5 ms·
Why haven't they called? If planets are abundant, that puts the kibosh on the "rare Earth" theory, as shaky as that was to begin with. The other explanations a
by Zigurd 13y ago
Why haven't they called?
If planets are abundant, that puts the kibosh on the "rare Earth" theory, as shaky as that was to begin with. The other explanations are less optimistic: Maybe they all nuke themselves or turn to grey goo before they can muster the technology and energy to build a starship. Or they are roasted by random blasts of radiation before they become space-faring.
It's either something universal about civilizations, or something is wrong with the Drake equation or the underlying cosmology.
- Renaud 13y agoOr we've been going at this for way too short a time to be able to draw definite conclusions. There are hundreds of plausible reasons why, if there is life outside, we haven't been contacted. Maybe they know about us but we're not interesting, maybe they don't know about us, maybe they tried to contact us but we haven't been able to detect them, maybe we just don't have the right technology, or we're not looking in the right place, maybe we're all limited by these pesky laws of physics and there is no chance that we could ever meet or even know about each other, maybe they are not looking in the right place and missed us, maybe they are not yet aware of our existence since we've been emitting radio for such a short time, etc
- Zigurd 13y agoAll those objections, have, I think, been factored in and yet the odds should be overwhelmingly in favor of life making itself known. For example "we've been going at this for way too short a time," but we know that millions to billions of stars are billions of years older than the Sun and that millions of those stars have planets. The thing about the scale of the universe is that the odds are always cosmically against "That just hasn't happened yet" being the right answer.
- vidarh 13y ago> The thing about the scale of the universe is that the odds are always cosmically against "That just hasn't happened yet" being the right answer. But there are many other constraints: It may have happened many times, but they may not currently be at a level where we'd be able to communicate. We have only been emitting radio for about hundred years, and only tried to detect others for a few decades. Maybe we evolve to a point where we lose interest in being known and stop "leaking" radio signals all over the place within the next hundred. Then we're not just talking about whether or not it "has happened yet", but our interest in finding others - perhaps that'll only be a hundred year timespan - must intersect with the couple of centuries that such civilizations broadcasts hit earth, and they'd need to be in the regions of sky we've tried to detect signals from. Suddenly there can be vast number of current or past civilisations out there that'd we'd never notice.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoSpace is big. Let's say someone was beaming a very strong signal at us, would we have detected it by now with all our SETI programs? Nope, not very likely we would have. We've only scratched a tiny bit of the search space with SETI, spatially and in wavelength. Similarly, what if an Earth-twin existed in a stellar system within 20 light-years of us, would we have detected it by now? Again, also no. It would take rather a lot of luck for us to have detected it by now, our methods of detecting planets are very limited. It will likely take many more decades before we can confidently have a nearly complete survey of exoplanets near Earth, let alone at greater distances. As far as the Fermi paradox, I never bought it as a paradox. All it says is that we probably don't understand the nature of space-faring technological civilizations, which we clearly don't, nothing more.
- btilly 13y agoDon't talk about planets within 20 light years, we probably haven't even found all of the stars within 20 light years! See http://science.psu.edu/news-and-events/2013-news/Luhman3-2013 http://science.psu.edu/news-and-events/2013-news/Luhman3-201... for proof that we found stars THIS YEAR within 6.5 light years of us. What else is out there? We don't know.
- Balgair 13y agoThere are many reasons: Here are a few: A) The universe is very large. The nearest star is 4 and some change lightyears (ly) away. That means any message take over 8 years to get, process, and transmit to the nearest star. All other stars are further than that. Since we have been weakly radio broadcasting for about 100 years, the number of stars we have been able to speak with is at best 1600 (http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_stars_within_50_light_years_from_earth http://wiki.answers.com/Q/How_many_stars_within_50_light_yea...). B)Messages get lost in noise. We assume that we are heard out in the universe. But it is very very difficult to hear a mosquito at a rock concert 100 miles from you. The reverse is true for us. Also, you have to know to look. The concert has been going on for 100 years but the venue, so to speak, is 4 billion years old. Also, you might be on the other side of the galaxy, or in another one entirely. C)Messages aren't understood as such. Do you know the protocol for USB to serial conversion? (If so I have many questions for you) We may think an actual message is just noise. Or, that noise is a message. We cannot possibly tell. Yes hopefully the other side will start out easy on us but define 'easy' to an alien. D)Lets assume that they have spotted us and are pre-sending signals. In what medium? We haven't even figured out the basic laws of the universe yet. Heck Dark matter is ~25% of the mass-energy of the universe. The other ~75% is some crazy stuff we just labeled Dark Energy. We have no clue what is going on there. They may already be blasting us with data, but we just haven't got the interstellar radio invented yet. E) They simply don't give a shit. What do we have that they want? Lets assume they are about 10,000 years older in tech than we are. Geologically speaking, thats nada, thats the last ice age. People were around then. And look now we have radios and iPads and ISS's and stuff. 10,000 years is a lot of time to think and make stuff. What could we do in that much more time? Well, make a computer that'll calculate just about anything, probably. And if your civilization is all entertained, why bother looking at the stars? Why bother with a,likely, giant telescope array that beams out gibberish for a thousand years. What stuff on Earth over 1000 years old? Not all that much but piles of rocks and some windows. The engineering of a giant thingy is very hard. And all for what? Some algae that you hope turns into a little curious squid or something? F) They dont give a shit. Not because they are hedonistic but because they live under an ice-sheet the planet wide. Or they are at the bottom of a giant cloud where pressure is just right. Or they are frozen periodically in ammonia ice for 700 years. Or they have no idea of math and science because they don't have nerves that work like that. Or because they don't have cells at all. Or because they have no photoreceptors and can't even begin to imagine light. Or because they think that thing we call matter is just a rounding error. Or because they already migrated into dark energy beings and are just waiting to see us. G) We are just plain jane alone.
- spc476 13y agoI'd like to think they're encrypting their communications and thus, it is indistinguishable from random noise.
- GrantS 13y agoAre you talking about this rare earth hypothesis? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_Earth_hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rare_Earth_hypothesis It's been a decade since I read the book but IIRC very little of it had to do with whether lots of planets exist. In fact they assume microbial life is abundant but argue against complex multi-cellular life being very common. It's a fascinating book ("Rare Earth") but even without their arguments, I'm curious: why would one assume that planets equal civilizations?
- kamaal 13y ago>>Why haven't they called? They probably have, or are trying to. But even if they want to, a start system say 2000 light years away looking at us is seeing the world as it was during the time of Jesus. And we are looking at them when they were equally ancient. And not to mention, if they tried to communicate with us we won't know until the next 2000 years. Basically you get the point. For a civilization to communicate to us, they should've started the process of sending signals out x years, based on for x light years far they are. And that's just the first problem. The universe is so big, each galaxy has billions of stars and there are some billions of galaxies in the universe. Given the vastness and size of universe, its next to impossible to search such a large space with already existing limitations of distance and time. Thirdly, we've hardly been listening for a few decades, we might have missed a signal if it was ever sent out or haven't received one.
- jussij 13y ago> Why haven't they called? Here's how far our out going call has gone: http://zidbits.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/how-far-in-space-our-radio-broadcasts-reach1.jpg http://zidbits.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/07/how-far-in-spa...
- Sharlin 13y agoIt seems many people here make the implicit assumption that once there's life, there will be a technological civilization. We do know that microbial life did appear quite soon after the formation of the Earth, so we have some evidence that life can bootstrap itself readily given a favorable environment. However, we also know that life then spent the next three billion years quite content at being unicellular, until the Cambrian Explosion made lots of things happen very quickly (at least on the astronomical timescale). We don't really have much ideas about why the CE happened, and how inevitable it was to happen at some point at least by sheer probability. I believe the shift from unicellular to multicellular life was the most fine-toothed of the Great Filters we've already passed - let us hope there won't be even stricter ones in our future. Given the number of ways it appears a technological civilization could snuff itself out of existence in an eyeblink, I'm not very optimistic.
- sampo 13y ago> We don't really have much ideas about why the CE happened Look at the graph here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_catastrophe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxygen_catastrophe It took 1 Ga from the invention of photosynthesis to grow enough biomass so that photosynthesis started to be a notable process in geological scale. Then it took 0.5 Ga of photosynthesis, when the produced oxygen would dissolve into the oceans, until the oceans were saturated. Atmospheric oxygen remained at 2–4%. Then it tool 1.5 Ga of hard work, when the land surface minerals would be oxidized, until they were all oxidized and finally oxygen started to accumulate in the atmosphere. Then around 600 Ma ago the atmosphere hit above 10% oxygen, and this pretty much coincides with the Cambrian evolutionary explosion.
- Sharlin 13y agoThanks! Hadn't really thought about the connection between the oxygenation and the CE.
- sampo 13y agoIt's not canon. There are lots of theories, but none is widely accepted. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion#Possible_causes_of_the_.E2.80.9Cexplosion.E2.80.9D http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cambrian_explosion#Possible_cau...
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> Why haven't they called? Maybe for the same reason we're not "calling" that much anymore? For the last several decades we've been investing tons of money and engineer-hours to make radio waves stop going up, as we mostly need them on the ground, and we don't have cable or cellular subscribers in space.