3 ms·
I find it extremely unfortunate that more of the "democratic" countries are now starting to see China's model of censorship and surveillance of its population a
by mtgx 13y ago
I find it extremely unfortunate that more of the "democratic" countries are now starting to see China's model of censorship and surveillance of its population as something to aspire to.
This is not just a one-off. It's a trend. They all seem to want what the Chinese government has (full control over its population), while still "pretending" it's a democracy and everyone's rights are unharmed.
- smackay 13y agoThere's an unfortunate view in the learned press that business-like governments such as Singapore and China are able to work efficiently and generally get things done and are generally to be admired (though not always publicly). Combine that with the UK Government's Big Sister approach to managing the population and the worst effects of political correctness and you can see where this is all heading - a country safely protected from itself under the watchful gaze of those that know what's best for us - Downton Abbey on a grand scale.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoIt's unfortunate but it's true - China has the advantage that without those pesky elections to worry about it can take a longer term view of things and be planning over a 10 year period, not a 5 year period with re-election and all the populist stuff that requires. Obviously that's only part of the story but the discussion certainly becomes more "interesting" than it did in the 80s when democracy seemed to give better results across the board having the moral and economic high ground. Not for a moment endorsing the Chinese approach, just saying that there is a more interesting debate than there used to be.
- waps 13y agoToo bad that actual planning seems to take a backseat to "my own swiss bank account in 10 years" planning. The same problem "islamic democracies" (or the "islamic republic") or dictatorships have. And then western (and Chinese) companies come in who promise personal kickbacks in trade for contracts. And soon the situation happens that companies who don't do this simply can't get any business at all. China will get killed by it's own politicians much quicker than any western democracy. They're still growing, today it's easy for them because China is growing at 7% per year. It will get hard soon and things will change. Fast.
- Tyrannosaurs 13y agoBecause no Western politician ever made decisions thinking about a non-exec directorship at some point in the future or campaign contributions. Politics is a mucky business full of self interest the world over, let's not pretend that's a problem for China alone.
- w_t_payne 13y agoYou might not always get what you want, but the converse is more frequently true. For example, positions of power and authority tend to be occupied by the sort of person who actively seeks out greater power and authority. In contrast, those with no real desire to dominate and control others neither seek nor achieve power. As a result, our elite political and law enforcement institutions are inevitably dominated by an authoritarian culture and mindset. The authoritarian mind is characterised by a desire to dominate and control others. The more invasive, disruptive and widespread the control, the more satisfying it is to the authoritarian, and the greater the validation of their elite status. Sex; particularly issues of sexual morality; is a tremendously intimate and personal factor. It is this very intimacy that makes the exertion of control over sexual behaviour so very compelling: Control over sexual behaviour is like crack cocaine to the authoritarian mind. Time and time again throughout history, those in power have sought to control the sexual behaviour of their subjects, a motive that is exactly equivalent to the alpha male in the pack controlling access to the harem, and reminding all the beta males of their status by rubbing their noses in their inability to mate. Technology is a lever - it gives increased power to those who wield it. Modern technology is already enabling those in power to gain greater control over their subjects. It is inevitable that technology will embed itself ever more intimately in our lives, and it is inevitable that this technology will be used by the alpha males in our society to exert their domination and suppression over the rest of the population - to mock, to belittle and to abuse those who are not in power. This is a sad, but inevitable truth.
- rmc 13y agoConversely when people in China (or elsewhere) campaign for more liberty and freedom, the Chinese government can point to the USA/UK/EU/etc and say "Look they block things too!". Likewise when UK/EU/USA/etc. tell China to stop blocking things, China turns around and says "But you block things!"