5 ms·
Yes. Since light is effect by gravity, it must have a mass. The increase should however be quite small on the crystal. correction: See below.
by belorn 13y ago
Yes. Since light is effect by gravity, it must have a mass. The increase should however be quite small on the crystal.
correction: See below.
- Zergy 13y agoI thought light was not effected by gravity but by the increased distance it had to travel due to warping effect on time/space caused by gravity?
- belorn 13y agoCorrect. Photons are responding to the curvature in space-time, not directly to the gravitational field. Doing a second check, light has inertia-mass, but not rest-mass.
- hobs 13y agoI was about to say, how else does a solar sail work?
- czr80 13y ago> Photons are responding to the curvature in space-time, not directly to the gravitational field In general relativity, space-time curvature is the gravitational field, so I'm not quite sure what distinction you're trying to draw?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- fargolime 13y agoKeep in mind these descriptions are just interpretations of observations. Another intelligent civilization could explain the observations in a wholly different way. The observations show that light is affected by gravity (more precisely, by centers of gravitational attraction) the same as material objects are. We have alternate generally accepted ways of looking at this, such as the river model of space [1], where space is moving inward toward a center of gravitational attraction, carrying along in its "current" everything including light rays. [1] http://arxiv.org/abs/1204.0419 http://arxiv.org/abs/1204.0419
- ErsatzVerkehr 13y ago> Since light is effect by gravity, it must have a mass Sorry, this is completely false. Light is affected by gravity because gravity is really a curvature of spacetime. * I guess "curvature of spacetime" is perhaps not the most satisfying explanation of why light is redshifted as it moves out of a gravitational potential well (i.e. if you shoot a laser from earth into space). Nonetheless the answer is still "because of relativity".
- czr80 13y agoLight does have mass (it has zero rest mass, but it's always moving at c, and as we know m = E/c^2...)
- ErsatzVerkehr 13y agoI'm not sure this is a useful thing to say.
- masterzora 13y agoUh, E = mc^2 is not the full equation. That is, in fact, a special case for an object with no momentum in a given frame. The actual equation is E^2 = (mc^2)^2 + (pc)^2, where the p is momentum. And, unsurprisingly, the old "p=mv" isn't the whole story, either. The (magnitude of the) momentum of a photon is given by h/λ where h is Planck's constant and λ, of course, is the wavelength. As such, at no point is it necessary for light to have mass and it is believed that, in fact, photons are entirely and truly massless. Relativistic mass--which some take to mean photons actually gain mass--is a confusing and misleading concept that doesn't really have a whole lot to do with actual mass and doesn't really help explain anything. "Effective mass"--which is more related to stopping photons, but not really related to the Einstein equation you gave--also doesn't really mean the photon gains mass but it does mean that interactions within the crystal give effects similar to if the photon had mass.