4 ms·
you say anti-scientific hysteria, I say reasonable fears regularly ignored by industry and whitewashed by an industry captured fda. example 1: bpa from the wi
by x0x0 13y ago
you say anti-scientific hysteria, I say reasonable fears regularly ignored by industry and whitewashed by an industry captured fda. example 1: bpa
from the wiki article [1]:
In 2006, the US Government sponsored an assessment of the scientific
literature on BPA. Thirty-eight experts in fields involved with bisphenol A
gathered in Chapel Hill, North Carolina to review several hundred studies on
BPA, many conducted by members of the group. At the end of the meeting, the
group issued the Chapel Hill Consensus Statement,[100] which stated BPA at
concentrations found in the human body is associated with organizational
changes in the prostate, breast, testis, mammary glands, body size, brain
structure and chemistry, and behavior of laboratory animals.[101]
The Chapel Hill Consensus Statement found that average levels in people are
above those that cause harm to many animals in laboratory experiments. They
noted that while BPA is not persistent in the environment or in humans,
biomonitoring surveys indicate that exposure is continuous, which is
problematic because acute animal exposure studies are used to estimate daily
human exposure to BPA, and no studies that had examined BPA pharmacokinetics
in animal models had followed continuous low-level exposures. They added
that measurement of BPA levels in serum and other body fluids suggests the
possibilities that BPA intake is much higher than accounted for, and/or that
BPA can bioaccumulate in some conditions (such as pregnancy).[100]
A 2008 report by the Center for the Evaluation of Risks to Human
Reproduction within the U.S. National Toxicology Program (NTP), which is
within the National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, reported the
results of its exhaustive review of the literature. Its conclusions,
expressed relative to current estimates of general population exposure
levels in the U.S., were the following:
and yet bpa is still used. So when we hear that monsanto pinky-swears their experiments, even when they contaminate neighboring fields, are super duper safe, or orange growers promise up and down that, well, their genetic modifications they introduced to prevent their business from being destroyed are absolutely positively safe (we promise!)... forgive me for being skeptical.
Not to mention the freakout about labeling foods; if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods? Any reasonable adult should have his or her bullshit detector going off when they are told gmo is absolutely safe, but it's the end of the world if we tell people which foods have gmo ingredients so that they can choose what to eat.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bisphenol_A
- ims 13y agoThere's a difference between chemicals and genetically modified foods. We know that human health can be damaged by all sorts of different chemicals. That being established, the task at hand is identifying which are harmful (or usually in what quantities do they become harmful). Meanwhile there is no persuasive evidence that any foods become harmful simple because they have been genetically modified. Completely different. > if they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods? Perhaps precisely because of this hysteria surrounding GMO?
- crusso 13y agoif they weren't knowingly poisoning us, why exactly would corporations be so very afraid of properly labeling foods For the same reason that measles infections are on the rise? Because the public is largely ignorant and doesn't understand much about Science or genetic engineering and thus is easily influenced by Hollywood and celebrities who in their ignorance push their favorite environmental/medical causes (Jenny McCarthy).
- x0x0 13y agoPlease. Jenny McCarthy is a fucking idiot. See the wiki article for evidence published in medical journals that bpa harms human beings. There's plenty of evidence to say it should be banned, at bare minimum until long term studies at actual dosing levels have been performed.
- eli 13y agoYou cut off the quote just before it details the experts' estimate that, extrapolating from animal studies, the threat of BPA ranges from "some concern" for fetuses (the FDA banned the use of BPA in baby bottles) to "negligible concern" for adults. From a much more recent meta-analysis of existing data: "The analysis showed that BPA levels were often so low that it was below the ability of current toxicological methods to detect it, raising the possibility that most instances of high BPA dose might have been the result of contamination from tubes and plastics in hospitals." http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/feb/15/no-toxic-effects-chemical-experts http://www.guardian.co.uk/society/2013/feb/15/no-toxic-effec... Anyway, I agree it's hard to argue with "label the product and let the consumer decide." But I think the case could be made that it plays on people's unscientific views of what is and isn't healthy. As with "organic" or "locally sourced" there's nothing stopping companies that don't use GMOs from putting a "No GMO" label on their food. Some already do.