5 ms·
Sounds like not "the death of public key encryption" but the golden age of building technical controls into hardware/software which cannot be subverted by the o
by rdl 13y ago
Sounds like not "the death of public key encryption" but the golden age of building technical controls into hardware/software which cannot be subverted by the operator, even in the face of a state agent with a gun.
Assuming the right tech is developed and deployed, this is going to be far better for everyone in a few years. Yes, it will be shitty for a year or two, but by 2020, if we actually have real technical security, it will improve security and trust for end users. Rather than "trust us", it will be "trust us, because...".
- 1337biz 13y agoSituations like these probably rarely produce a real "winner". It is going to be an arms race between those favoring personal privacy and those favoring government snooping. Just keep in mind that government operates basically on an unlimited budget and has access to a wide range of harassment opportunities for non compliance in matters like these. This fact alone will keep them at least at a dead level with potential counter measures.
- rdl 13y agoNo, it's a win because the government is not the only, and in most cases not the worst, threat. Insiders (like Snowden and Manning, ironically) are one of the biggest threats. Being attacked by non-USG outsiders is a major threat ("hackers", state sponsored or not). Your business partners being hacked, or having lax security, is another threat. USG is probably near the bottom of the list of actual threats for most people, in terms of frequency; they just have the most amazing resources. If the "evil NSA boogeyman" is enough to get people to finally care about security, that's great. It's like people preparing for zombies by buying water, freeze dried food, radios, shotguns, etc., when in fact they're at the same time preparing for the far more likely earthquake or civil insurrection.
- ferdo 13y ago> Insiders (like Snowden and Manning, ironically) are one of the biggest threats. They're a threat to those who like running a Surveillance State, not to the average citizen.
- nathan_long 13y agoWhistleblowers are a help to the average citizen, yes, but perhaps the parent poster meant "insiders with their own motives", which might not be benevolent.
- scarecrowbob 13y ago"They" specifically are... generally, the point is that 'insiders' are probably not motivated the same way but have the same access to data which they could leverage against a target.
- rdl 13y agoInsiders are the biggest threat to any organization. Doesn't matter if it is USG and Manning or that Icelandic kid and wiki leaks or whatever. Independent of whether the org is good or evil.
- tlrobinson 13y agoI always assumed "zombie apocalypse" was code for "civil uprising" anyway.
- rdl 13y agoEven in Oakland, I am way more worried about things like an earthquake, blackout, etc than a civil war, though.
- chmodd 13y agoI can think of at least one counterexample, namely the failure of the NSA-promoted key escrow system in 1990s (aka Clipper chip)
- rdl 13y agoAnd removing publicly available software crypto from the most serious export restrictions, at roughly the same time.
- chmodd 13y agoI hope it works out similarly to how proliferation of public wi-fi led to increased adoption of https.
- chris_mahan 13y agoDid you know it is illegal to broadcast encrypted signals on HAM radio? Wonder how long it will take for that to come to the internet.
- chmodd 13y agoI didn't know that! I used to be a member of FidoNet (pre-internet network that provided e-mail and usenet-like services) back in 1990s and any commercial activity and encryption was similarly prohibited - relay operators were even supposed to read their users' mail and delete any messages that violated the rules. I don't think there's any chance of this coming to the internet though. There are just too much uses for encryption besides conspiring for terrorist attacks.
- rdl 13y agoHam radio is a special case, and it is actually the Hams trying to block crypto. There is actually an FCC open rule making issue right now on the issue, and arrl is against it. The solution is to develop protocols which use crypto but use a public key for now.
- chris_mahan 13y agoI saw that. Apparently issue is with self-monitoring. Also, would only be allowed for emergencies.
- dvmmh 13y agoThose things you speak of will be outlawed and you won't be allowed to use them.
- lkrubner 13y agoHarsh. dvmmh made a joke a few days ago and got downvoted to oblivion. But I think this comment is a good one: we do not live in a libertarian paradise. The government is comfortable using its powers, including physical violence under the law, to keep people from doing things it does not want them to do.
- rubinelli 13y agoSadly, that's exactly how things work. We tend to think we can find technical solutions to create legal loopholes, but they usually end up as contempt of court.
- dev1n 13y agoI've recently begun designing such security systems(a few weeks ago). They are quite ugly at the moment and would require entirely new approaches to systems design. I can only hope that more people begin to think like this as it is the best possible evolution in security past things like RSA encryption IMO.
- john_b 13y agoIn terms of hardware safeguards, is it really an improvement when we have to rely on proprietary hardware safeguards that may have government "special features" silently built in, vs open source software that can be inspected by the public?
- rdl 13y agoThe point is to make the hardware itself feasible to verify. There are ways to do this arbitrarily well. Traditional HSMs are a very bad choice for "interesting" users for exactly this reason -- look what Crypto AG did to the Iranian Government and others, and other vs proofed commercial devices.
- coldtea 13y ago>Assuming the right tech is developed and deployed, this is going to be far better for everyone in a few years. A, the old "let's use technology to solve a political issue" idea. Sadly, it does not work. For one, the government has all the technology available for it too, including dedicated, full-time paid researchers. Second, they can outlaw any of those things at whim.
- dlitz 13y agoI think it's important to do both. We can't solve political issues using only technology, but it can also be helpful to build our infrastructure in a way that would make it cost-prohibitive to outlaw these technologies. For example, we could deprecate and eventually disallow TLS ciphersuites that don't provide forward secrecy, just like we did with single-DES, the NULL cipher, and "anonymous" (unauthenticated) encryption modes.
- jlgreco 13y agoThese criticisms of technological solutions always miss the obvious: both approaches complement each other. If I send my aunt a letter, I am assured that unless there is a warrant, my letter to her will not be read by my government. She doesn't live in my country though, and her country gives no such assurances. More-so, even if it did, I would have no particular reason to trust her government. On that note, what if I don't trust my government? Instead of sending her a regular letter, thanks to technology I have the option of mailing her a message encrypted with her PGP public key. Now I have to trust that my government will not beat me with a wrench or compromise my computer to gain access to the pre-encrypted letter (if I posses it), I have to trust her government to not beat her with a wrench or break into her computer, and I have to trust our governments to not outlaw PGP. So which is preferable, finding political solutions to the "my aunt and I are being beaten with wrenches" problem, or finding political solutions to the "my letters are secretly being read without our knowledge" problem? I assert the former is preferable. Beating people with wrenches is a far more extreme action, it is easier to trust governments not to do something that is more extreme. All of the problems with technical solutions are ultimately political problems. You can either abandon all technical solutions and only go for political solutions, or you can find political solutions to the shortcomings to technical solutions. Technical and political solutions complement each other, providing assurances that the other cannot. Both need to be pursued. Don't want the government to read your mail? Encrypt it. Don't want your government to ban that? Lobby your position.
- shoeless 13y agoJust wondering - will older, but still decent hardware, start to become increasingly valuable since the hardware controls don't exist there? Will the value of my circa 2000 Dell PowerEdge take on new life?
- rdl 13y agoI'm looking at ways to do an open source HSM using either trivially auditable/passive components (batteries, wire, wl gore fabric) and old cots components which you could buy from arbitrary sources, or buy a bunch of and inspect destructively.
- MarkHarmon 13y agoMaybe we need a manufacturer to step up and make a line of computers that is open source and contains self auditing features such as checksums for all hardware. There has to be a way to do it. Some of the latest Kickstarter projects that are hardware based would be in a good position to try and pull that off.