4 ms·
Why stuff like this isn't considered bribing in US boggles my mind. They're receiving money for voting a certain way.
by mtgx 13y ago
Why stuff like this isn't considered bribing in US boggles my mind. They're receiving money for voting a certain way.
- robotcookies 13y agoIt is absolutely bribery. And as an American, I'm glad there are people in other places who see it for exactly what it is.
- a3n 13y agoAnd sometimes it gets pretty damned blatant: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boehner#Connections_to_lobbyists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Boehner#Connections_to_lo... "In June 1995, Boehner distributed campaign contributions from tobacco industry lobbyists on the House floor as House members were weighing how to vote on tobacco subsidies"
- crusso 13y agoIsn't voting a certain way the only real reason why anyone makes campaign contributions to legislative candidates?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 13y agoBecause the people being bribed are the ones who vote on the laws that define illegal bribery.
- cdwhite 13y agoThis sort of stuff doesn't require the politicians in question to change their minds. Think of it as a two-fold selection effect. First, the candidate who already holds views of which the defense industry approves, receives campaign contributions therefrom and is therefore more likely to win. Second, I would think that defense companies are hardly likely to donate to a politician of the Ron Paul stripe when they are in a race against someone more ... conventional. As rayiner pointed out elswhere in the thread, correlation does not imply causation. This mechanism may have deleterious effects on our political discourse and decision-making, but it's hard to call something that doesn't involve a politician changing his mind as a result of money "bribery". This mechanism is a systems problem, it seems to me, not a problem with individuals. Now I'm sure this is far from the only thing that's going on. (In particular, I think I remember Lawrence Lessig talking about how money may or may not buy a change of views, but it surely buys access. You pick up the phone for the guy that contributed $LEGAL_LIMIT to your campaign.) Moreover, I haven't ruled out that the money changed their minds---just provided an alternate hypothesis. Nonetheless, this toy model provides a not-totally-implausible explanation for things we observed, without invoking bribery. Edited for style.
- rayiner 13y agoUnless you're willing to move entirely to public financing, which has it's own problems, making aspects of politicking illegal presents a massive separation of powers issue. Imagine if the DOJ could put a Congressman under investigation because some Lockheed-Martin engineer donated some money to his campaign. You should want your legislators more insulated from executive-branch influence, not less. This is, incidentally, also the argument for why insider trading isn't illegal for Congress. It would give the executive branch a huge stick to beat the legislative branch with.
- md224 13y agoI think I want my legislators insulated from money overall. They should not have their chances of election boosted by their cash flow. Of course, this doesn't help the problem of poorer candidates trying to run against candidates who are already wealthy to begin with. But I think it could be a start. There has to be some way to equalize the playing field so that everyone running for office has a voice. Otherwise the democratic process is distorted. Here's a radical idea: what if we outlaw electioneering? No advertising, no campaigns, just structured dissemination of information via debates and perhaps online charts comparing differences in candidate views.
- MartinCron 13y agoAt some point, it becomes impossible to differentiate "electioneering" from political speech, which is a pretty important thing to protect.
- md224 13y agoThis is a very good point and needs to be addressed. Two thoughts: 1) What about differentiating between speech in support of an idea vs. in support of a person running for election? This may be useless though, as it still privileges viewpoints held by wealthier individuals. 2) What about restricting political speech to mediums where reach is (mostly) independent of financial input, such as internet forums and public/private meetings? For example, I can post something on Hacker News about a candidate, but I can't pay to get that posting to #1. This is a more egalitarian platform for the dissemination of ideas.