4 ms·
I believe the authors is confusing correlation and casuation. Do you see any rich hacker belittling the little poor startup guys? I think it is more like the r
by kiba 18y ago
I believe the authors is confusing correlation and casuation.
Do you see any rich hacker belittling the little poor startup guys? I think it is more like the rich, successful hackesr is seen as a community resource. They constantly day in and day out give advices to startup newbies on what to do and how to avoid their mistakes.
It is as if each hackers are expected to face obstacles, learn, and then eventually win.
Maybe the inequality problem is more of a cultural thing. Maybe it is about how we deal with inequality? It is kinda like comparing the immigrants to native Americans.
You know, the Vietnamese are famous for their nail saloon and their beef noodles. The Italians specialize in Italian foods. Indian specialize in computer programming.(Note, not all indians want to be programmer, etc) Certainly the field of computer programming and the arts of nail were there long before those immigrants came to America.
Do people rise up to the challenge and overcome poverty or do people hold your head low and envy the rich?
Edit: I just realize that I am just trying to rationalize away the inequality. However, I am still very worried about the potential solutions to this problem.(Assuming it is indeed, correct.)
I know the effect of the mininum wage laws that was supposed to help the poor have a damaging effect on upward social mobility of the working class.
I am very worried that this capped wage proposal would have undersirable unintended consequences.
Perhap the solution to the inequality problem is to lower barrier of entry to the poor such as reducing government red-tape and regulations allowing people to start up business easier, as well reducing labor regulations to open up jobs that were not previously availiable due to labor cartelization via unions and occupational licensure.
- inerte 18y agoOh, c'mon... these guys are not your average armchair statiticians newbies. One of the authors: "He studied economic history at the London School of Economics before training in epidemiology and is Professor Emeritus at the University of Nottingham Medical School and Honorary Professor at University College London." The other: "Kate Pickett is a Senior Lecturer at the University of York and a National Institute for Health Research Career Scientist. She studied physical anthropology at Cambridge, nutritional sciences at Cornell and epidemiology at Berkeley before spending four years as an Assistant Professor at the University of Chicago." Their board http://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/about/board http://www.equalitytrust.org.uk/about/board : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molly_Scott_Cato http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Molly_Scott_Cato (Phd) http://www.shef.ac.uk/geography/staff/dorling_danny/ http://www.shef.ac.uk/geography/staff/dorling_danny/ - Danny Dorling was educated at The University of Newcastle upon Tyne in Geography, Mathematics and Statistics leading to a PhD in the Visualization of Spatial Social Structure http://www.penguin.co.uk/nf/Author/AuthorPage/0,,1000074828,00.html http://www.penguin.co.uk/nf/Author/AuthorPage/0,,1000074828,... - gained a BA in Oriental Studies at Oxford, received a Harvard MBA before returning to Scotland to manage the family paper mill business, transforming it into a more open company, for which he was given the ‘Scottish Business Achievement Award’ in 1998. His St Andrews PhD was on the subject of employee ownership http://www.uel.ac.uk/ssmcs/staff/rustin-michael.htm http://www.uel.ac.uk/ssmcs/staff/rustin-michael.htm Not saying the book is right, but I'll be damned if we have to teach correlation/causation to these people. edited: The Wikipedia article on "Correlation does not imply causation" cites a "a widely-studied example, (where) numerous epidemiological studies showed". Just a friendly reminder :)
- gaius 18y agoBoth people who've only ever had State jobs, tho'.
- ellyagg 18y agoNevertheless. One issue is that the US probably has a much higher segment of the population that's at least a standard deviation below average in IQ than European nations do. I'd love to see Finland work with our IQ distribution. Low IQ demographics cause a lot of problems.
- euccastro 18y ago"Probably"? Do you have data on that? And if that were true, what explanation do you propose for that? I bet something that affects mental health and criminality rates can have an impact in IQ distribution. Anyway, the study compared 20 different countries, and each state of the USA. Low IQ in the US wouldn't begin to explain their observations.
- lutorm 18y agoIQ scores are affected by education and training, so if the US has lower IQ than European nations (a fact I have no idea if it's true) I would suspect that's because of the differences in education (where education does not just mean school). If you want to suggest there is a big genetic difference in the two populations, I think you're going to need to cite some references there before that's credible.
- bokonist 18y agoThe confusion of correlation with causation is everywhere in the social sciences. The entire profession suffers from the keys and lamppost fallacy. They study intensive mathematics and then they end up trying to attack every problem with regressions, and miss out on the supporting logic that proves causation. How many useful and accurate predictions do you see coming out of economics? Or out of nutrition for that matter? This article is a classic example of confusing correlation with causation. The author simply does not detail a chain of cause and effect. And the correlation she poses, does not explain such facts as why Baltimore was really safe in 1900, and is violent wreck today.
- zouhair 18y agoYou are lucky not to be in Reddit, you would have been downmoded to smithereens.
- vorador 18y agoOn a side note, It's seems that the xkcd strip on "correlation and causation" entered into geek culture.