3 ms·
the a priori assumption here is that the government is 'better' than private interests in deciding how charitable funds should be spent. Why do you think that
by dnautics 13y ago
the a priori assumption here is that the government is 'better' than private interests in deciding how charitable funds should be spent. Why do you think that these newfound revenues coming into the treasuries of the state will be subjected to good stewardship? The government is liable to be using those funds to fight unjust wars, subject innocent people to draconic and unjust policies with escalating costs (like the drugs wars), and so on and so forth.
And there are plenty plenty plenty of corrupt businessmen, but it's way worse in government. right now there is a controversy going on in the central basin municipal water district in california, where overbilling contractors (and kickbacks) happened, the son of an LA councilman was 'hired' as the director, paid six figures to do nothing, and had benefits such as a retirement plan and paid tuition for an expensive private undergraduate degree. How do you get away with that? Almost every director of a nonprofit charity knows that there are rules upon rules prohibiting conflicts of interest that you have to bend over backwards making sure you don't violate in case the IRS comes after you.
- leot 13y agoI don't see where that assumption comes into play. The reform mentioned above need not increase government revenue.
- quinnchr 13y agoPeople think government is better at it, because that's what the evidence overwhelmingly points to. The U.S. routinely top's the list of the world's most charitable nations (private charity): http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2011/12/20/144035063/survey-u-s-takes-top-spot-as-most-charitable-nation http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2011/12/20/144035063/sur... While we also top the list of OECD countries for child poverty http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/CO2.2%20Child%20poverty%20-%20update%20270112.pdf http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/CO2.2%20Child%20poverty%20-%20up... Now compare those poverty rates with the amount of public and private social spending: http://www.oecd.org/media/oecdorg/directorates/directorateforemploymentlabourandsocialaffairs/Chart2_SOCXWeb2012.JPG http://www.oecd.org/media/oecdorg/directorates/directoratefo... More public social spending has a higher effect on poverty than more private social spending.
- dnautics 13y agosince when does the amount of spending have anything to do with its effectiveness? And anyways, by what criterion is the OECD judging what constitutes "social spending"? Finally, the child poverty rates in that graph is a really fine comparison. The US has a lower child poverty rate than australia or japan, which would have been surprising to me. I'm not terribly embarassed by living in a country whose child poverty rate is equivalent to New Zealand's.
- quinnchr 13y agoThere is a pretty clear link between amount of social spending and poverty: http://www.epi.org/publication/ib339-us-poverty-higher-safety-net-weaker/ http://www.epi.org/publication/ib339-us-poverty-higher-safet... I'm not sure what graph you are looking at, according to Chart CO2.2.A there are only five countries with higher child poverty rates: Chile, Turkey, Romania, Mexico and Israel. This is their methodology for determining social spending: http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/SOCXAnnex-DescriptionProjections.pdf http://www.oecd.org/els/soc/SOCXAnnex-DescriptionProjections...
- krrrh 13y agoSome of that surprised me as well. But... these sorts of micro-rankings of countries that all have similar "operating systems" are not very useful. The real lesson here is that OECD countries which by and large practice liberal democracy and free markets are tightly clustered on most quality of life measurements, while countries that don't tend to cluster lower down. This is true of countries with vastly different cultural legacies, and even countries like Japan that has liberal demoracy successfully forced on them at gun point. It makes you wonder just what Buffet thinks he's talking about. I doubt he knows.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoThe a priori assumption here is that the government is 'better' than private interests in deciding how charitable funds should be spent. Better at fulfilling the democratically mandated will of the people, yes. A given government can be (and often is) corrupt, but if you don't trust in the principles of democracy, what you are really saying is that you don't trust people to know what's best for themselves on any collective level. Which is a dangerous assumption, because it indicates that you don't really believe in freedom for other people, but instead in (what's the phrase? ahhhh...) world optimization.