3 ms·
How does adding a VAT to a wealth tax offset the immediate consumption incentives? Either way, you are taxed when you spend the money. Additionally, if you don'
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
How does adding a VAT to a wealth tax offset the immediate consumption incentives? Either way, you are taxed when you spend the money. Additionally, if you don't consume immediately, you are taxed some more. Hence, immediate consumption incentives.
- leot 13y agoVAT rate is a tunable parameter in a tax system. It could, in principle, be set high enough to discourage all consumption (which would of course not be desirable). This implies that there is some rate that it could be set to that would offset any added consumption incentive caused by wealth taxation (assuming such an incentive exists, which I think might not actually be the case under most wealth tax schemes). Indeed, whether there is an immediate consumption incentive or not depends on how good someone is at investing. If the person is able to generate a return far in excess of the periodic wealth tax, that person has no added incentive to spend whatsoever (spending would decrease future income and wealth). If the person isn't a particularly good investor, then spending becomes more attractive. Which seems to me exactly like the outcome we want. Furthermore, a wealth tax tends to hit most those individuals who as a group already spend a much smaller proportion of their income (the highest earners tend to save the most). Indeed, since most middle- and low-income earners would only be taxed on their consumption, such a tax scheme would incentivize those with little to increase their rate of saving.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWithout a VAT tax but with a wealth tax, $10 can buy 10 sandwiches today or 8 sandwiches in the future. If you add a VAT, $10 can buy 8 sandwiches today or 6.4 sandwiches in the future. Either way, better to consume today than tomorrow. This applies to the wealthy and middle class alike. A wealth tax discourages productive investments since it reduces all rates of return. In particular, it reduces marginal rates of return below zero, discouraging productive investments. Say I can buy 10 sandwiches today, or build a machine which will give me 11 sandwiches tomorrow. If your wealth tax is 20%, it's better for me to consume 10 sandwiches today than 8.8 sandwiches tomorrow. Seriously, just crunch the numbers. It's not hard.
- leot 13y agoPerhaps something hasn't been made clear. I'm not sure why you seem to have adopted a condescending tone. A wealth tax is typically a periodic (monthly/quarterly/yearly) tax on total net worth. This tax often ranges between 0 and 3% yearly, often with with highest rates only applying to wealth above a certain amount. What I think might have been left out from your example is the fact that the person isn't choosing just between spending and not spending. They are choosing between spending and saving/investing. The arithmetic is simple. If I can generate a 7% return on my assets, and I'm being taxed yearly at 1% of my assets, then the way for me to make the most money is to have the most assets. The return I get yearly is 7% - 1% = 6%. If one year I have $120 and I spend $20 of it, then I make $6 that year. If don't spend any, I make $7.20 that year. EDIT: Re "... discouraging productive investments". This statement might be true for capital gains taxation, but it isn't so for wealth taxation. If I invest extremely conservatively (e.g. in precious metals) then I might only manage a 3% return. A 1% wealth tax would then amount to a 33% capital gains tax. If I invest aggressively and successfully, then I might earn 10% that year. Then the 1% would be equivalent to only a 10% capital gains tax. As such, a wealth tax is the only tax that actually encourages productive investment and discourages hoarding.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoAn investment is socially useful if it has a positive rate of return, since it creates wealth. An investment will only be made if the investor can capture a positive rate of return. If the rate of return is R and the wealth tax is T, then the investor can capture only R-T. Thus, productive investments for which 0 < R < T are not made. Unless you want to assert that there are no investment opportunities in the world with 0 < R < T, the wealth tax clearly discourages some productive investments.
- leot 13y agoIf this claim is true, it's highly non-obvious. For one, it seems you would need to conclude that inflation should also be zero (or negative!?) lest certain productive investments go unmade. Sure, it may discourage some very low-yield productive investments. This is the cost of encouraging some more productive ones. At present, we live in a world where there's lots of wealth that's poorly (too conservatively) allocated. So such a trade-off seems entirely reasonable.