3 ms·
> As always the solution to a low ebb in HN quality is to post interesting content, or even better to write some. This is an economics problem: * Posting an o
by davidw 13y ago
> As always the solution to a low ebb in HN quality is to post interesting content, or even better to write some.
This is an economics problem:
* Posting an outrage story written by someone else, or a political article: cheap.
* Writing good, interesting, and thoughtful content yourself: expensive.
The relative quantities of the two goods, without any intervention, is left as an exercise to the reader.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoso ... if you wrote the original, you get karma, if you just post the original, you get 1/x Karma? seems, interesting. Would encourage less posting, more thoughtful commenting.
- yareally 13y agoPerhaps amending to that a filter to that which gives less upvotes for submissions that are repetitive based on url, page title and article keywords during a certain period of time. Though the only problem with that would be if early submissions are of less quality and get upvoted while ones that come slightly later are of higher quality.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoI would go for the brute force approach - write your own good articles, write your own good comments. Otherwise, its just "hey look world this one is interesting" with nothing back
- brudgers 13y agoOne solution is to write something really fucking great. Doing so is left as an exercise for the writer. Those economics are not restricted to stories about politics. Remember the days when the front page would be flodded every time the MacBook Pro got longer screws, a couple of megahertz processor speed, and a bigger base hard drive? There have always been cheap and easy stories. There always will be. If you run a zeitgeist, it comes in the box.
- davidw 13y ago> One solution is to write something really fucking great. No, it isn't. I thought the logic was pretty clear: In the time it takes one person to write a great article - assuming they're capable of it, which not all of us are - another person can submit 100's of low value links, some of which will get a lot of votes because they're about high-passion, high-profile topics.
- brudgers 13y agoThe logic was clear and its ongoing attractiveness as a first approximation of HN empirically demonstrated over the years. Sometimes, I find it an attractive first approximation. However, I recognize that my dog, Scarlett, is an animal and therefore to a first approximation an insect. Yet, I do not squash her when she's in the bed with me, nor spread chemicals to prevent her entry to the house, nor scrupulously remove all potential food sources. We agree that there is an endless supply of HN submissions. Though we may disagree about which is which, we also agree that some are better and some are worse. We also agree that there is virtually no barrier to entry in regards to becoming a supplier of articles to HN. The points at which I find dissonance in the market model are: () The supply of karma points is also unlimited. I can create a karma point for another HN'er. Of course, I can destroy a karma point for another HN'er, but only to a more limited degree; at least I understand that there's throttling in the software. () Karma points are not fungible. I cannot exchange them for anything - except in a limited sense snark that I am willing to have downvoted, a practice in which I have occasionally engaged. () Thus, if there is a market of the sort amenable to economic market theories, it is the sort of market which is for all practical purposes entirely illiquid. I don't know enough economic theory to suggest that such markets are not the subject of voluminous academic research, but supposing they are, that perhaps still suggests dubiousness in the first order approximation. Teasing out the interesting facts about HN requires, in my opinion, a better abstraction. I prefer a political model. HN has some democratic institutions - like one account one vote. It even has some aspects of Athenian democracy where the mob gets to vote on daily decisions regarding articles, and as in Socrates day, rhetoric oft sways the passions and ballots of men (and unlike his day, women). More specifically, I prefer the republic - in the platonic sense - as an abstraction for modeling online communities. Ultimately there is a sovereign with whom we form a Hobbesian compact. Participation in a compact with HN requires us to give up certain rights in exchange for a particular form of security. The rights we give up to HN's sovereign and the security we gain are distinct from what we give up and obtain from the sovereign of StackOverflow or MSDNtechnet, or a professional cycling website. The security we gain is largely that of reasonable norms. But among the rights we give up is that of not being subject to unreasonable policies at the extreme and policies with which we may niggle in the common.