4 ms·
Employers are not subsidized, people are. If anything employers are obligated to pay a higher cost for labor since they need to compete with government program
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Employers are not subsidized, people are.
If anything employers are obligated to pay a higher cost for labor since they need to compete with government programs that pay people not to work. Even programs which pay people regardless of employment status create disincentives for employment (thereby requiring employers to pay more), due to diminishing marginal utility.
The most recent empirical study on this that I've seen: http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/matthew.notowidigdo/research/ggn_tenncare_july2013.pdf http://faculty.chicagobooth.edu/matthew.notowidigdo/research...
- yequalsx 13y agoThere are many examples of employers (corporations) that are subsidized. Record profits, declining real wages over the last ten years for average employees, and massive increase in pay for management over the last 30 years suggest that employers aren't being obligated to pay too much for labor. Do you have any data that suggests that labor is costing too much as a result of government programs that pay people not to work? The distribution of resources (wealth) is grossly unfair and anyone working ought to make a living wage. It is immoral to do otherwise.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't dispute that many corporations receive subsidies. I dispute that government benefits given to low skill workers are a subsidy given to their employer. Do you have any data that suggests that labor is costing too much as a result of government programs that pay people not to work? I cited one bit of data that showed exactly this in the post you just responded to.
- yequalsx 13y agoCosting too much as in companies folding as a result of this alleged increase in labor cost.
- UK-AL 13y agoGovernment subsidies allow a persons surviving wage to be lower. And with low skilled workers, their wage tends to be pushed down to a wage they can just about survive on, or your workers die. Thus government subsidies are indirectly founding companies, by allowing them to lower wages beyond what would normally be possible.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoEmployees will not die if their wages are reduced to $4-8/hour. As proof that this is not the case, consider that most nations of the world have lots of people not dying on an unsubsidized $8/hour. Mexico is a fairly wealthy nation, and the GDP/capita is equivalent to a full time job at $8.33/hour (adjusted for PPP). Literally billions of people avoid death on far less than $8/hour. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)_per_capita https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_GDP_(PPP)...
- UK-AL 13y ago1 dollar means different things in different countries. In some countries 1 dollar could buy you decent food, for a few days. There's differences in rent. Living in a slum is illegal in developed countries.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe numbers I give are adjusted for purchasing power. Workers will not engage in a massive die off on $8/hour or even $1/hour.
- UK-AL 13y agoWell I'm just repeating Adam Smith on how low skilled jobs are priced. They go as low as they can go, without something bad happening to the employee.