3 ms·
yup, also what would happen is the government would get bigger and bigger on these newfound taxation revenues. That's not great, but in the most idealistic sit
by dnautics 13y ago
yup, also what would happen is the government would get bigger and bigger on these newfound taxation revenues. That's not great, but in the most idealistic situation, it's not necessarily bad. However, what is bad, is when the economy sags, the taxation revenues to sustain this bigger government will fall short, the government will go into debt, and do one of two things: It will either print money or borrow.
Borrowing (with interest) implicitly assumes the growth of a revenue stream. With private entities, the lender is on the hook if it goes bankrupt and can't fulfill its obligation. With public entities, the citizen is on the hook, so the only solution is to increase taxation down the pike, unless you have a miraculous recovery that restores the economy to what it was before (plus interest). If you don't think the wealthy will find a way to avoid this taxation down the pike that the middle class and poor will have a harder time leveraging, you are naive.
Printing money is worse. Because it devalues the currency, makes everything more expensive, and that $100,000 limit that you set as the point where the wealth tax kicks in becomes a lot more painful. Pretty soon, the poor are paying this tax that only the rich were supposed to pay. Over net time, the people that you are hurting the most are the poor, because the rich have long ago figured out how to avoid this tax.
Congratulations. Through your programme of good intentions to fix the divide between the rich and poor you have made the situation far worse than it ever was.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoMoney is debt. There has never been a world without public debt, because that debt has to come from somewhere. Usually, it comes from the government, and the rates of interest and repayment dictate growth or shrinkage of the money supply.
- dnautics 13y agoContemporary money is certainly equivalent debt, but in the long run historically, debt has been private debt. Keeping in mind that for much of modern history, any form of lending was considered "usury" and generally relegated to corners of society. There is a difference between money that is based on savings and money that is based on debt. Money that is based on savings is net, an exchange for services that have already been rendered. Money that is net based on debt is net, an exchange for services that are expected to be rendered. One of these paradigms is subject to painful corrections as a result of counterparty risk; the other paradigm treats unexpected failures as a sunk cost.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoI've never heard of any such thing as "money based on savings".
- dnautics 13y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8dq1bH1X6s http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8dq1bH1X6s and http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcc-TqvCXqU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcc-TqvCXqU
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoYouTube videos are almost uniformly bunk. Please post actual text I can read, by someone credible preferably.