15 ms·
Ink – Interface Kit
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gregorkas 13y agoHow is this different from Bootstrap (http://twitter.github.io/bootstrap/ http://twitter.github.io/bootstrap/)?
- aren55555 13y agoServes the same purpose (building a UI) but seems to have style differences and a few different JS UI plugins.
- rcarmo 13y agoWhich, incidentally, don't require you to use jQuery. Just sayin'. (it's agnostic).
- rfnslyr 13y agoLiterally JUST a skin. No idea how this crap gets voted up.
- JohnDotAwesome 13y agoIs it _literally_ just a skin? Looks like a mostly different codebase. Compare mixins.less https://github.com/sapo/Ink/blob/develop/less/modules/mixins.less https://github.com/sapo/Ink/blob/develop/less/modules/mixins... https://github.com/twbs/bootstrap/blob/master/less/mixins.less https://github.com/twbs/bootstrap/blob/master/less/mixins.le... Personally, I like it. It's nice to have competition :)
- ceejayoz 13y agohttp://theoatmeal.com/comics/literally http://theoatmeal.com/comics/literally
- fredoliveira 13y agoI don't think you read the source code. At all.
- rcarmo 13y agoNope, not a skin. It's a very different beast in terms of grid layouts, for instance.
- pedroscs 13y agoIt is definitely not a skin. I can tell you we started for scratch. I'm on the Dev team.
- ceejayoz 13y agoAt this point, if your CSS framework doesn't start with "why we're different/better than Bootstrap" I'm pretty much out. I skimmed the docs and see very little here that isn't a direct "Bootstrap does that, we'll do that too".
- chrischen 13y agoThey support IE7, which I believe Bootstrap 3 has dropped. If you don't do the comparison yourself, you're at risk of losing out.
- ceejayoz 13y agoI'm at risk of losing out if I have to go through 20 pages of documentation and compare line-for-line against Bootstrap rather than the creator going "we decided not to just re-skin Bootstrap primarily for reasons A, B, and C".
- chrischen 13y agoI'm going to reveal a big secret. I actually managed to find out the tidbit about IE 7 without reading it line by line. Their primary job is not marketing. Their primary job is to build the framework. Why do you think things like Y Combinator exists? They do some work others aren't willing to and others lose out because of it. It's to the developer's benefit to tell you why his product is good, but it's not their duty. These guys worked on and released a free product for you. You can choose to use it if you want but they don't owe you anything or an explanation of why it's better than Bootstrap.
- orky56 13y agoForms is a nice addition over Bootstrap for me.
- wut42 13y agoBootstrap has always had forms.
- rcarmo 13y agoWe have always been at war with Eurasia :) Seriously now, yes, Bootstrap has always had forms. But as a developer who merely dabbles in design, I personally prefer Ink's markup because it's responsive off the bat (at least compared to BS 2.0, haven't tried 3.0).
- davidroetzel 13y agoWe desperately need something like todomvc for ui kits.
- ChrisClark 13y agohttp://ink.sapo.pt/icons#nav-textedit http://ink.sapo.pt/icons#nav-textedit The link for Text Editor Icons is broken because the id for that section is set to nav-web. A copy-paste error most likely.
- rcarmo 13y agoThanks for the heads-up!
- rokusho 13y agoIt feels to close to Bootstrap without bringing enough new stuff to the table to be worth it. It's nice to see people making alternatives, but it needs to be a lot more developed.
- rcarmo 13y agoWell, like I said above, it addresses some internal issues my colleagues had. It also tries to make a lot of things simpler for web designers (especially regarding the grid system) without tying you down too much.
- MattStopa 13y agoNo it's awesome! Don't listen to the downers. It is a lot easier to use than Bootstrap. Fewer elements, etc
- bstar77 13y agoI like the idea of having interface "skins", but I honestly could not tell this one apart from Bootstrap. I would love to see more varying interface styles, not another bootstrap clone.
- windsurfer 13y agoI thought this was built on top of bootstrap.
- ditados 13y agoIt's not. It's a completely different codebase.
- joeblau 13y agoIt looks good; You should add your framework to: http://usablica.github.io/front-end-frameworks/compare.html http://usablica.github.io/front-end-frameworks/compare.html
- chuckd1356 13y agoYet another! Foundation, Bootstrap, 960, unsemantic, etc.
- film42 13y agoI think this is cool, so I say good job on that front. But I kind of feel like you're trying to introduce yet another low end sedan. There's already hundreds, and I've already purchased one. It's gonna take at least a few more years for me to be ready to shop for a new one.
- rcarmo 13y agoWell, we're not actually selling, but rather giving it away :) Seriously now, it's been in internal use for a good while because it solved problems that Bootstrap didn't address (like the particular grid flavour and some corner cases in responsive layouts), and the best way gather feedback and improve it is, of course, making it public.
- film42 13y agoIt's a technical debt metaphor. Myself and the company I work for have all learned the caveats of bootstrap and how to hack through them. Now it's happily sitting in most, if not all, of our projects. It just doesn't make sense for us to change at this point.
- mmatants 13y agoCan we please come up with a better markup for form element grouping than "div.control-group"? Specifically, HTML has always allowed nesting an <input> inside <label> - and that's more than enough to create either a horizontal or stacked layout. No <div>s needed. And no "for" attribute needed with an unnecessary input ID.
- orky56 13y agoThat's a fair point. Although div's are not completely necessary for this purpose from a functional perspective, the standard definitely allows one to understand/create the layout of the page more efficiently.
- lewisflude 13y agoSometimes introducing more markup can be better architecturally. I agree, .control-group isn't the nicest way of doing things but I don't think nesting an input inside a label is any better.
- mmatants 13y agoI do not see any disadvantages to nesting inputs inside labels - and it's actually quite semantic and maintainable (in part because inputs no longer need auto-generated IDs). This approach has been part of the HTML standard pretty much always, as well. It doesn't matter much if forms are generated using a builder like Formtastic, etc. But even then less custom CSS classes is usually better. This way I have been able to write CSS for fairly complex forms using just standard tag selectors, with just one class on the root form container to separate multiple form styles.
- tracker1 13y agoWhen you put a label with text and the input inside, how would you get the text to take up 150px and the input to be to the right of that consistently across a large form? Such as here: https://www.roadreadycertified.com/order/begin/ https://www.roadreadycertified.com/order/begin/ Note: It's just an example, not promoting the site.
- orky56 13y agoAs someone who hasn't integrated Bootstrapped before, I have a clean slate to evaluate and use any interface kit that comes along. As long as it's more comprehensive that what's currently out there, it doesn't matter so much to me how much more of an improvement this latest project is over the prior standard.
- bbayer 13y agoI like the colors and type of default theme of framework. It really looks neat. On the other hand, used markup looks less than Bootstrap. It definitely could be a selling point. Large screen concept and flexible columns also looks very good. I can give them a try.
- rcarmo 13y agoPlease do, and feel free to file issues on Github: https://github.com/sapo/Ink https://github.com/sapo/Ink
- rithi 13y agoI have only tried out YUI pure and went back to bootstrap almost immediately. This feels more complete - I particularly like the icon collection.
- JelteF 13y agoThe icon collection is worth a look for any web project. It's an icon font, so colours and scaling can just be done with css. Very easily integrable with Bootstrap as well, just include the css after the Bootstrap css and it works. (All you might have to test is icons that are a different colour now since they just use the font colour) http://fortawesome.github.io/Font-Awesome/examples/ http://fortawesome.github.io/Font-Awesome/examples/
- ajsharma 13y agoCame across this UI kit a while back. I like their solution of a glossary page to show all classes in use: http://ink.sapo.pt/glossary http://ink.sapo.pt/glossary
- joshuacc 13y agoOne thing I like about this is that most of the class names are namespaced (as "ink-something"), unlike most of the other ui frameworks I've looked at. This makes it a lot simpler to integrate into an existing site without accidentally dealing with conflicting class names.
- rcarmo 13y agoYeah, that was one of the goals. Ink is supposed to co-exist with existing layouts when you have a legacy to maintain.
- BSousa 13y agoFirst of all congratulations or Parabens :) Nice to see some portuguese projects here. On a unrelated note, how did this end up on as the musicbox website framework? I worked in this project a while ago (backend and frontend clients only) and had no idea who did the musicbox.sapo.pt frontend.
- rcarmo 13y agoWell, IIRC Ink came about due to the need to quickly build out sites like that (you'll notice SAPO is involved in a bunch of other services like that), and things dovetailed together when the site was revised recently.
- desireco42 13y agoI welcome the intent which I understand is to provide another point of view on css frameworks. Honestly like others, I am a little overwhelmed with multitude of css frameworks. I think the point was to have a framework to provide aggregation and organization of multiple tools you used previously. For me Bootstrap, Zurb are currently only really interesting in a sense I would use them in projects. For a while I used Skeleton, I think it lost pace a little and I get same benefits with Zurb. Again, I welcome your vision of organized front-end, would appreciate a page that would outline differences and specific benefits.
- pedroscs 13y agoIf everyone's wondering how Ink is different from Bootstrap, the answer is: mainly in how Ink builds layouts. Instead of the column span philosophy, Ink uses percentage based blocks. That alone is a big difference.
- pedrocorreia 13y agoDon't forget to mention that although we as a default support 3 screen sizes, our grid system is configurable, so you can add or remove as many breakpoints for as many screens as necessary. All with a couple of lines of code.
- philip1209 13y agoRandom, but I think the site could benefit from font pairing. Ubuntu is pretty for the titles, but the body could use something less ornate.
- bdcravens 13y agoAt first I thought the filepicker.io folks, who recently rebranded as Ink, had released a UI kit. Of course they don't own those 3 letters which have a wide array of meaning, similar to words like "bootstrap", "ember", "buffer", or "backbone". I'd be hesitant to use those words in a product, open source or otherwise, however.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pedalpete 13y agoI may give this a shot. The way they manage columns without needing to specify the number of columns in a div seems nice. For instance, if I want a two column layout, I put two divs inside the '.column-group' container. Now (theoretically) if I were to dynamically add a third column, it seems that Ink would automatically adjust the other two columns to fit. With bootstrap, I would need to change the '.spanx' of each div within the '.row'
- suskind 13y agoUsing Ink you just need to use math. Using "large/medium/small" prefixes and specifying the percentage of each column (large-50 medium-50 small-100) Take a look at http://ink.sapo.pt/layout http://ink.sapo.pt/layout
- ChikkaChiChi 13y agoI dig the way this handles multiple screen sizes instead of responsiveness, but my lifelong question continues to go unanswered: Why does the W3C and every CSS framework avoid making 'center' a thing? Yes, I know how to do it myself...I'm just saying that it has its place. Doesn't it?
- MattStopa 13y agoI personally think this looks great. I was kinda of burnt out of Bootstrap. I'm gonna give it a shot!
- engleek 13y agoAlthough it looks a lot like Bootstrap, the code is very different. For one thing they really do use LESS. The code is full of variables and mixins, much more than Bootstrap. The custom Javascript Core is interesting too. Now just hesitating because of the end CSS size. 160KB minified is nearly twice the size of Bootstrap.