3 ms·
This is a "UK injunction" to prevent the scientists from publishing their paper "in Washington DC in August". How does that work? It seems quite "not right" to
by jlgaddis 13y ago
This is a "UK injunction" to prevent the scientists from publishing their paper "in Washington DC in August". How does that work?
It seems quite "not right" to me that my own government could legally prohibit me from doing something in another country (jurisdiction).
- DanBC 13y agoI agree that it's weird & bad when applied to publishing information. The information will leak somehow. It makes a bit more sense when applied to things like child abuse - US citizens who travel abroad and pay to have sex with someone under the age of 18 can be tried in the US. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_sex_tourism#Tourists_from_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_sex_tourism#Tourists_fro...)
- Amadou 13y agoUgh, that's literally a case of, "think of the children." If what they did was illegal in the country they did it in, then they should be punished there - making it straightforward to extradite them back for trial would be reasonable (assuming it isn't already(. And if it isn't illegal there, well it ought to be. It also sounds like it would be legal for them to marry a 17 year old (as it is in many states in the US) but pay that 17 year old for sex and 30 years in prison.
- jlgaddis 13y agoI am all for protecting children so I hope this doesn't come out wrong but there are way too many "think of the children" laws on the books (and it's only going to continue). Similar to your example, in the state where I live (Indiana) it would be legal for me (a 34-year-old man) to have sex 10 times a day with a 16-year-old kid but it would be a felony punishable by years in prison if I took a naked picture of the same kid. (I don't have any desire to do either one, of course, I just think that's an illustrative example.)
- driverdan 13y agoI can't speak for the UK but in the USA our laws technically apply no matter where a citizen is. US law trumps foreign laws and you could be prosecuted when you return.
- hncommenter13 13y agoAnd for good reason. Otherwise the entire Foreign Corrupt Practices Act would be unenforceable, as the bribery takes place overseas. Similarly, one could evade US law on insider trading or criminal conspiracies simply by moving overseas. If there's a nexus with the US, you can be prosecuted here.
- nknighthb 13y agoNo, they don't. One of the canons of statutory construction is a presumption against extraterritorial application of laws. Congress has to intend for a law to apply beyond US borders, and it's assumed they don't without evidence to the contrary. In some cases they have done this, such as in the PROTECT Act of 2003 which contains a prohibition on child sex tourism. But there is no general assumption that US law applies everywhere.
- smsm42 13y agoSo you say if I went to Amsterdam, where smoking marijuana is legal, and did smoke it there, and went back to the US, they could arrest me for drug possession because drug possession is illegal in the US and I possessed it while being in Amsterdam? Doesn't make much sense.