4 ms·
I wonder if Senator Chambliss realizes that he's being played. "I have been assured ... that there is no capability at NSA for anyone without a court order to
by lisper 13y ago
I wonder if Senator Chambliss realizes that he's being played.
"I have been assured ... that there is no capability at NSA for anyone without a court order to listen to any telephone conversation or to monitor any e-mail.” Chambliss said that any monitoring of emails is purely “accidental.”
You can't have it both ways. Either there is "no capability", or the monitoring is "accidental." It can't be both.
- dictum 13y agoEvery response from the NSA and people speaking on their behalf, both before and after the Snowden leaks, has basically been 1. A denial that they have the "capability" to do [insert method of mass surveilance], leaving open the possibility that "capability" means legal authorization; 2. A quasi admission that maybe the surveillance happens (Clapper: "not wittingly"). In other words, "we're collecting everything, but we'll only inspect your data if you're not American, or have a relationship of any kind with someone who has ever contacted a terrorist suspect."
- danenania 13y ago'In other words, "we're collecting everything, but we'll only inspect your data if you're not American, or have a relationship of any kind with someone who has ever contacted a terrorist suspect."' Or if a random analyst is bored and finds you interesting for some reason.
- baconner 13y agoor have a relationship with someone who has a relationship with someone who has ever contacted a terrorist suspect.
- coopdog 13y agoOr if your information happens to be valuable (bitcoins, passwords, stock tips, blackmail material) and can be sold without it being traced back to an analyst in any of the facilities around the world where your information is cached.
- samstave 13y agoExactly! At this point - every single "analysts" security-clearance worthiness has been jeopardized. I don't trust ANY NSA employee at this point. NONE.
- greenyoda 13y agoThe other possibility is that he's complicit in the NSA's game.
- malandrew 13y agoOn this note, has anyone done any real social network analysis of all the people our congressmen and women meet regularly with? I know investigative journalists look a lot at campaign contributions, but besides those are there other sources of data from which it possible to draw association between Congressman Chambliss and people of importance in the Surveillance-Industrial complex and/or high ranking NSA officials? I would imagine that the schedule of who members of congress meet during the course of the day are part of the public record and should be subject to a FOIA request.
- jkestner 13y agoThat would be a great volley back on how revealing metadata is, a la the Paul Revere piece. I know the White House has to keep these records - if congresspeople (AND their staff) don't, there oughta be a law.
- malandrew 13y agoWhich watchdog group (e.g. EFF, change.org) would be the best one to propose a congressional metadata law? If our elected officials can see value in knowing the metadata of his or her citizens, then the citizens that elected those officials should be able to see the metadata of everyone his or her congressman calls, meets with or emails. The same should apply to all the senior staff of any elected official. One of the easiest way to handle making sure official meetings outside the office are logged is to only allow expense reports to be honored, when the other party in the meeting is logged.
- cgio 13y agoI would guess the expenses are charged to the private party in the meetings you care about. This measure would probably only make some spicy meetings more frugal :-)