3 ms·
Serious question: are you stating that the reason we do not see 50,000 deaths per year in the US due to terrorist attacks is because the NSA keeps that from hap
by samstave 13y ago
Serious question: are you stating that the reason we do not see 50,000 deaths per year in the US due to terrorist attacks is because the NSA keeps that from happening?
- sneak 13y agoNope, because 50000 deaths/(50 plots/10 years) is too large of a number. I don't think the NSA prevents significant amounts of American deaths. That means that these programs are all pain for practically zero gain. (And, consequently, ambivalence about them is dangerous poison.) I addressed this question a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062363 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6062363 TL;DR: Most humans, even those enraged at the killing of their families, simply do not want to commit mass murder.
- mpyne 13y agoI think he's trying to pose the question that he thinks his opponents would ask, before they ask it. But AFAICS no one is claiming that terrorism left unchecked would cause 50,000 deaths/yr, so really it's more of a strawman (and in poor taste too, IMHO).
- marshray 13y ago> I think he's trying to pose the question that he thinks his opponents would ask, before they ask it. It's amazing how difficult it is to pull that off successfully, even in discussions with people who know you really well.
- sneak 13y agoNope, trying to illustrate how useless these domestic programs actually are via the socratic method. I welcome sound arguments against my conclusions, though. I admit they're educated guesses.