4 ms·
I heard on Security Now (twit.tv) that they (among other companies) were asked if they ever provided master keys to US law enforcement, and they refused to repl
by mtgx 13y ago
I heard on Security Now (twit.tv) that they (among other companies) were asked if they ever provided master keys to US law enforcement, and they refused to reply.
- josteink 13y agoTo clarify on that: As far as I read it they refused to reply to the question about them having handed out masterkeys. They did not reply that they refused to hand out masterkeys. This sort of denial is hard to read as anything else than that they have already handed over the keys and aren't allowed to talk about it. It has caused me serious concerns about if I should bother doing a full trial with fastmail, which otherwise seemed like an excellent (although somewhat pricey) replacement for gmail. You can say it has definitely validated my concerns about fastmail using a US-based hosting provider. If I was fastmail I would be extremely busy looking for a reliable hosting partner elsewhere. People looking to jump ship from Google are doing it for one of two reasons: 1. Enough with the Google or 2. Enough with the US spying on everything you do. Stuck with a US datacenter they wont be able to grab near the amount of customers the market is more or less throwing at them right now.
- alfiejohn_ 13y agoPlease see my response to the GP.
- levosmetalo 13y agoMaybe they refused to answer because it's the only option they have if they don't want to lie to their users. Note that US law enforcement actively forbids the company to disclose spying.
- alfiejohn_ 13y agoPlease see my response to the GP and stop the speculation.
- e_proxus 13y agoYou should add clarification to your answer that you work with / own Fastmail.
- alfiejohn_ 13y agoThanks. I've editing my original comment.
- levosmetalo 13y agoThe speculation is only due to lack of information. However, even if you indeed handed the keys to the US government, you will be bound by them not to disclose it, so there's no much point answering either "yes" or "no" as long as you or any of your company assets are in the reach of US government. The same line of thought applies to any company connected with the US in any way, not just to Opera/FastMail. Anyways, thanks for the update.
- chris_mahan 13y agoLack of transparency leads to speculation.
- workhere-io 13y agoAs levosmetalo mentioned, we're forced to speculate when it comes to NSA spying, since companies apparently can be forced to not disclose anything. Which is why I think FastMail should see this as a great opportunity to move all servers to Norway. That would stop the speculation.
- workhere-io 13y agoWhich is why they should break all ties to the US completely. Shouldn't be too hard for an Australian/Norwegian company.
- alfiejohn_ 13y agoWe did not refuse to reply. We have contacted the author to find out who he contacted within the company, because it was the first time we have heard about it! Edit: I work for Opera Software/FastMail.FM