8 ms·
>>You don't see this kind of innovation in the American health system because it has been engineered with greed in mind right from the start. As an Indian, I c
by kamaal 13y ago
>>You don't see this kind of innovation in the American health system because it has been engineered with greed in mind right from the start.
As an Indian, I can tell you people here think the same about our health care system. The Doctor in discussion here, Dr Devi Shetty is a sort of a local hero here in Bangalore. And who knows in some years he might as well be a national hero. Its basically because he seems to bring in advantages of doing things in volume + some health insurance based innovations into the whole equation. And I do agree that he is pragmatically altruistic. But such people are exceedingly rare. We are simply fortunate to have him.
I've never been to US, but I can tell you the Indian health care system is if not less is equally greedy compared to their US counterparts. Its just the same.
These days if you don't have health insurance you are more or less screwed. Its just like the US. I mean from whatever I've read about US so far its the very same. Nothing changes. You just feel its cheaper as $1 = 60 rupees. There you get a straight 60x value of your money. That is what it is at the end of the day.
Coming to our system. Forget greed, fraud in the system is so massively high nothing that I write here will explain it. It is extremely common for doctors to order lab tests wholesale even if they are dead sure the patient has no problems at all. Doctors get commissions from testing labs/pharmacies etc for ordering lab tests, medicines. Treatment is purposefully prolonged, patients made to eat all kinds of antibiotics, undergo all sorts of non sense tests because doctors get commissions for it.
The fees for completing your medical course is astronomically high. Capitation fee often runs in crores, the net fee by the time you finish your MD is so high no doubt most doctors have to practically turn into crooks to get something out of it. Add to this nearly more than a decade of studies sets a perfect stage for these sort of activities to happen.
Its just the same old game, as you see in US. Just served differently.
- acchow 13y ago> You just feel its cheaper as $1 = 60 rupees. There you get a straight 60x value of your money. That is what it is at the end of the day. I find the vast majority of people are tripped up by currency conversion, but I'm surprised to find this on HN. In Japan $1 = 100 yen, but certainly I don't feel I have 100x in buying power. A bowl of ramen will cost me $8 in SF; an equivalent bowl will cost me 800 JPY in tokyo. Let's not even get started on the Korean Won...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- kokey 13y agoI'm surprised that how many otherwise smart people gets tripped up by this. The only time you can deduce something from the exchange rate is if you compare the difference between the two rates over a longer period of time. Then it can roughly tell you things about difference in direction of inflation between the two countries, and the effect on wages and imports/exports. If the difference between the exchange rate between two countries doesn't change for a long time the prices of goods in both countries end up being roughly the same.
- endeavour 13y ago"If the difference between the exchange rate between two countries doesn't change for a long time the prices of goods in both countries end up being roughly the same." Simply not true. Compare the cost of a beer in, say, Thailand and Norway. Are you suggesting if the exchange rate were fixed they would reach parity over time?
- vbuterin 13y agoAssuming no new disruptions, then yes, economic conditions in the two countries would eventually equalize and prices would differ by at most the shipping cost if one of the two countries happens to have much better natural conditions for producing beer than the other. It's because disruptions are now becoming (have become?) the norm that equilibrium never has time to come close to manifesting itself.
- mistermann 13y agoAlcohol is a poor example because of special taxation. The Big Mac index is better for many reasons, one being Mcdonalds is large enough to mostly optimize everything wherever they operate: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Mac_Index http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Mac_Index
- 13y ago
- barking 13y agoIn agricultural terminology you can either pay people 'by the day' or pay them 'by the hundred yards'. I have worked in both types of systems and can see merits and pitfalls in both. In the former system there can woeful output whilst in the latter there can be woeful quality. Neither of these are inevitable. In a salary system, if the lazy/incompetent can 'get away with it' and the industrious/competent aren't acknowledged it has a poisonous effect on the organisation. In a fee per item system the lazy will earn less automatically but there needs to be careful monitoring of the quality of the output with particular attention paid to people at either tail of the output distribution. Also people with high output (because of poor quality) can drive down wages for everyone and create a treadmill where the quality of everyones' work suffers as they try to maintain their income.
- stephencanon 13y agoThose aren't the only two options. If you want to incentivize outcomes and efficiency, fee-for-outcome is an obvious option.
- amerika_blog 13y ago> If you want to incentivize outcomes and efficiency, fee-for-outcome is and obvious option. When I write a contract, there are often two prices: a minimum which is stingy and a bonus which is far from it. The point is to say that if you do the minimum for this contract, you get a certain amount; if you excel, you get paid for that excellence. Translated to health care, I think I'd like to see doctors doing less paperwork and more doctoring. It's not perfect, but I trust competition to pay that excellence price to those who deserve it. That in turn means that if I need some kind of crucial care, I know where it can be found. If the system is over-regulated, that is not so.
- DougWebb 13y agoWhen it comes to medical care, you have to be really careful about how you define "outcome" if you want to use that as an incentive. You can't just use patient recovery/survival, because then you'd have doctors avoiding patients that need their care the most. You'd also continue to get extraordinary measures taken to extend the life of patients that can't survive, even when letting them go is the more humane thing to do to ease their suffering. I've thought about this a lot, and I don't think there is any objective way to provide outcome-based incentives. The best I could think of is peer-reviewed judgements of outcomes, but that could become pretty corrupt.
- realrocker 13y agoI am in Bangalore and don't have medical insurance. Paid Rs 300 fee to General Physician for a consultation another 1500 Rs. for a bunch of tests. In my hometown in Bihar the same thing costs Rs 150+500 with excellent doctors. It's not all rosy but it's not that bad.
- kamaal 13y agoThe only thing I can tell you is to go and get health insurance ASAP. Both for yourself and your dependents. Get one and be safe, one serious illness can bankrupt you these days(actually it always has). But my point is even a week of hospitalization can be pretty expensive. And don't be under an impression you will be able to travel to Bihar or wherever when the need arises. During cases of emergency those are not practical solutions.
- harichinnan 13y agoAgree. The last time I bought health insurance in India, it cost me Rs 2600 ~ $50 for a year for $10000 worth of coverage.
- realrocker 13y agoThat cant be right/Probably has a thesis of prohibitive clauses where you dont get the monies
- rehack 13y ago>The only thing I can tell you is to go and get health insurance ASAP. Both for yourself and your dependents. I am not too sure about that. I think medical insurance hasn't yet become all pervasive in India, and thankfully so. Insurance companies are there to make profit, and so will tend to exploit fear to maximize their profits. Leading to inflated costs, as it has happened in US. So I am against insurance in this form, unless it works like a non-profit cooperative. In fact Dr. Devi Shetty has also innovated here, with a scheme which costs as little as Re. 5 per month (1/60 USD per month) and provides heart coverage to rural Indians. It works as a cooperative scheme of course. I am surprised, Insurance companies, even exist. As they should be the first thing to be replaced by Software (as in 'Software eating the world' by Marc Andressen)... It should happen, will just take some time, I guess. So, I think, India can still save itself from corporate medical insurance. As seen in some countries like Canada, a fully public health care system, works as good, if not better. On a personal note, after having, earlier, taken medical insurance for me and family by paying some 9000/- Rs per annum and getting a cover of 300000/- Rs. I decided this year to not renew it. But of course, I won't dare to prescribe it generally, each person must take his own decision. Appendix: 1) http://arachnoid.com/wrong/index.html http://arachnoid.com/wrong/index.html (ctrl-f 'Insurance is a wise investment')
- whatusername 13y agoI know - anecdote!=data. But here's an anecdote: We recently had a baby (in Aus). Our Indian neighbour (been in au for 7 years) was amazed at how little medical intervention we had. His comment was that in India there was much more incentive to recommend drugs, c-sections, etc.
- lostlogin 13y agoAnecdata is the term I've heard for this situation.
- dheer01 13y ago>>I've never been to US, but I can tell you the Indian health care system is if not less is equally greedy compared to their US counterparts. Its just the same. Its NOT the same. High costs in the US are essentially a result of policy corruption - a systemic issue with results in the exorbitant prices. Greed amongst doctors is prevalent in India as well as the US - maybe more prevalent in India due to general poverty. But health care in India is more 'free-market' than in the US, which is why it is more efficient. >>I've never been to US, but I can tell you the Indian health care system is if not less is equally greedy compared to their US counterparts. Its just the same. I have been to the US and I have spent a huge time in India. I have witnessed the Indian health system in close quarters and have close family members undergone major surgeries. There is greed in India, no doubt about it. But the American system is completely EFFED up - there is no comparison. If you go to the US and spend some time understanding/experiencing the system, you will be thankful for what you have in India. >>These days if you don't have health insurance you are more or less screwed. Its just like the US. I mean from whatever I've read about US so far its the very same. Nothing changes. You just feel its cheaper as $1 = 60 rupees. There you get a straight 60x value of your money. That is what it is at the end of the day. You are completely wrong about this only because you don't know what happens in the US if you dont have insurance. My close family members have undergone major heart surgery at Narayanan Hrudyalaya. They had insurance, but even if the insurance did not cover it, it was not a big deal. I could have easily paid from my own pocket - it cost just over $2K USD - not a big amount for middle class Indians for life threatening surgery. All the prices are transparent - so if you dont want to pay as much you can choose cheaper options (shared post-op bedding etc.) which will reduce prices in half - with very little difference in medical care. In the US if you dont have insurance for something like this - you will go bankrupt. The only reason you don't know about this is because most of your NRI friends work for bigger tech companies which provide good coverage. Infact one of the reasons why health care is reasonable in India is because insurance coverage is limited and not mandated by law. The resulting free market delivers the economies quoted in this article. >>Coming to our system. Forget greed, fraud in the system is so massively high nothing that I write here will explain it. No it is NOT. There is a tendency in Indians to think that they are completely fucked up. Travel around the world - especially to the US and you will thank your stars - and please dont go with what NRI's say - they have a vested interest. It is true that there is greed in the system and there is fraud - but there is a relatively freer market. You can 'choose' your doctors/hospitals. If you dont have a good experience with a hospital you can choose to write a review on Mouthshut.com and have them get less business. You can do your research and choose a better doctor/hospital over a worse one. This 'choice' and the enabling free market makes India health care deliver economies at scale which are impossible in the American system. >>The fees for completing your medical course is astronomically high. Capitation fee often runs in crores, the net fee by the time you finish your MD is so high no doubt most doctors have to practically turn into crooks to get something out of it. Add to this nearly more than a decade of studies sets a perfect stage for these sort of activities to happen. Assuming that this does turn them into 'crooks', they have an easy way to get their money 'out' - migrate to the US/UK after completing their residency. Some doctors are greedy, some are good. The greedy ones land up outside India as much if not less than inside.
- monksy 13y agoThe TV show Scam City had a field day with the Indian "doctors" http://natgeotv.com/za/scam-city/videos/delhi-doctor-scam http://natgeotv.com/za/scam-city/videos/delhi-doctor-scam