2 ms·
Theft is the depriviation of men's property, not of potential profit. The copying and digital distribution of work cannot qualified as stealing because there i
by kiba 18y ago
Theft is the depriviation of men's property, not of potential profit.
The copying and digital distribution of work cannot qualified as stealing because there is no property being stolen. Nobody is depriving anyone of their ability to watch, copy, sell, and modify these movies.
This is very simple logic. The fact that you wish to deflate these actions of copying and distribution with stealing is disingenuous.
- pj 18y agoCall it whatever you want. If you copy and distribute things that look exactly like U.S. currency, would that be rationally justified in your world?
- randallsquared 18y agoYes, but a currency system based on intrinsic value would solve that problem, and have other beneficial effects as well, such as curbing runaway inflation (well, except that that's really the same problem, just official instead of unofficial counterfeiting).
- kiba 18y agoYou are talking about messing up a tool that is used to perform economic calculation. Intentionally introducing calculation chaos into the economic system is a far different issue from who should have the right to copy, modify, and distribute digital goods. It is obvious I would condemn counterfeiting as abusing the monetary system.
- rms 18y agoIt has been established so many times on this board that copyright infringement is NOT stealing that I would recommend against even bothering to have this argument. You're right, the other argument is disingenuous.