3 ms·
> I'm not talking about lobbying or raising attention to the issue, but the technical challenges of designing a network that is immune to all forms of surveilla
by pron 13y ago
> I'm not talking about lobbying or raising attention to the issue, but the technical challenges of designing a network that is immune to all forms of surveillance. Let's treat this as an issue of computer science, not politics.
Absolutely not! That's precisely why technologists and scientists have always been easily manipulated. Any technology, any technology, can always be turned on its head and abused. If technologists really have the power they've come to believe they possess, it must be used politically. Politics cannot be avoided. Trying to eschew politics is merely following a policy of not caring, and yielding power to those who openly espouse politics.
> Facebook should be a protocol, not a service. Twitter should be a protocol, not a service. And so forth. This of course completely upends the business model these technologies are based on, and would need to be approached by people with a completely different perspective.
Yes! But this could only be done by raising political awareness.
The biggest problem with the internet is not government control. You can see how government control, when exposed (and it will always be exposed as it always has been), creates an uproar. When people are aware and upset, things will be kept in check.
The biggest problem is that articles such as this claim that "US cloud services cannot be trusted" only when government surveillance is in play. But services couldn't have been trusted beforehand. People give up information — and information is power — to private corporations. Those corporations are under far less scrutiny and oversight than the government, but that's not the worst of it. The worst of it is that people surrender information voluntarily; possibly because they don't care, and possibly because the corporations have been able, through far more effective propaganda than any government could ever hope to produce, convinced the people that the corporations have their best interest in mind.
The worst form of exploitation happen when people voluntarily surrender power. People actively support the abuse, then they don't mind, and then it may be too late.
The solution must be politics and laws. Just like antitrust laws try to prevent corporations from amassing too much power, so too new information laws must prevent them from doing the same.
- kintamanimatt 13y agoPolitics plays a role, but it's secondary to creating a secure network. Today's network and its core protocols are trivial to abuse, and the trouble lies in the fact that the people that were its original creators couldn't see the future. Jon Postel created SMTP at a time when governments were more trusted to act in the interests of the people (whether this was true in practice or not), and also only ~200 hosts were connected to the internet with a total of ~20,000 people actually using the internet.[0] Nobody thought that SMTP would be used by a large chunk of the world's population, that spam would be an issue, that traffic could be sniffed and intercepted, or that governments would start programs of virtually indiscriminate en masse surveillance of the world's electronic communications. The idea of a Room 614A would have been regarded as ridiculous and excessively paranoid. Cloud services are an entirely different issue, and the issue isn't necessarily resolved politically, but by mass decentralization. Things like OwnCloud are a great starting point and people today generally have the bandwidth to run their own micro-servers at home, or, possible, if battery life improves, on their phones. Some things are impossible to decentralize, for example search, at least until technology and storage advances sufficiently that we can all host our own Google search product on our phones, and Google search becomes an app that can be paid for and downloaded, with live changes to the index being streamed to the device. It sounds absurd in today's world, but tomorrow could be different. [0] http://education.illinois.edu/wp/commercialism/history-of-the-internet.htm http://education.illinois.edu/wp/commercialism/history-of-th...
- dpatru 13y agoThere's a big difference between government and corporations. Corporations are, at bottom, simply groups of ordinary people with whom you deal with on a voluntary basis. A corporation cannot rob (tax, fine), kidnap (arrest), imprison, or drone you. A corporation has to be very bad indeed before it sinks to the level of even an ordinary government.
- pron 13y agoI'm not quite sure how to respond to that. You might agree that some arrests and taxes are necessary. I'm not really sure what you're saying (like, how capitalists are any more "ordinary" than elected officials). One thing is sure, though. If you think corporations can't, or won't do all those things if they could (putting aside the fact that governments are elected while corporations aren't), then you're not familiar with US history: * http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_Government_Services http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_Government_Services * http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_union_busting_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_union_busting_in_the...