12 ms·
It's kind of fascinating, to me, that internal combustion engines won the car war for so long. Electric motors are so much simpler to build, and so much more ef
by SwellJoe 13y ago
It's kind of fascinating, to me, that internal combustion engines won the car war for so long. Electric motors are so much simpler to build, and so much more efficient from an energy usage perspective. I understand why electric lost out (energy storage, range of vehicle), but I think it could have gone a different way had there been just a couple of nudges in the electric direction at the right time. And, what a different world we'd live in, if those nudges had happened...
- DanBC 13y agoIt's interesting that I can make a toy electric motor by with a battery, a magnet, and some wire. While some people do make tiny internal combustion engines the work involved in incredible. (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLn7xG8vuPQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mLn7xG8vuPQ) World's smallest V12 engine: (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3KdpzL3Hkk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3KdpzL3Hkk) Making model IC Engine valves: (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nofj1CGSCM4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nofj1CGSCM4)
- mikeash 13y agoThat's not a fair comparison at all. Building a hobby V12 like that is like building a modern brushless high-efficiency electric motor, not like building the toy you mention. The combustion engine equivalent to the toy electric motor would be a simple stirling engine or even a Hero engine. These can be very easy to build.
- bigiain 13y agoBuilding a high-efficiency brushless motor isn't particularly hard - especially if you're happy to consider "reusing/repurposing components from readily available 'junk'", or buying kits like this: http://www.customcdr.com/cgi-bin/ccp51/cp-app.cgi?usr=51H8179247&rnd=9102115&rrc=N&affl=&cip=115.64.46.107&act=&aff=&pg=prod&ref=singlekit&cat=motorkits&catstr=HOME:motorkits http://www.customcdr.com/cgi-bin/ccp51/cp-app.cgi?usr=51H817... (I've built both kit versions and "from scratch" motors built with parts ratted from cd rom drive motors with a few bucks worth of rare-earth magnets.) Building your own controller for it is somewhat more challenging…
- TheLegace 13y agoThere is an open source project called Open-BLDC, I really like the project and use it to help me make a regular Brushed DC motor controller, eventually I'll want to play with BLDCs and there is some fine work done by the author of the boards and code esden. http://esden.net/2010/09/19/open-bldc-v0-3-hardware-based-closed-loop-control/ http://esden.net/2010/09/19/open-bldc-v0-3-hardware-based-cl...
- WalterBright 13y agoYou don't even need a magnet. I made an electric motor as a kid out of nails, wire and a battery. It worked pretty good. But, being a boy, I wanted it to work better. So I replaced the battery with a lamp cord and plugged it in. It promptly burst into flames. Awesome!
- speeder 13y agoOnce I plugged a toy race track to the outlet (in portuguese we call it "Autorama" I dunno the name in english), I knew enough of physics to expect it to burst in flame... But instead the car got REALLY, REALLY, REALLY fast, shoot out of the track and smashed into the wall. Of course, I happily put a second car on it, and changed the track so that the car does not end smashed, and indeed, I could launch cars all over the place. Also as the car raced, sparks came out of the contacts with the track. Now that I am older and know even more physics, I have no fucking idea on how I made a DC motor work only forward with a AC current.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoAssuming the track was designed so the cars go forward no matter which direction you place them, the cars likely had a small diode-based circuit to always feed the current into the motor with the same polarity. When you fed an AC current into the track, that circuit in the cars would have acted like a rectifier, turning the AC into poor-quality, high-voltage DC. The sparks would come from feeding way too much voltage in, enough to jump the gaps caused by momentary losses of contact between the track and a fast-moving car.
- speeder 13y agoDiodes! Great idea, I should have thought of that.
- mangamadaiyan 13y agoI'm guessing your mains supply would've been 230v/5A - in which case I have to say I'm surprised that it didn't blow the diodes out :) I remember plugging a 1N2001 (or similar) into a wall socket, and turning the switch on to watch the diode blow out as a schoolboy.
- flomo 13y agoSmall two-stroke engines used in lawn mowers and the like were incredibly simple. Perhaps a dozen parts for the entire engine. Of course, such things are now banned in California.
- walshemj 13y agoa basic 2 stoke has only 3 moving parts I recall from the dim and distant days of my BTEC in Mech Engineering
- jasonwatkinspdx 13y agoYeah. It's worth noting that for engines in stationary devices like fabrication tools and machinery, electric totally won. So what made the difference with cars wasn't just the engines themselves, but rather the energy storage/distribution network. Now that we have batteries that are good enough at a cheap enough price, electric is gaining fast despite a lot of cultural opposition.
- walshemj 13y agoIt took hundreds of years to go from belt drive in factories to individual electric motors which probably didn't get installed in large numbers until post WW1 Even in the late 70's the mechanical technician courses in the UK required you to be able to design an old school belt drive.
- jasonwatkinspdx 13y agoYup. I am quite familiar. My great grandfather made a minor fortune in the 20's with a service company that would refinish the bearings used in shops with overhead drive shafts, etc.
- vacri 13y agoI'm not sure about totally won - here is a demonstration of a gasoline-powered flashlight, which might create a resurgence of this method for power tools. At 0:30 he expounds on the advantages of the device. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcdVaslktBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OcdVaslktBE
- mikeash 13y agoAnd let's not forget compressed air, which is still a very popular way to run power tools. Electric vastly outnumbers it, of course, but compressed air is still used in a significant portion of tools.
- noonespecial 13y agoCompressed CO2 and nitrogen are gaining favor in the tool space as well.
- ars 13y ago> but I think it could have gone a different way had there been just a couple of nudges in the electric direction at the right time Gasoline cars were popularized before electric power generation was widespread. It would be decades before the power grid could possibly have supported electric cars. The Model-T started in 1908 (and there were of course cars before that), the War of the Currents was in the late 1880's. The Model-T represents cars becoming popular, but the War of the Currents was just the beginning of the electric grid. The first Gasoline car was also around the 1880's (must have been an amazing time to be alive with all those inventions). It was not until the late 1940's that electricity was widespread, i.e. rural areas which are of course important for long distance travel. So the electric car would not have been practical until then, and by then of course gasoline was completely entrenched.
- ganeumann 13y agoWhen Henry Ford finally made it big with his Model T, his wife Clara made him buy her a fancy car: a 1914 Detroit Electric. Electric cars were the 'good' cars, easier to run, not as dirty or hard to start, more luxurious. But they were an expensive luxury. The Model T was cheap, easy to fix, and adaptable to many other uses (like hooking a wheel to a belt and running a saw to cut wood.) The Model T was a classic disruptive invention: less good but much, much cheaper; it created an entirely new market of car buyers. It may be that that electric is a better option now: oil is expensive and non-renewable, and burning fuel pollutes. But neither of these reasons were very compelling a century ago.
- ams6110 13y agoElectric cars needed far more than a "nudge" and still do. Even with today's state-of-the-art battery technology the range, recharge time, and cost equation still doesn't work for most people. With the lead-acid technology of the day, it was never even close compared to internal combustion.