6 ms·
I am always reminded of a quote from Arthur C. Clarke I was made aware of through Bill Joys "Why the future doesen't need us." http://www.wired.com/wired/archiv
by ThomPete 13y ago
I am always reminded of a quote from Arthur C. Clarke I was made aware of through Bill Joys "Why the future doesen't need us." http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/8.04/joy.html (Still a classic piece)
"Another idea is to erect a series of shields to defend against each of the dangerous technologies. The Strategic Defense Initiative, proposed by the Reagan administration, was an attempt to design such a shield against the threat of a nuclear attack from the Soviet Union. But as Arthur C. Clarke, who was privy to discussions about the project, observed: "Though it might be possible, at vast expense, to construct local defense systems that would 'only' let through a few percent of ballistic missiles, the much touted idea of a national umbrella was nonsense. Luis Alvarez, perhaps the greatest experimental physicist of this century, remarked to me that the advocates of such schemes were 'very bright guys with no common sense.'"
Clarke continued: "Looking into my often cloudy crystal ball, I suspect that a total defense might indeed be possible in a century or so. But the technology involved would produce, as a by-product, weapons so terrible that no one would bother with anything as primitive as ballistic missiles.""
The threat of terrorism is greatly overplayed by various interest groups. I wonder if the accumulated effect of this attempt to oust terrorists is creating more harm than it's hindering.
More people die in a year on the US roads than have died from all terrorist attacks accumulated.
Some of those that died on the roads most probably chose a car instead of the tediousness that is airports.
If the US government truly where interested in hindering terrorists and saving lives, they wouldn't hide the fact that they are eavesdropping, they would make it obvious and transparent, and possible for each individual citizen to know what they know about you.
I just don't get their logic.
- bingaling 13y agoI recently saw bcantrill ranting on that piece in this talk[1] and hadn't looked it up yet. Thanks for the pointer. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=bAHItZ1cSNM&t=2409 https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=bA...
- zzzeek 13y ago> More people die in a year on the US roads than have died from all terrorist attacks accumulated. I'm a little tired of this argument. "Only" 3000 people died in 9/11. Yet look at the effect that 9/11 had on the world, versus 100 times that many automobile deaths. As much as we'd like to think the only bad outcome of a terrorist attack is loss of life, that's not really the biggest outcome. It is the impact on society, like it or not. At the end of the day, terrorism is primarily a tool to affect political situations, their effect on public health situations is not really the point; it is that political damage that is worrying to governments.
- ThomPete 13y agoThat's kind of my point. An overreaction to 9/11 with the added results of increased deaths because of hysteria.
- mikeash 13y ago99.99% of the impact of 9/11 was due to the reaction, not the initial action. Using the vast impact of 9/11 as an argument for further reaction is getting everything backwards. We would have been vastly better off following 9/11 if the government had gone with a "keep calm and carry on" mentality rather than the "everybody panic and start invading things" reaction they actually had. Terrorism is like a bee sting, and our reaction to terror attacks in the US is like an allergic reaction. The difference is that the US has control over its own immune system, and could choose not to be allergic if it wished. That "political damage" is almost all caused by the government, and can't be treated like an independent entity. The excessive impact of terrorism cannot be used to argue that the government needs to pay attention to terrorism, because it is that paying attention which causes the excessive impact in the first place.
- zzzeek 13y agocertainly if politicians felt it was feasible to allow terrorist attacks to occur without mass hysteria resulting, they'd be doing that? Perhaps if all the media in the country were state run, and the government simply suppressed reporting of incidents like that in Boston, they'd be able to contain the hysteria. But as it stands, we have a free press, and on 9/11 as well as in Boston, the government did absolutely nothing in the immediate sense to cause the resulting hysteria; the 24/7 media did that all by themselves. The government's overreaction to all of it was only after the populace collectively freaked out (which you can argue, they could have downplayed, but again the government is extremely politically reactive - which is likely better than them not giving a shit about political opinion); this because they were informed by the media, which itself is an institution resulting from what the populace wants, as the media is a for-profit, market driven entity.
- mikeash 13y ago