4 ms·
blocked by paywall One thing I've learned from many so-called "philanthropists" is that hosting charity events can be a great status and money making/saving op
by bane 13y ago
blocked by paywall
One thing I've learned from many so-called "philanthropists" is that hosting charity events can be a great status and money making/saving opportunity for those in the business of it. If you've ever watched a "real housewive of ..." episode, those wacky ladies are constantly hosting charity events and provide a pretty good example of how this works:
1) Get a really good tax accountant and lawyer.
2) Establish a charity (in the U.S. they're called 501(c)(3) organizations and have various laws about how they operate. Dedicate it to "Cancer Research" or "Helping Orphans" or whatever.
3) Set yourself up as the head of the charity, give yourself a respectable, but not over the top salary. This is the "organizational overhead" you often hear about.
4) Recruit a bunch of free volunteers concerned about your cause and host a charity event. Well done theme parties can bring in the most money. Include a donation envelope in case people can't come but still want to "support your cause".
5) Collect money. Make sure you remind everybody that their charitable donations are tax deductions! This will keep them coming. Guilt your friends into coming as well. If you get popular in the charity circuit you can even start charging a "cover charge for the even expenses, recommended donation is...$xxx" or "$xxx per plate" if it's a dinner.
6) Subtract misc expenses for room rental, supplies, cheap gifts for volunteers etc.
7) Take the donated money, subtract a percentage for "organizational overhead"
8) Donate the remainder to your cause or if you have time, spend the money on "donation events" where you get press for doing some kind of community service (advertising).
9) Get your charity to spend money on office equipment, cars, travel expenses etc. Deduct as business expenses.
10) Any left over money is a bonus to you for a job well done (can't show a profit!)
11) rinse and repeat
There actually are good charities out there that do good work, but separating them from this kind of self-service is hard to do.
- rdouble 13y agoAnother thing to consider is that just because an org is a non profit, does not mean the people working there are making social worker salaries. One of my aunts makes over $400K/yr as an administrator at a non profit, and she's still technically on the bottom half of the management totem pole.
- muzz 13y agoThe general form of this is such an urban legend that there's even a Snopes page: http://www.snopes.com/politics/business/charities.asp http://www.snopes.com/politics/business/charities.asp
- napoleond 13y agoThat page, while refuting the specific claims of a few old chain letters, actually seems to support the parent's assertion that the executives of some charitable organisations get paid fairly well (several over $500k). Then again, I'm not sure what people expect--it is presumably difficult to retain the sort of people required to manage very large organisations without paying them something in the ballpark of what they could get at a for-profit.
- g8oz 13y agoThe salaries can also be explained by the lack of active "shareholders" to keep the self-interest of management in check. If you can't find competent managers for less than $400k a year you need to get out more. Charitynavigator.org breaks down the admin costs etc of most charities. I wouldn't consider donating to one that devoted less than 85% to actual program expenses.
- lisper 13y ago> blocked by paywall It's a very interesting paywall, too. It continues to block me even if I clear all my local state (cookies and localstorage), turn on private browsing, and disable Javascript. But it does NOT block me if I use a different browser. I can't figure out how it works. Anyone here have a clue?
- gojomo 13y agoWhich private browsing are you using? Some (such as Chrome's 'incognito' mode) share cookies among all incognito windows until the last is closed. So I was baffled when my fresh 'incognito' window was sending cookies on a 1st request somewhere... until I found the older window I'd forgotten about.
- lisper 13y agoSafari 5.1.9 on Snow Leopard.
- pygy_ 13y agoNo idea, but using a private window in Firefox 22 (my main bowser ATM) works.
- gamblor956 13y agoThe block lasts until you restart the browser. This same problem pops up in IE9/10.
- revelation 13y agoI just wget the page and it works every time. I think its a mix of cookies and <ip, user agent> tracking.
- muzz 13y ago> There actually are good charities out there that do good work, but separating them from this kind of self-service is hard to do No it's not. Charities have to report how much money they spend on things like overhead, and sites like Charity Navigator can be used to quickly and easily locate this information. Your ignorance of it does not make it so.
- bane 13y agoSo I checked a dozen or so local charities I know of, some with reputations I don't know and some with, not a single one I checked was on the site. It appears to be absolutely useless and totally doesn't help at all with what I was talking about.
- rdouble 13y agoGuidestar is best for that but sadly the reports are very expensive these days.
- kareemm 13y ago> Charities have to report how much money they spend on things like overhead, and sites like Charity Navigator can be used to quickly and easily locate this information. Reporting many expenses as either "Programs" vs. "Overhead" is subjective; guess which way most charities lean? I know this because I've been building a product for one of the most knowledgeable charitable tax lawyers in this space over the last five years, and have gone over many charity tax returns in that time (called T3010 forms in Canada).
- scarmig 13y agoEfficiency and overhead aren't good measures of a charity's effectiveness. Trying to evaluate the success and impact of a program is very important, for instance. But many charity's don't do it, because it adds "overhead" costs when you could be using that money to inflate a meaningless metric that looks good to donors who like to think of themselves as savvy.
- thejteam 13y ago