3 ms·
You are conflating the overall cost with the per-year cost. Per-year, fatties and smokers cost more. Since insurance premiums are also paid on a per-year basis
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
You are conflating the overall cost with the per-year cost. Per-year, fatties and smokers cost more.
Since insurance premiums are also paid on a per-year basis, per-year is the relevant point of comparison. Of course, in a single payer system which only receives payments from people while they work, it would in fact be beneficial to induce people to die earlier.
- rdl 13y agoInsurance premiums are insignificant for lifelong unhealthy people who heavily use healthcare. A $500/mo/person premium (which is about the maximum you could get per individual in the new system) is $240k total for 40 years. There's no compounding since the price of healthcare goes up faster than regulated premiums, and because expenses per-year exceed the premiums. $6k covers not a lot of care in a year, and the whole lifetime number is blown away by one serious event.
- jjoonathan 13y ago> You are conflating the overall cost with the per-year cost. Performing the division to approximate yearly costs from the source I linked does not support your point. Obese people may have had the highest costs, but not the highest average yearly costs. In a single payer health system, the "insurance provider" sees ROI from peoples' productivity, meaning the single payer system has incentive to keep people healthy even if it costs more. OTOH, private insurance wants to dump you as quickly as legally possible the moment your costs exceed your premiums weather you are healthy or not.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI stand corrected. I misinterpreted this sentence: "The researchers found that from age 20 to 56, obese people racked up the most expensive health costs." I should indeed have done the math. You are correct that for long term health insurance contracts (i.e., contracts which are guaranteed to cover people past the age of 56 at a fixed cost), fatties and smokers should pay less. In a single payer health system, the "insurance provider" sees ROI from peoples' productivity, meaning the single payer system has incentive to keep people healthy even if it costs more. This makes no sense. According to your link, the healthy people cost more due to medical costs incurred during their unproductive years. There is no incentive for a single payer system to keep people alive in their unproductive years.