the questions, mainly because what he is proposing is, well, a New Kind of Science. Which means that there are going to be hundreds or thousands of questions.
What might be missing the most is a methodology for exploration. But I think overall Wolfram is just a bit ahead of his time. Those things will be worked out.
- slackenerny 18y agoBecause it was no review but an analysis. Review is when renowed reviewer gives his opinion which is backed by his authority. When your'e a poor grad student, like Aaronson in 2002, then you better withold emotional opinons and give facts. he is proposing And what Aaronson analyses is that book's statements form no proposal.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoHe isn't remotely proposing a new kind of science. All he is proposing is to do regular science, but use cellular automata as a framework for new theories (rather than PDEs).